Friday May 9th, 2014

2014 NFL Draft

Plenty of notable figures walked the red carpet at yesterday's NFL draft, from Jadeveon Clowney to Johnny Manziel. But there was one notable absence: Joan Rivers and the rest of her Fashion Police ensemble. Because Extra Mustard takes fashion as seriously as sports, we now present the NFL Draft Grades: Fashion Edition.


Jadeveon Clowney

2014 NFL Draft

It looks like Clowney knew well before the draft that he was going to be holding up a Texans jersey, because that tie was designed to match. The South Carolina-product kept the rest of his accessories sleek and simple, although he does lose points for his tie knot being a little too small (it's also possible that his neck is just gigantic).

Grade: B+

Also on Extra Mustard: Hours Before Being Drafted, Eric Ebron Proposed To His Girlfriend

em-linebreak_cut_v1

Mike Evans

2014 NFL Draft

Like Clowney, Mike Evans really lucked out with his color combinations -- they beautifully offset his new Buccaneers jersey. I like the visual  interest in his shirt and his bravery in mixing patterns between shirt and tie. Unfortunately, Evans loses some serious fashion credibility just by holding up a Bucs jersey, which are easily the ugliest in the NFL.

Grade: C+

em-linebreak_cut_v1

Justin Gilbert

2014 NFL Draft

It was a bold statement for Justin Gilbert to wear such a light-colored suit for an evening event -- and that bold statement paid off. Gilbert looks fresh and ready for spring in his light blue ensemble, and the red accents in his pocket square and tie are crisp and visually interesting. And Gilbert is sporting the most important accessory for any outfit -- a winning smile.

Grade: A

em-linebreak_cut_v1

Jason Verrett

2014 NFL Draft

I wish we had a better photo of Jason Verrett's all-black ensemble, because this understated-yet-elegant look was one of the sleekest of the night. An all-black look is an instant way to class up your outfit, not to mention it's very slimming (although at 5' 10" and 180 lbs, Verret hardly needs the help). Verrett did have a bit of bad luck, though -- the Chargers gave him a navy blue hat, and we all know that mixing black and navy is a big no-no. The suit gets an A, but that hat knocks him down a peg.

Grade: B

em-linebreak_cut_v1

Ha-Ha Clinton-Dix

2014 NFL Draft

The clear winner of the night, Clinton-Dix took fashion risks and had fun with his outfit, which is the most important thing to do. He made a smart choice wearing a conservative black tie with his red smoking jacket -- when you're making a bold statement like that, the other pieces should complement, not distract from it. I also like his choice to go with a silver watch instead of a gold one; with this color combination, gold would be too fancy. Silver keeps it F-U-N fun.

Grade: A+

CJ Mosley

2014 NFL Draft

CJ Mosley is giving us a real mixed bag with this outfit. I love that he's making a bold choice with the patterned bow-tie, but it's looking a little helter-skelter. The ring was a bold move that I think didn't pay off for him, and his pocket square is dipping too far into his pocket. That being said, I'm always happy to see a non-black suit make its way into the sea of traditional mens formal wear.

Grade: C

em-linebreak_cut_v1

Sammy Watkins

2014 NFL Draft

Sammy Watkins kept it simple and classy with his draft-day outfit, and the subtle plaid pattern of his suit made it one of my favorites of the night. However, given the Instagram video he posted yesterday showing off his ice, I was really expecting to see more adventurous choices with his accessories.  For setting up my jewelry expectations and then failing to follow through, he loses substantial fashion credibility.

Grade: C-

em-linebreak_cut_v1

Johnny Manziel

2014 NFL Draft

It was a disappointing night all-around for buzzed-about quarterback Johnny Football (née Manziel). His silver tie clip failed to spruce up an incredibly boring outfit. Manziel was drowning in a sea of navy and all but disappeared into the NFL Draft sign behind him, just like his pocket square disappeared into his pocket.  Total yawn.

Grade: D-

All that being said, I loved Manziel's mani-cam footage:

mani cam


Follow Extra Mustard and Nicole Conlan on Twitter.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.