Down
enlarge shrink
All-Star MVP Westbrook and Thunder now look to playoffs
1:58 | NBA
All-Star MVP Westbrook and Thunder now look to playoffs
Monday February 16th, 2015

NEW YORK -- Lots of points, lot of storylines, lots of highlights and lots of unsurprising All-Star Game truisms. The West topped the East 163-158 Sunday night at Madison Square Garden, with a roster better suited for the shot-happy pace, and an angry Russell Westbrook leading the charge. At the end of the night, here’s how all 24 stars graded out:

Western Conference

Russell Westbrook: A

If you had to pick one player to smell blood in the water at an All-Star Game, Westbrook would have been the obvious choice. With 41 points, one short of Wilt Chamberlain’s All-Star record, Westbrook took home MVP honors, led the West to a win and gave the Madison Square Garden crowd something to cheer about (sorry, Carmelo). Though we could have watched him go at it all night, he receives a slight demerit for taking 28 shots in an All-Star Game.

MORE NBA: Westbrook sets a scoring recordWestbrook skies for dunk

James Harden: A-

Harden may not have gotten hot in Saturday’s Three-Point Contest, but he more than made up for it with 29 points, including seven threes, and showcased a well-rounded game with eight assists and eight rebounds. More often than not, it was Harden finding the net when the West needed a basket. Still skeptical on him being a self-proclaimed “great defender,” but in this environment, he gets a pass.

Watch: Stephen Curry sets up a Harden alley-oop with crafty pass

Chris Paul: A-

Though he garnered boos at the end of the game for not feeding the record-chasing Westbrook, Paul came off the bench with a game-high 15 assists, sometimes dominating but mostly sharing the ball with the many weapons around him. Worth noting, he also logged more floor time than anyone else on his team. Not saying Steve Kerr would tire out a divisional rival, but…

LaMarcus Aldridge: B+

Aldridge filled in effectively for injured Anthony Davis, and though he only grabbed two boards, he added 18 points and made all four of his shots from deep. With his unique skill set on display, the Blazers big man managed a significant offensive impact despite the game being predictably dominated by the guards.

DeMarcus Cousins: B

Boogie was his usual self, adding a respectable 14 points and 7 boards and earning Steve Kerr’s trust in the game’s final minutes. He’ll have plenty more All-Star games to improve on that mark. 

Stephen Curry: B

There might have been a slight hangover from Saturday night’s Three-Point Contest win for Curry, who shot just 3-of-10 from three and 6-for-16 overall. Several moments of brilliance, including a whirling flip-shot high off the glass and two spectacular feeds to James Harden for dunks, helped his case.

Marc Gasol: B-

Though the high point of the Gasol-Gasol matchup was the opening tip, Gasol led the West on the glass and stayed active. He’ll get some bragging rights at home.

Dirk Nowitzki: B-

Dirk dunked! Though wasn’t especially effective, an alley-oop finish from Curry had his bench rolling, and everyone struggling to remember the last time he actually got above the rim. After he dusted off Vince Carter’s old throat-slash celebration, the highlight alone was more than enough.

Ned Dishman/NBAE/Getty Images

Damian Lillard: C+

At least he made it into the game. Lillard never really got into the flow of things, adding a few threes but not a lot else. A bit of a point guard pecking order became evident with Paul and Westbrook controlling the ball most of the time in the halfcourt. A narrowly missed one-handed alley-oop almost helped his case.

MORE NBA: See photos of All-Star sneakers, including the D Lillard 1s

Tim Duncan: C+

He only took two shots, and scored once. Duncan probably wouldn’t have minded a family vacation this week. 

Klay Thompson: C

It was a tough night for Thompson, who made just two of 11 field goals. After scoring 37 in one quarter in a real game, his bar was set pretty high Sunday.

Kevin Durant: C-

Durant played the fewest minutes on his team, and despite being banged up, the night was a disappointment. Maybe he just didn't want to have anything to talk about with the media.

Eastern Conference

LeBron James: A

It didn’t take James long at all to get going, with three dunks in the first three minutes and 15 first-quarter points. All of which was a reminder that he’s still the league’s most dominant player when he wants to be, despite the lack of defense. Though he cooled the rest of the game, the pure entertainment value of the James' team-high 30 points and seven assists was exactly what everyone wanted from him.

MORE NBA: Watch James score first points of the game on an alley-oop

Kyle Korver: A-

The game’s top marksman thrived with elite playmakers around him, to the tune of 21 points on seven threes in a fairly typical, yet no less impressive showing. The fact that there’s not much else to say here says a lot.

John Wall: A-

Wall’s chemistry with James got the game off to a roaring start, and the Wizards star added some dunks of his own to showcase his freak athleticism in addition to his always-stellar playmaking. Though we missed him in the dunk contest Saturday night, there was plenty to enjoy here.

Jeff Teague: B+

The first-time All-Star was typically steady, and validated his selection with 14 points in 13 minutes. Get in where you fit in.

Pau Gasol: B

Another night, another double double for Gasol. Though the matchup with his brother was essentially a toss-up, it was that steadiness (and, probably, millions of votes from adoring Spanish fans) that got him here in the first place.

MORE NBA: Gasol brothers make history by being voted as All-Star starters

Chris Bosh: B-

Let’s face it, Bosh’s marquee event is the Shooting Stars competition. But 10 points in 10 minutes ain’t bad.

Al Horford: B-

Horford certainly deserved to be in this game and did his thing, adding eight points and seven rebounds. He proved his quiet, superb consistency plays in any environment (with an emphasis on quiet).

Kyle Lowry: C+

Well, Lowry probably can’t wait for next year’s game in Toronto, where he could have a chance to redeem his 2-of-11 showing from beyond the arc. Eight assists helped a little bit. He’ll have Drake to answer to.

Kyrie Irving: C+

The other elite point guards overshadowed Irving, who was solid but unassertive on his way to 11 points, six rebounds and five assists. Not to worry, he won All-Star MVP last year and has plenty more All-Star Games ahead of him.

Carmelo Anthony: C

Yep, you had to scroll all the way to the bottom of the page to hear from Anthony. This might have been the banged-up Knicks star’s last game at Madison Square Garden for who-knows-how-long, and 6-of-20 from the field and 2-of-13 from behind the arc made for a rather unceremonious potential end to the current chapter of a strange, strange saga. As the game ended, news broke that the Knicks are buying out Amar'e Stoudemire. We know, Knicks fans, we know.

Jimmy Butler: C

Butler gets a bit of a pass for playing with an injured right shoulder. Odds are, he’ll get another crack at the whole All-Star thing before long.

Paul Millsap: C-

Not a whole lot to see here. Don’t worry, the Hawks are still in first place.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.