Why do faceoffs have to be so fair?

Why does a team that causes a delay by stopping play get a 50 per cent chance of regaining possession of the puck?
Publish date:
The Hockey News

The Hockey News

Before technology started shrinking our world and co-mingling cultures in ways we’d never imagined, being Canadian meant being uniquely paradoxical. Quietly patriotic. Fiercely polite. Moderately tolerant. It’s amazing the flag is red and white, and not several shades of grey, just not 50.

The quirkiness extended into our national passion. For the longest time, when two teams battled hard and scored the same number of goals in a contest, we were content, proud even, to reward them both with one point. No winner, no loser. Very Canadian. Even the overtime and shootout format retains the quaint (or infuriating, depending on your perspective) ideal of sending everyone home with something.

And then there’s the faceoff, the subject of frequent derision, especially in the playoffs. While hockey fans everywhere – not just the new breed of Canadians – go postal over the delays at the dots, you know this tradition has its roots in good, old Canuck fairness. Think about it. In what other sport does an offending team get so many second chances?

But that’s precisely what happens in hockey. When a defending team’s goalie freezes a puck, or one of its defenders tips it out of play, his club gets a 50 per cent chance of getting possession back immediately. If an attacking team causes a delay of game by going offside, they, too, get invited to win back the disc right away.

No other sport operates with such benevolence. When the ball goes out of bounds in soccer or basketball, possession goes to the opponent. When a team is flagged for delay of game in football, they are penalized yardage. In baseball, when you hit the ball foul, it’s a strike against you. In hockey, all is forgiven. Instantly.

If we like this about ourselves, then carry on. Just stop jeering linesmen for trying to keep the faceoffs fair. If, however, it gives you pause for thought, perhaps it’s time to reconsider the role of the draw in our game.

The solution? Somehow give immediate possession of the puck to the non-offending team following whistles, without drastically altering how the game is played. Easier said then done, perhaps, but we’ll hand the baton off, very politely, to Brendan Shanahan’s R&D department. Ummm, sorry Brendan.



NHL Power Rankings: Golden All the Way

Vegas is on top thanks to their two-way ace and their veteran goaltender. Where does your team rank?


Q&A: Sportsnet's Breakout Star Analyst Jennifer Botterill

One of hockey's best and busiest studio analysts caught up with the Hockey News to discuss her evolution on Hockey Night in Canada, competing on 'Battle of the Blades' and much more.

Stan Szeto-USA TODAY Sports

'Kirill the Thrill' Has Been Exactly as Advertised

Kaprizov has made the Minnesota Wild a better team in the early days of his NHL career. His arrival took a while, but it's been absolutely worth every second.