Bad third-strike call ends a Rays game ... AGAIN, pointing to league-wide epidemic

Publish date:

Fernando Rodney celebrates getting the save after a questionable third-strike call. (Abelimages/Getty Images)

Fernando Rodney gets questionable third-strike call from umpire Dale Scott

Remember back in April when the Rays lost a game on a blown third-strike call by home plate umpire Marty Foster?

Well, the Rays got to see the other side of that coin Tuesday in Toronto night when, in the bottom of the ninth, with the tying run on first base, two outs and the Blue Jays' Melky Caberera at the plate, home plate umpire Dale Scott called pitches 1 and 3 below strikes to give Fernando Rodney a three-pitch strikeout and the save in a 4-3 Rays win.

Image placeholder title

There's a pattern here. It's that both games ended on pitches that were outside to left-handed batters (the graphic above is from the umpire's perspective). I made a mistake in my post on the April game, linked above. I wrote then, Foster had a habit of calling strikes on pitches outside to lefties, but I misunderstood's graphics. It turns out this is a league-wide probem.

Here's a map of the pitches Scott called against lefty batters in Tuesday night's game (again, from the umpire's perspective), with strikes in red and balls in green:

Image placeholder title

The solid black box is the rule book strikezone. I erroneously identified the grey box as Foster's zone in April. It's actually the league-wide zone as applied by all umpires (in BrooksBaseball's words "the strikezones that Umpires generally call" [their emphasis]). As I wrote in April in regards to Foster, that should not be allowed to continue. Umpires should not be allowed to regularly call strikes on pitches a half-foot outside to lefties, but per the above, that's exactly what they are doing. And we've already seen two games (and likely more have gone unnoticed by this blog) end prematurely because of it, never mind how many mid-game rallies have been squashed by bad strike calls within that expanded zone.

Not long after the Foster game, FanGraphs's Dave Cameron dug into the increasing strikeout rates in baseball and found the increase is coming via called strikes, not swinging strikes per this graph: