Publish date:

Should we have published this photo of Thomas Vanek?

We ran a photo of Thomas Vanek on the contents page of our most recent print edition in which he may have had a tin of chewing tobacco in his pocket. A few pages later, we had an opinion piece that was critical of the use of chew in hockey. Some of our readers thought we made a bad decision in publishing the photo. What do you think?
Author:
The Hockey News

The Hockey News

In the August issue of The Hockey News, in the wake of baseball star Tony Gwynn’s death this past June, columnist Adam Proteau wrote a critical piece about the use of chewing tobacco in hockey. A few pages earlier, in our table of contents, we published an image of Thomas Vanek throwing out the first pitch in a Minnesota Twins game. In the front right pocket of his shorts is the outline of what appears to be a cell phone. In the front left pocket, there’s something shaped like a tin of chew. Apparently, the picture was worth about 10,000 words. We received a high volume of letters to the editor (particularly for July), mostly bemoaning our photo choice. Here's an example:

The article about chewing tobacco in the August, 2014 issue carried a strong message. It really is a shame that so many young men are being drawn into taking up the filthy habit. It's really disappointing though that the same issue features a photo of Thomas Vanek throwing out the first pitch at the Twins game, with a tin of tobacco clearly visible in his pocket. Using this photo is counterproductive when you run an anti-chewing tobacco article six pages later. 

Mike MacLean Cole Harbour, N.S. And this one:

I love the idea of kicking tobacco out of hockey. Obviously it is a health risk and a nasty habit; growing up there was nothing more disgusting than falling into a pile of it (that was spit by my coach). However, something immediately caught my eye in your August edition; on the inside cover Thomas Vanek is throwing the first pitch at a Twins game with what appears to be a tin of dip in his left pocket. Let's hope it's gum, right?

Michael Weinstock Blue Bell, P.A. Our editors noticed the bulge and discussed it briefly. We thought it was likely dip, but could also be gum, mints or candy that come in a similarly shaped container. One reader wondered if it might be a puck. We concluded regardless of the contents of the container, we’d run the photo. If it indeed was chewing tobacco, so be it. It’s reality and could be a stimulant for more debate (like this one). Some of our editors simply thought it was a non-issue. Our question to you: did we make the right call by publishing it? What would you have done? Are you 100 percent convinced it’s chewing tobacco?

The Hockey News

The Hockey News

TOP HEADLINES

Lucas Raymond
Play

Make Way for Red Wings Rookie Lucas Raymond

Lucas Raymond's hot start isn't exactly a surprise for those who've followed his career to date. He's one of the better young players in the game today, and yet another positive piece of Detroit's long-term future.

Alexander Holtz
Play

Prospect Roundup: The Impressive Djurgårdens Pipeline to the NHL

Everyone knows about powerhouse development programs like the London Knights and Chicago Steel. But Djurgårdens in Sweden has proven to be a major stepping stone to the NHL, too.

A3C80C09-C731-4AFE-9407-BDE51E26F282
Play

Maple Leafs Aim to Block Out the Noise against Andersen's Hurricanes

Carolina Hurricanes goaltender Frederik Andersen takes on his former team as the Toronto Maple Leafs look to get back on track.