Soccer America
Wednesday December 2nd, 2009

During MLS Cup week in Seattle, much off-field buzz swirled about a possible Landon Donovan move to Europe, as if the Los Angeles Galaxy captain heading overseas in January during the next European transfer window was not only a foregone conclusion, but the best thing he could do at this point in his career.

Well, why? Another loan move -- as Donovan made last winter to Bayern Munich -- doesn't make much sense at this point without concrete assurances that he'll get playing time in a team, league and system conducive to his abilities and honing them for the World Cup.

For all the furor and hyperbole generated in the press about the January window, most teams are looking for short-term solutions to problems that have arisen since the summer shopping spree or issues that existed at that time and haven't been addressed.

A few major moves arise, but Donovan shouldn't even consider going overseas at this point unless the right team comes in with the right transfer offer. A loan could be just the wrong thing to do if he went to a team in trouble looking for a quick fix and mired in volatility or a club needing a backup.

Stewing on the bench or being hounded by fans desperate for a savior isn't the ideal preparation for a World Cup. Donovan won't improve to any great extent unless he's playing for a top team in a strong league, and his chances of jumping into the starting lineup in those circumstances are slim, even though he's probably the only American field player capable of such a feat. Anything less, and he's better off staying put for the next six months.

If he stays in L.A., he'll train with the national team in January, then report to the Galaxy, play regularly for a coach and a team and a league he knows well and head off to South Africa in late May, after which he can sift through offers when the market is roiling in its quadrennial post-World Cup frenzy. At age 28 (as of next March), at the peak of his powers and with years of top performances pending, if his previous stumbles in Europe don't count against him, he'll find the right fit.

This past season, Donovan played his most consistent soccer in MLS, and shook off much of the complacency on which he had glided for parts of his career. With just two months of league play between the start of the 2010 season and reporting for World Cup duty, he'll make every effort to be as fit and sharp as possible, driven perhaps by missing a penalty kick and losing an MLS Cup for the first time after winning his first MVP award.

Now, MLS has to do something about him sooner, since he's been "grandfathered" the past few years to earn a Designated Player salary even though he doesn't officially carry that designation. However, there's a sneaky way around that; with David Beckham on loan to AC Milan until after the World Cup and not available to the Galaxy, all MLS has to do is deem him "non-eligible," or something similar, and re-classify Donovan as the Galaxy's only "active" DP.

Come July, and the return of Beckham to the Galaxy, if a transfer is imminent, MLS can forego any official procedure regarding Donovan and bid him farewell when the time comes. That's assuming it hasn't already extended his exemption into 2010 and '11, which are the option years on his MLS contract.

In a perfect world, he'd go to the right team in January, play a lot and play well, kick some butt at the World Cup and settle into a lucrative and productive stint with a foreign club. But unless that seems more likely than not, he's best off right where he is.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.