Understanding the Smart fallout, an interview with Jim Boeheim, more

Monday February 10th, 2014

Marcus Smart shoved fan Jeff Orr (center) in the second half of Oklahoma State's loss to Texas Tech.
John Weast/Getty Images

It was an ugly incident that provoked an ugly conversation, but hopefully the worst is behind us. Having been suspended three games for shoving a fan toward the end of Oklahoma State's loss at Texas Tech Saturday night, Marcus Smart faced the cameras on Sunday night, apologized, and promised to do better. The consensus among media and fans seemed to be that Smart spoke well and the Big 12 got the punishment right. Before we (hopefully) move on and enjoy a (hopefully) fabulous stretch run to the end of the college basketball season, here's one final look at the primary takeaways from all that sound and fury.

• Nothing moves the needle like race. A young black man shoves an older white male. One side alleges racial epithets and the other tosses around stupid words like "thug." The stereotypes flowed all too freely, whether it was about college athletes or people who live in Texas. It played out on Twitter, on radio, on television -- everywhere.

Thus were we reminded of what we already knew. Once race is involved, it is no longer a sports story, it's a news story. And everyone chooses sides. It ain't pretty, but it's the world we live in.

A player can never go into the stands to confront a fan physically. Sucks, right? Some yahoo yells the vilest insults your way, and you can't even go up there to knock his block off. Some people tried to defend Smart by drawing an equivalence between him and the fan, Jeff Orr, but the fact is, the player has a higher obligation to abide by the rules of engagement.

Given that Smart is just 19 years old, was frustrated at having to suffer yet another loss and honestly believed that someone called him the N-word, it is understandable that he lost his composure. But that does not make it excusable. You just can't do it. Even he has conceded as much.

Just because you bought a ticket does not give you license to say whatever you want. I'm not here to defend Jeff Orr, but let's be fair: The initial claims that he shouted something racist at Smart appear to have been unfounded. Nobody who was within earshot has said they heard him use that word, and video obtained by the school confirmed Orr's claim that he called Smart a "piece of crap." Should Orr have done that? Of course not. But there is a big difference between calling someone a piece of crap and using the N-word. On that score, Orr got a raw deal.

Having said that, I was quite pleased that video surfaced on Twitter showing Orr, a self-proclaimed "superfan" of Texas Tech hoops, making an obscene gesture and an obnoxious face at an opposing player several years ago. His actions on that video were repulsive, but the real problem is that Orr's behavior has gone unchecked for so long. Indeed, he has been the subject of articles extolling his loyalty to the program. I mean, seriously, what kind of adult calls a college kid a piece of crap anyway? Smart was playing his heart out for Orr's entertainment. And where were the people in that section who should have told Orr to shut his trap? Smart may have crossed the line of acceptable behavior, but he's just a young man. What is the adult's excuse?

My hope is that this incident spurs a badly needed conversation about fan behavior. It doesn't matter the particulars of what was said in this case. We must develop a higher standard of civility in our stadiums and arenas. Unfortunately, as anyone who has been to a game lately can attest, we've got a long way to go.

The referees should have ejected Smart. Technically, this is a gray area. A referee is permitted to call an unsportsmanlike conduct technical if a player incites the crowd. If a player balls his fist and tries to hit an opponent, he is automatically ejected. However, there is nothing in the rule book that explicitly covers a player fighting a fan.

Still, I don't buy the argument the refs did not have jurisdiction to eject Smart. Clearly, they saw him shove the fan. They could have called him for a double technical on the spot and sent him to the locker room. The game was basically over, anyway. If the final determination is that the referees did not have that ability, then that needs to be changed. Call it the Marcus Smart rule if you want, but by all means, get it in the book.

This is why I don't like court storms. If you saw the scene that unfolded after the game ended, then you know why I am so adamantly opposed to the court storming which has become so rampant in college basketball -- and only in college basketball. There is a sacred line between the athletes and the fans that should never be bridged. Smart violated that, but so did the fans who stormed. Yet, we allow and even celebrate these storms all the time.

With all those fans on the court, it was very difficult to get Smart out of there. His blood was running so hot that if any fan went up to him and shouted something he didn't appreciate, there's no telling what could have happened. I hear people say all the time, "They're college kids, let 'em have fun." But there are other college kids I'm worried about, too, and those are the players who just lost a game and aren't happy about it. Setting aside the potential for serious injury, I believe it's only a matter of time before a player takes a swing at a fan who is storming the court. And college hoops will suffer another black eye.

