Cincinnati Awarded MLS Franchise as Expansion Fees Rise $10 Million per Year
Major League Soccer has introduced Cincinnati as the league’s 26th franchise, with FC Cincinnati (formerly of the USL) set join North America’s top-flight soccer league next season (’19). The team will continue to play at the University of Cincinnati’s Nippert Stadium until a “world class soccer stadium” is ready in ‘21. Nashville (awarded team in December ‘17) and Miami (awarded team in January ‘18) will play their expansion seasons in 2020. MLS plans has plans for two more expansion franchises. Detroit and Sacramento are among the cities expected to receive consideration.
Howie Long-Short: FC Cincinnati (Managing Owner is Carl Linder III, former Reds owner) will privately finance most the team’s proposed 21,000 seat West End stadium (blocks from downtown). The anticipated cost is $212.5 million – the city will chip in $34.8 million and the state has committed $4 million to covering infrastructure costs (think: roads, utility lines).
There’s been no indication that Goldman Sachs (GS) is loaning money to the Linder group, but no financial institution has been more bullish on the North American soccer league than the NY headquartered investment bank. GS has lent league teams upwards of $500 million (LAFC - $180 million, Orlando City - $120 million, D.C. United - $100 million) to build four new stadiums (the 4th team is undisclosed) within the last year. Global head of sports finance Greg Carey cited the overwhelming success of Atlanta’s expansion franchise, league-wide sponsorship deals (see: Adidas), strong local ownership groups (think: Kraft in New England), the league’s target demographic (see: millennials) and a projected rise in media rights fees (current deal expires in ’23) as reasons the investment bank is “willing to commit a significant amount of money to the league and the teams.”
As for Goldman Sachs (GS), the company posted their highest equities trading revenue in 3 years in Q1 ’18 (+38% over trailing quarter to $2.31 billion). Higher fees, market volatility and increased client activity were credited for driving the sharp rise in results. Investing and lending revenue (+43% to $2.09 billion) and underwriting revenue (+27% to $1.21 billion) also contributed to the top and bottom line earnings beat. Shares hit a 5-year high back in March ($275.31) but have steadily declined since; they closed Wednesday at $232.23.
MLS expansion fees are rising +/- $10 million each year. Toronto paid $10 million in 2006. By the time that Portland and Vancouver joined the league in 2012, the league was asking for $40 million/franchise. Minnesota paid a $100 million expansion fee 5 years later (2017) and LAFC was charged an additional $10 million to join the league this year. Cincinnati will pay $150 million.
Fan Marino: Despite all the positives Greg Carey cited, it’s important to point out that MLS continues to face both viewership and attendance struggles; television ratings are flat (+/- 250,000 viewers/game) and attendance is down 6.5% YoY (to 20,683, 86.32% capacity) in 2018. The addition of Cincinnati should help boost league attendance figures, though. The club drew 21,000+ fans/game in 16 home games last season and is averaging nearly 24,000 fans/game this season, more than all but five MLS clubs.
Interested in Sports Business? Sports Finance? Sign-up for our free daily email newsletter list, here!