Dr. Z's Super Bowl Positional Breakdown

Wednesday January 30th, 2008

Dr. Z's Positional Breakdown
How the Patriots and Giants match up for Super Bowl XLII

Special Teams
Neither the Patriots' Stephen Gostkowski nor the Giants Lawrence Tynes has what you'd call a heavy leg. Gostkowski is more consistent from shorter range, but he isn't as good from 40 yards or more. Neither has kicked one 50 yards. Tynes missed two in the fourth quarter against the Packers.
Edge: Even
Both the Pats' Chris Hanson and New York's Jeff Feagles are near the bottom in gross and net average, but Feagles is the master of the coffin corner kick inside the 10. In the warm weather he'll be even better.
Edge: Giants
Giants' Domenik Hixon has the edge over the Patriots, who have done it by committee. In the postseason, New England's punt returner, Wes Welker, has almost doubled the average of New York's R.W. McQuarters. The coverage units for both teams have been pretty decent.
Edge: Even
TOTAL: Giants 1-0-2.
OVERALL TOTAL: Patriots 11-9-5.

Dr. Z's Pick: Giants 24, Patriots 20
Giants' biggest problem will be getting their secondary to match up with New England's multiple wideout attack. Patriots hope that their older LB unit can contain the Giants' running.

Dr. Z's Breakdowns: Offense | Defense

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.