This too shall pass. It's amazing how fast news stories flame out these days. By the time Oklahoma State finished its press conference Sunday night, we were not even 24 hours removed from the incident. Yet, everyone was already exhausted by it. Today, tomorrow, or sometime real soon, someone else who is famous is going to do something stupid, and we'll all move onto the next Twitterized drama. Ain't that America.

For Smart, however, it will be harder to move forward. First, he has to serve his three-game suspension. That's three games spent sitting on the bench in street clothes. Think the TV cameras will find him? Then he'll have to do a round of interviews, which will serve him well because he is thoughtful and well spoken. When he returns to action, that will be another big story (his first game will be against Texas Tech, naturally), and wherever he goes the rest of his life, he will be asked about The Incident. This is Marcus Smart's albatross, and he will carry it forever.

Just because we watch a kid play basketball or interview him a few times, that does not mean we really know him. Until he started unraveling the last few weeks, everything I had heard about Smart indicated he was a man of the utmost character. Maybe those reports weren't quite right, but maybe the current assessments aren't right, either. Only Smart and those closest to him can know for sure.

I hope he does not despair too badly. We live in a forgiving society. Not many of us could have handled this kind of pressure and scrutiny as a sophomore in college. If Smart has anger management issues, he needs to deal with them. If he made mistakes, he needs to learn from them. This has been a trying few weeks, but it's the kind of experience that can make Smart a better player. More importantly, it can make him a better man.

Other Hoop Thoughts

  • Michigan State sophomore guard Gary Harris turned in the best 3-for-20 game I've ever seen during Sunday's loss at Wisconsin. The only reason Harris had to shoot so much was because Keith Appling was out with an injured wrist. Despite his shooting woes (and Wisconsin guard Josh Gasser had much to do with that), Harris still got seven rebounds and three steals, and he made a key jumper late. Yes, he got beat by Traevon Jackson's game-winner, but if you're making a list of guards who play both ends of the floor well, you'd better have Harris right near the top -- even when he's having a bad shooting game.
  • Stop telling me defense wins championships. I see far more teams that are struggling because they can't score. Defense can get you to the Sweet 16, but if you can't score, you ain't going any further.
  • For all of the obsession about freshmen, you'd think people would have discovered Kansas State's Marcus Foster by now. Even his 34-point explosion against Texas on Saturday -- which required just 16 shots and 29 minutes -- was overshadowed by Melvin Ejim's 48-point performance in Iowa State's win over TCU later that night. By the way, don't bother looking for Foster's name on Rivals.com's rankings of the top 150 players in the high school Class of 2013. He's nowhere to be found.
  • I know it's a real small sample size, but Florida freshman forward Chris Walker has played just 11 minutes over two games, and he made four field goals. You think if he got more minutes, he'd get more buckets? Bet we're about to find out.
  • During his first 17 games, Andrew Wiggins did not have a single game in which he shot at least 10 free throws. During his last six games, he has reached that threshold three times. Looks like the kid is starting to figure it out.
  • Pretty surprising that Malcolm Brogdon, not Joe Harris, is the biggest reason Virginia is surging. A lot of people had Harris as a preseason ACC Player of the Year candidate, but Brogdon, a 6-5 sophomore guard, has improved over his freshman season. And yes, Tony Bennett can coach a little bit. But you knew that already.

