Should Evgeni Malkin's game-tying goal have counted?

Evgeni Malkin's game-tying goal was a controversial one as he crashed into Maple Leafs goalie Jonathan Bernier. Pittsburgh ended up winning the game in a shootout, but should that goal have even counted?
Publish date:
The Hockey News

The Hockey News

It was all looking so good for the Maple Leafs. A 4-1 lead over the Pittsburgh Penguins after two goals were scored within the first minute of the second period and a 5-3 lead by the time the frame was over. Sure, they had a little hiccup in there, but they bounced back to restore a two-goal lead. Two points seemed to be coming down the pipe.

But then the third period happened.

The most important stat you need to know about the third period is the zero shots Toronto put on the board. Zero. Advanced stats or not, that’s ugly to anybody’s eyes.

James Neal brought the Penguins to within one again in the first five minutes of the third, but the real controversial play came a few minutes later. After Chris Kunitz brought the puck into Toronto’s zone along the boards and threw it towards the net and Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin came crashing into the crease. As the puck went underneath Jonathan Bernier’s pad, Malkin actually shoved the goalie into the net with one move, then the puck with the next. The goal was allowed, which tied the wild game 5-5.

Should it have counted?

The answer, of course, is “Oh My God No!” The NHL has enough goalie interference problems without a player pushing a goaltender into the net and being awarded a goal for it. How is Bernier supposed to play this?

The rulebook is clear as day on this, too, in case you needed convincing. Here is a piece of Rule 69 that applies:

The overriding rationale of this rule is that a goalkeeper should have the ability to move freely within his goal crease without being hindered by the actions of an attacking player. If an attacking player enters the goal crease and, by his actions, impairs the goalkeeper’s ability to defend his goal, and a goal is scored, the goal will be disallowed.

Pretty sure Malkin impaired Bernier's ability to defend his goal, by his actions. It was an inexcusable missed call that directly led to a game-tying goal.

But the Leafs still didn’t get a shot all period and ended up blowing a game they should have won because of disorganized defense. This loss said a lot about the state of the Leafs and showed just how far they have to go to gain the stability of a legitimately threatening team. Without the stellar goaltending they’ve gotten from James Reimer and Bernier this season, Toronto would be intently studying the top-end of the 2014 draft.

Toronto needs help in the defensive zone ASAP. This loss was ugly - and not just because of the officiating blunder.



Why Does the NHL Keep Enabling Tom Wilson?

Wilson's seven-game sentence for boarding is the fifth suspension of his career, but by not penalizing him for what it acknowledges to be a direct blow to the head, the NHL once again is sending the wrong message.

Photo courtesy of True North Sports & Entertainment

Job With Jets a 'Dream Come True' for Linzy Jones

He grew up a die-hard fan of the first incarnation of the Jets, and now, after skyrocketing up the TNSE ladder, he's an integral part of Winnipeg's NHL and AHL clubs.


Canucks Provide Leafs Reminder that the Season is far From Over

After sweeping a surging Edmonton Oilers earlier in their road trip, the struggling Vancouver Canucks provided the Toronto Maple Leafs a gentle reminder that the North Division is far from settled.