UCSB did not score in the extra session, missing all five field goal attempts and turning it over six times. Justin Bibbins had six of his 17 points in overtime, all at the line. A.J. Spencer added 11 points and Gabe Levin had 10 for the 49ers (10-12, 4-3 Big West).
The Gauchos' Michael Bryson was fouled by Faust shooting a 3-pointer as time expired in regulation and made three consecutive free throws with 0.6 seconds left to force overtime.