HAMILTON: Malcolm Brodgon and Virgina are recovering together

  • Please please please watch Saint Louis if you get a chance. It's basketball the way it was meant to be played.
  • You know why I like Memphis? Because it understands its identity and embraces it. It has been a real mystery why the Tigers have struggled to make three-pointers, but they compensate by not shooting too many of them. They took 12 treys against Gonzaga and made four, but they won because they turned into absolute demons on defense during the last six minutes. If Memphis has a hot shooting night at the right time, it can take down anyone.
  • How awesome was that image of Rick Pitino's son sitting next to him at the Minnesota-Indiana game while wearing a chicken suit because he lost a bet? Although I thought it was pretty weak that he took the costume off at halftime. You gotta commit, bro.
  • My favorite stat of the weekend: During Pittsburgh's double-overtime win at home over Virginia Tech, the two teams combined to make one field goal in both overtimes. In a word: oy.
  • Things I never thought I'd type: James Michael McAdoo was 6-for-6 from the foul line in North Carolina's win at Notre Dame on Saturday.
  • Wildest game of the weekend was Oregon at Arizona State on Saturday night. The Sun Devils spotted Oregon a 21-point lead, surrendered every bit of it to trail by two with just under five minutes to go, then escaped with a win courtesy of last-second block by Jordan Bachynski's, his ninth of the game. Bachynski also finished with 26 points and nine rebounds.
  • Yes, Jabari Parker is playing as well as anyone in the country, but a big reason for Duke's improvement the last couple of weeks has been the extended minutes that Rasheed Sulaimon has spent playing point guard. Sulaimon had a terrible first half of the season, but the move has revitalized him.
  • Speaking of Duke, I heard coach Mike Krzyzewski say something interesting recently about statistics. His point was that season-long stats are irrelevant because players get hurt and coaches make adjustments. Therefore, the only numbers that matter are what a team has done during its previous two or three weeks. Just about every scouting report I've ever read organizes stats this way, yet none of the professional stat sites provide that kind of data. Who's gonna get to that first?
  • Next time you want to vent to Twitter or a message board or a radio show that your favorite team's coach should be fired, just consider this: During his first 10 years at San Diego State, Steve Fisher took the Aztecs to the NCAA tournament twice. Both times they lost in the first round.
  • ESPN's otherworldly play-by-play man, Mike Tirico, had some scathing criticism for the behavior of the coaches towards the end of last week's telecast of the Ohio State-Iowa game. I will quote Tirico verbatim because I agreed so much with what he said: "Listen, calls have gone both ways about both coaches, and I understand their anger. Something's got to be done about decorum in college basketball coaches. If these guys want their players to play with poise, their actions on the sideline, and that's all coaches in this league, needs to be better. Candidly, it's childish and embarrassing." Preach it, Michael.
  • On a related note, is it me or is Kevin Ollie's demeanor a lot less calm than it was last season? And I don't mean in a good way.
  • Looks to me like Arizona is going to miss Brandon Ashley even more than we originally thought. It's not just his points and rebounds, it's the effect his departure has on the team's depth.

WINN: What Arizona lost when it lost Brandon Ashley

  • Through 23 games, Tyler Ennis has 130 assists. The next highest totals on Syracuse belong to C.J. Fair and Trevor Cooney, who both have 33. Just making sure you knew.
  • Every time I have a new man-crush, he goes into a slump. First it was Marcus Smart, then Memphis forward Shaq Goodwin. Now it's Michigan's Nik Stauskas, who has shot 5-for-15 (2-for-8 from three) over his last three games. Seems to me like Stauskas is trying too hard to be a facilitator instead of just letting it fly. Remember the wise words of Dr. Seuss: Unslumping yourself is not easily done.
  • I love when one coach calls a time out and the other one comes out of the time out playing a totally different defense. Yet another reason why I don't like coaches calling so many time outs. If were up to me -- and we all know it should be -- they would only get two time outs per game.
  • Even though there are more situations under which the referees can go to the monitor, it seems to me that they are making their decisions more quickly this season. Gotta like that.
  • The Big Ten league office has been sending out weekly updates on the effects of the new emphasis to limit physical defense. The numbers confirm what your eyes are telling you: The changes are working. In conference games, scoring is up by 3.44 points per game. The cost of those extra points is just 1.42 more fouls per game. Well worth it, I'd say.
  • The best all-time chant could be heard when Fly Williams played for Austin Peay. The fans would yell: "The Fly is open. Let's go Peay!"

Continue reading: Five games to watch ... An interview with Jim Boeheim ... Seth's Top 25

Jim Boeheim said he would have never imagined coaching past 60, but now at age 69, he doesn't know when he'll stop.
Lance King/Getty Images

Five Games I'm Psyched To See This Week

Kansas at Kansas State, Monday, 9 p.m., ESPN

This is arguably the most imbalanced major rivalry in college athletics. That's especially true when the teams play in Manhattan, where Kansas has prevailed 28 of the last 30 meetings. As much as I love Marcus Foster, I don't see that trend reversing here, especially now that Andrew Wiggins is attacking the rim with such regularity.

Kansas 82, Kansas State 70

Michigan at Ohio State, Tuesday, 9 p.m., ESPN

Funny how quickly narratives can change. A week ago, the Buckeyes were in a tailspin. Now, it's the Wolverines who are sliding the wrong way, having lost two of their last three, both on the road (at Indiana and Iowa), to fall into a tie with Michigan State for first place in the Big Ten. Guess that means it's time for the narrative to switch once more. I know Ohio State is at home, but John Beilein is one scary dude when he needs to figure out what's wrong with his team.

