Montreat College was paced by Alonzo Mobley with 21 points, 10 rebounds and four steals. Amir Davis added 11 points.
Presbyterian scored the first six points of the game, but Montreat made it a one-point game on Mobley's 3-pointer with 5:43 in the first half.
The Blue Hose went on a 7-0 spurt and led by six, 38-32 at intermission. Then, a 13-0 run at the start of the second half gave Presbyterian a 19-point cushion and it never looked back.