Tuesday May 8th, 2012

Sammy Watkins made headlines when a traffic stop led to the discovery of pot and pills in his vehicle.
(Getty Images)

In a Campus Union feature first, the Allstate Police Blotter Item of the Week* is jam-packed with players you've actually heard of, all making bad life choices! (Half of them, anyway, but we'll get to that.) Who'll wrest the lead of most LOLsome police interaction of spring away from Boston College's Jaryd Rudolph?

Cast your vote below for the Allstate Police Blotter Item of the Week:

Case 1: Sammy Watkins (WR/demigod) Clemson

The Incident: A traffic stop led to the discovery of weed and pills and drug charges for the freshman phenom.

The Case For: The possibility that the drugs were planted on Watkins by the Tigers' perpetually intoxicated-looking plush mascot. (Seriously, have you seen that thing's eyes? We would almost rather be dropped into a cage with an actual live tiger.)

The Case Against: Turning the mic over here to Georgia O-lineman Watts Danzler:

Case 2: Tommy Rees (QB) and Carlo Calabrese (LB), Notre Dame

The Incident: Four misdemeanor charges for Rees (battery, resisting arrest, public drunkenness and being underage while in that state) and one disorderly conduct charge for Calabrese, all picked up while cops attempted to break up an off-campus house party.

The Case For: Notre Dame jokes are always easy to come by because of the handy "_____ LIKE A CHAMPION TODAY" template (that and WHERE IS THE CHARACTER EDUCATION IN NOTRE DAME, HOTBED OF SIN??), plus, Rees actually connected with a target!

The Case Against: Only we really can't make jokes about this one, because the target was a police officer, whom Rees reportedly kneed, and that is a really bad idea. Calabrese threatening police with taunts of "My people will get you" is almost too ludicrous to contemplate.

Case 3: Montee Ball (RB), Wisconsin

The Incident: Ball was ticketed by police during a block party for standing on an unauthorized porch. No, for real. That is everything that happened. What in the HELL.

The Case For: As a Heisman finalist, Ball is certainly the most famous player to appear here.

The Case Against: Somebody wrote Ball a ticket for trespassing for being on a porch during a block party. We just cannot get over how sad and dumb that is for all involved.

Case 4: Alex Okafor (DE), Kenny Vaccaro (S), Barrett Matthews (TE), Texas

The Incident: Arrested Sunday night for failure to obey law enforcement.

The Case For: By sheer volume, this is an impressive haul.

The Case Against: But the actual incident rivals Ball's for flimsiness: "Alex Okafor, Kenny Vaccaro and Barrett Matthews were all arrested along with former player Eryon Barnett on a charge of failure to obey after allegedly refusing to leave a pizza parlor late Sunday night."

[polldaddy poll=6209707]
*As ever, the Allstate Police Blotter Item of the Week is not at all sponsored by Allstate in any way. Please don’t come after us, President Palmer. We love the Sugar Bowl.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.