Michigan 72, Ohio State 66

Oklahoma State at Texas, Tuesday, 7 p.m., ESPN2

It will be interesting to see how the Cowboys play their first game without Marcus Smart. My guess is not all that well, especially considering they are going up against a Texas squad that a) is far bigger in the frontcourt and b) is returning home to regroup after an embarrassing loss at Kansas State.

Texas 80, Oklahoma State 68

Duke at North Carolina, Wednesday, 9 p.m., ESPN

For all the talk about how exciting Syracuse-Duke can become, this is still the best rivalry in college basketball, not to mention all of sports. There's been nothing Jekyll-and-Hyde about North Carolina lately. The Heels have won five in a row and six of their last seven, and you know they will be ready to give Duke their best shot. Still, the Blue Devils are a vastly improved team from a month ago, and that's largely due to the maturity of Jabari Parker, who had career-high 29 points and 16 rebounds in a win at Boston College on Saturday.

Duke 85, North Carolina 77

Syracuse at Pittsburgh, Wednesday, 7 p.m., ESPN

Yes, Syracuse is due to be clipped, as Jim Boeheim acknowledges below. But Pitt, which needed double overtime to escape Virginia Tech at home on Saturday, has been exposed as a mediocre offensive team that does not have the necessary shooters to beat the Orange's zone.

Syracuse 64, Pittsburgh 60

A Few Minutes With ... Syracuse Coach Jim Boeheim

SI.com: Let's start with your freshman point guard, Tyler Ennis. Everyone knew he would be good, but no one knew he was this good. When did you start to realize it?

Boeheim: We played an exhibition tour in Canada last summer against some really good teams. We had one close game, and he took it over. We came from 10 points behind and won. I knew he was pretty good, but that was the first indication that he could be real good.

SI.com: It's odd because he's not that big and not that quick. So what makes him so effective?

Boeheim: He's just calm. Things don't bother him. He has good instincts, so when he sees a play isn't working, he knows he has to make a play. And he gets to the rim. I don't know how, but he's good at that.

SI.com: Do you think he'll turn pro after the season is over?

Boeheim: I don't think so. I think he knows and his father knows that he's a really good college player. He has to become a better shooter and get stronger to go to the next level. He'd go in the first round, but look at the number of first-round picks who are already out of the league in the last two years. It's a huge number.

SI.com: How realistic is it for you to go undefeated?

Boeheim: We're not even thinking about it. We've had some close games. Villanova had us 18 down. Miami had us down, and we pulled it out. We were down against BC, down against Pittsburgh late, down in overtime against Duke. It's very unrealistic to think you could run the table when you've been in so many games that could have gone the other way.

SI.com: I've always thought it's better to have a loss before the NCAA tournament because it's hard enough to win that thing without the added pressure. Do you agree?

Boeheim: I disagree because I think the more pressure you have in the regular season, then you're going to be used to that pressure in the NCAA tournament. Once you get to the tournament the pressure is huge, whether you've lost none or one or two. So I don't buy into that.

SI.com: Your overtime win over Duke was just incredible, especially considering how hyped it was in advance. Is it fun to coach in a game like that?

Boeheim: It's not fun. It's not fun. Your guts are churning, you're trying to make decisions, you're thinking about what play are they doing. It's a continual adjustment. The only thing you say at the end of the day is it's satisfying to be in a game like that, but you don't say that it's fun.

SI.com: What do you think about the new emphasis on limiting physical defense?

Boeheim: It's a great thing. The best thing is the new charge rule, because if you've noticed, people are not trying to take charges. I'd like to see a 24-second shot clock. Twenty-four seconds is enough time to get a good shot, but I don't think they'll go for that.

SI.com: Your former player, Carmelo Anthony, is going to be a free agent this summer. Do you think he'll stay with the Knicks?

Boeheim: He came to New York, he wanted to be in New York. I think he still wants to be in New York, but your legacy now is only on one thing: Did you win a championship? It doesn't seem like he can win one with the Knicks, but where do you go? It's hard.

SI.com: I hear you're into Pilates now. That's very new age of you. How did that come about?

Boeheim: I needed to do something because if I was sitting in a chair, I was having trouble just standing up. I do 55 minutes twice a week, and it's all core. It's not killer, but it's not easy, either. It's helped tremendously.

SI.com: You're 69 years old. Are you going to be like Vin Scully and work until you're 86?

Boeheim: I'd like to say I won't be coaching when I'm 86, but I can't really say that because when I was 50, I said I'll never be coaching when I'm 60. I would say that I feel better than I ever did and the program's in better shape than it's ever been in, but I feel like I am getting closer. I feel that.

