Dr. Roto: FSTA Draft Review (Rounds 5-8)

Dr. Roto

Daily Dr. Roto - Wednesday, June 30

FSTA Draft Review (Rounds 5-8)

Last week in Tampa, I took part in the first Fantasy Baseball experts draft of the season. I will break down the draft here in this review, giving you an explanation of my picks as well as the best (and worst) picks of each round.

Round 5

  • 5.1 Ozzie Albies
  • 5.2 Joey Votto
  • 5.3 Daniel Murphy
  • 5.4 Patrick Corbin (My pick)
  • 5.5 Eugenio Suarez
  • 5.6 James Paxton
  • 5.7 Blake Treinen
  • 5.8 Yasiel Puig
  • 5.9 Jose Berrios
  • 5.10 Edwin Diaz
  • 5.11 Miguel Andujar
  • 5.12 Matt Carpenter
  • 5.13 J.T. Realmuto
  • 5.14 Marcel Ozuna

Round 5 Analysis: In Round 4 I was deciding between Jameson Taillon, James Paxton, and Patrick Corbin, so when I saw that both Paxton and Corbin were available in Round 5, I knew that I was going to take another pitcher. I really think that Paxton is an excellent pitcher, but he has a history of injury troubles and I wonder how he will handle playing in New York. I have none of those questions with Corbin, plus I think his going to Washington from Arizona is a boost to his value.

Best Pick: I have always liked Jose Berrios and when Ray Flowers took him here as his SP1 I think he made a great pick. Berrios has a skill set that could make him a third-round pitcher, so taking him in the fifth round gave Ray a possible anchor for his staff which is not easy to find at this point in the draft.

Worst Pick: It was just a few seasons ago that I used to call Blake Treinen, Blake Train Wreck. Treinen was the first closer off the board in Round 5 and with the volatility at the position, I think it was too much of a gamble here.

Round 6

  • 6.1 Madison Bumgarner
  • 6.2 Justin Upton
  • 6.3 Jack Flaherty
  • 6.4 Wil Myers
  • 6.5 Chris Archer
  • 6.6 Tommy Pham
  • 6.7 Robbie Ray
  • 6.8 Zack Wheeler
  • 6.9 Jonathan Villar
  • 6.10 Nelson Cruz
  • 6.11 Jose Peraza (My pick)
  • 6.12 Gary Sanchez
  • 6.13 Corey Seager
  • 6.14 Josh Donaldson

Round 6 Analysis: When I said the words “Jose Peraza”, Glenn Colton turned to Stacie Stern and gave her a fist bump as they had already decided to take Gary Sanchez with the next pick. Was I wrong to take Peraza? I don’t think so. Speed is incredibly difficult to come by and I think Peraza can help me in average, runs scored, and stolen bases.

Best Pick: If Jonathan Villar had been there when I picked, I would have taken him in a heartbeat. He is etched in stone in the Orioles lineup and he should easily be one of the top stolen base threats in the AL.

Worst Pick: I have been burned so many times by Chris Archer that I think I could start my own burn unit. I love the player, but he must prove to me that he is worth a 6th round pick. Basically, I think this was a case of a pitcher rising in value due to the scarcity of the position.

Round 7

  • 7.1 David Dahl
  • 7.2 Mike Foltynewicz
  • 7.3 Michael Conforto
  • 7.4 Jesus Aguilar (My pick)
  • 7.5 Travis Shaw
  • 7.6 Craig KImbrel
  • 7.7 Matt Chapman
  • 7.8 Matt Olson
  • 7.9 Brian Dozier
  • 7.10 Dee Gordon
  • 7.11 A.J. Pollock
  • 7.12 Mallex Smith
  • 7.13 Aroldis Chapman
  • 7.14 Felipe Vazquez
Image placeholder title

Round 7 Analysis: I was very torn as there were a lot of players on the board that I liked at this point. I knew if I passed on a closer, I would be forced to wait until the lesser closers were available in the later rounds. My choices came down to Aguilar, Olson, and AJ Pollock. I am normally a sucker for Pollock’s power/speed combination but as the saying goes “Fool me once shame on me, fool me ten times, I am an idiot.” So, I went with Aguilar who plays on a great team in a good park, and who should hit 30 HRs in his sleep.

Best Pick: Brian Dozier was on my short list, but I was secretly hoping he would make it back to me in the 8th round. He was injured for most of 2018 and underperformed severely. I think this season we see the old Dozier back who is capable of hitting 25-30 HRs and stealing 15-20 bases.

Worst Pick: I try to avoid one category players whenever possible and I think that Mallex Smith is just that. I look at him as a potential Billy Hamilton-type player which is not a compliment.

Round 8

  • 8.1 Carlos Martinez
  • 8.2 Roberto Osuna
  • 8.3 Brad Hand
  • 8.4 Kenley Jansen
  • 8.5 Luis Castillo
  • 8.6 Kyle Hendricks
  • 8.7 Rasiel Iglesias
  • 8.8 Jose Abreu
  • 8.9 Eddie Rosario
  • 8.10 Edwin Encarnacion
  • 8.11 German Marquez (My pick)
  • 8.12 Mitch Haniger
  • 8.13 Sean Doolittle
  • 8.14 David Price

Round 8 Analysis: This was a tough round for me as I saw many of the players I wanted being taken right before I selected. My pick came down to Marquez and Michael Brantley and luckily as you will see in my next article, Brantley fell to me in Round 9. I know that there is huge risk in taking a Colorado Rockies pitcher, but I could argue that Maarquez was the best pitcher in the game over the last month of the season. If he can build on that success, I might have a fourth ace on my staff.

Best Pick: Jose Abreu is Round 8 is a complete steal. There is no way he should have been on the board at this point in the draft.

Worst Pick: Edwin Encarnacion has been one of the better hitters of the past decade, but at 36 years old I wonder when he is going to start to decline. The Mariners want to trade him badly, so this might be a season where he gets off to a poor start, only to pick it up in the second half when he is playing for a contending team.

Image placeholder title

Want to learn to BEAT THE BOOK? Get the top sports betting information in the industry at Vegas Whispers, the site Las Vegas does not want you to know about!