This Week's AP Ballot

*(Last week's rank in parentheses)

1. Syracuse (1)
2. Arizona (2)
3. Florida (3)
4. Michigan State (4)
5. Wichita State (5)
6. San Diego State (6)
7. Kansas (7)
8. Duke (10)
9. Villanova (12)
10. Cincinnati (8)
11. Louisville (13)
12. Saint Louis (19)
13. Iowa State (16)
14. Kentucky (15)
15. Iowa (11)
16. Michigan (9)
17. UConn (19)
18. Virginia (21)
19. Memphis (22)
20. Creighton (20)
21. Texas (14)
22. Ohio State (NR)
23. Oklahoma (17)
24. New Mexico (25)
25. SMU (NR)

Dropped out: Pittsburgh (23), Oklahoma State (24)

We're getting late enough in the year that a single game, or even a single week, is going to yield less movement. Sure, Michigan State lost at Wisconsin, but the Spartans were once again down two starters and took a good team to the wire on the road. Yes, Cincinnati got drilled at SMU, but look at the Bearcats' body of work. They're still a top-10 team. Creighton lost at St. John's but kept its spot at No. 20 -- which, mind you, was already eight places lower than where my fellow voters ranked the Bluejays last week.

As for the teams that did drop, there was Iowa, which fell five spots because it lost at home; Michigan, which fell eight spots because it lost twice; and Texas, which dropped six spots because it got embarrassed on the road and was probably a little overrated last week because it happened to catch Kansas on a bad day.

You'll also notice that I've stuck with my limitation on ranking Wichita State no higher than No. 5 and San Diego State no higher than No. 6 because they are not playing the same caliber of competition as the other top-10 schools. However, it is important to understand the difference between rankings and NCAA tournament seeding. A rank is the voter's general opinion of who is better than whom, but the seeds are a reflection of what a team has accomplished -- and therefore earned -- during the season. If the season were to end today, Wichita State should and would be a No. 1 seed. The Aztecs also have an outside chance to get to the one line by virtue of their road win at Kansas, but they would have to run the table from here on out to get there. I wouldn't bet against them.

Meanwhile, I'd like to welcome Larry Brown -- Larry Brown! -- back to the Top 25. I don't know if my fellow voters will see fit to rank the Mustangs as well, but I'm telling you, that win over Cincinnati was no fluke. SMU now has victories over UConn, Memphis and Cincinnati, and it darn near knocked off Virginia on a neutral court back in November. The only fly in the ointment is that the Mustangs have no quality wins away from home, but they'll have some opportunities in the next four weeks to claim some. Last week, they saw their best center, 6-11 Yanick Moreira, return to the lineup after he missed a month because of a knee injury.

You'll notice I dropped Pitt off my ballot even though it did not lose last week. Both of its wins came in overtime against non-NCAA tournament teams in Miami (road) and Virginia Tech (home). That's not something you do if you're one of the 25 best teams in the country. If the Panthers can beat Syracuse at home Wednesday night, they will probably have a number next to their name next week.

As usual, some good teams finished in a tie for 26th. Wisconsin had a good week with wins over Illinois and Michigan State, but given how poorly the Badgers played to that point, I want to give them another week. Their next three games are home against Minnesota, followed by road dates at Michigan and Iowa. So they have some quality chances.

I probably would have ranked Gonzaga had it closed out a win at Memphis. The problem now is that there are no more quality wins left to be had in the West Coast Conference, so the Zags will not likely re-enter my ballot before the start of the NCAA tournament.

It's pretty remarkable that at this late juncture, only one Pac-12 team is on my ballot. Just sayin'.

I might have ranked VCU, but the Rams' loss at Saint Joseph's, which snapped their six-game winning streak, took them out of contention. VCU's conference schedule is ridiculously back-loaded, with an upcoming stretch of four out of five games on the road -- and the home game is against league leader Saint Louis.

North Carolina has sneaked back onto my radar with its most recent winning streak. Last week, I listed the Tar Heels as one of my bubble teams who could make a run in the NCAA tournament. If they beat Duke on Wednesday, the Tar Heels will likely be back on my ballot.

There are three teams sitting atop Conference USA that are worthy of mentioning, but unfortunately, they are not worthy of ranking. Southern Miss and UTEP are 8-1 in the league -- which is remarkable considering UTEP dismissed three players, including its leading scorer, for gambling last month -- and Louisiana Tech is one game behind at 8-2. The problem is that none of those teams can earn quality wins because of the overall weakness of Conference USA, which is going to be a one-bid league. But whichever team emerges from that conference is going to be a tough out in the NCAA tournament.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.