SI's 2009 MLB Scouting Reports

Toronto <a href=Blue Jays" title="Toronto Blue Jays"/>
SI Prediction: 5th in AL East
Snider will soon be accompanied by other future stars breaking out of the Blue Jays' farm system.
Snider will soon be accompanied by other future stars breaking out of the Blue Jays' farm system.
Winslow Townson/AP
Toronto Blue Jays Manager Cito Gaston
Second Season with Blue Jays
Team Page | 2009 Schedule
Strikeouts by Blue Jays starting pitchers last season, 61 more than any other rotation in the American League. However, 53% of those K's (439) were logged by A.J. Burnett, who signed a free-agent deal with the Yankees over the winter; Dustin McGowan, who will miss at least the first two months of this season with a shoulder injury; and Shaun Marcum, who will miss the entire year with an elbow injury.
The loss of three-fifths of its starting staff -- and subsequent refusal to replace those pitchers through free agency or the trade market -- have the Blue Jays mourning the collapse of what was one of last season's strongest rotations. With significant questions surrounding the 3-4-5 slots, the team should address the lack of depth by turning back the calendar to the 1970s and going to a four-man rotation. Having an ace such as Roy Halladay, among the most efficient pitchers in the game, is essential to this plan. Toronto also has a strong and deep bullpen that includes four effective southpaws, allowing the club to hedge against overworking its starters. Cito Gaston can't get last year's rotation back, but he can improve this year's by sending his best pitchers to the mound more often.
SS Marco Scutaro R 253 .267 7 60 7
2B Aaron Hill R 122 .263 2 20 4
RF Alex Rios R 50 .291 15 79 32
CF Vernon Wells R 97 .300 20 78 4
DH Adam Lind L 188 .282 9 40 2
3B Scott Rolen R 186 .262 11 50 5
1B Lyle Overbay L 220 .270 15 69 1
C Rod Barajas R 262 .249 11 49 0
LF Travis Snider (R) L 181 .301 2 13 0
IF-OF Joe Inglett L-R 288 .297 3 39 9
OF-IF Jose Bautista R 272 .238 15 54 1
RH Roy Halladay 6 20 11 7.5 1.05 2.78
RH Jesse Litsch 85 13 9 5.1 1.23 3.58
RH David Purcey 155 3 6 8.0 1.48 5.54
RH Brad Mills (R) 208 6 3 10.2 1.22
LH Ricky Romero (R) 243 3 3 5.8 1.44 3.38
LH B.J. Ryan 28 2 32 9.0 1.28 2.95
LH Scott Downs 247 0 5 7.3 1.15 1.78
RH Jeremy Accardo 228 0 4 3.7 1.54 6.57

He could have been a server, heeding the come-on posted by the diner across the street from Dunedin Stadium that read REAL MEN WEAR APRONS. Instead, to the delight of hundreds of fans in a queue stretching from the third base line to the centerfield wall, Travis Snider was a signer. So while several of his teammates were dishing out food during a spring training barbecue for season-ticket holders, Snider was satisfying their appetite for his autograph. Only 21, Snider downplayed his popularity with the same humility that has won over coaches and team executives. "We wore name tags," he said sheepishly. "Maybe that helped."

Snider needed no introduction to the Blue Jays' faithful who have been eagerly anticipating his arrival in the heart of the batting order since the 2006 draft, when Toronto took him with the 14th overall pick. Since then the tag affixed to Snider has been CAN'T MISS. And when asked for his early impressions of Snider, hitting coach Gene Tenace said, "You mean Boy Wonder?"

Snider may look young, but he has the bat skills of a mature hitter, drawing comparisons with Nationals slugger Adam Dunn?albeit with the ability to hit for average as well as power. While zooming through three levels of the minor leagues last season, Snider batted .275 (.349 OBP, .480 slugging) with 23 home runs and 91 RBIs. After a late-August call-up to the majors he hit .301 in 24 games and now says that playing in the big leagues was "easier than I thought."

Consider Snider's presence, and surging popularity, a sign of the times in Toronto. Even with holdovers such as centerfielder Vernon Wells and ace Roy Halladay, the emphasis is on the team's future. The next wave of talent, headed by Snider, could be playing prominent roles by midseason. For instance, Opening Day catcher Rod Barajas is merely a placeholder for hard-hitting prospect J.P. Arencibia, a first-round pick in 2007. First baseman David Cooper, infielder Bradley Emaus and a host of decent young starters, led by 24-year-old Ricky Romero and 22-year-old Brett Cecil, are also on the brink of sticking in the majors.

Manager Cito Gaston likens the next generation of Blue Jays to the core of his 1989 team that won the AL East. It's a bold comparison considering the '89 team had a lot of pop. Last year Toronto finished 10th in the American League in batting average, home runs and on-base percentage; 11th in walks, slugging percentage and runs scored; and 12th in hits. No player topped 20 home runs, 80 RBIs or a .500 slugging percentage.

Even so, the offense has fewer question marks than the rotation, which barely resembles the outfit that led the league in ERA in '08. While Halladay remains one of the game's best, injuries to Dustin McGowan and Shaun Marcum have left the Blue Jays with 24-year-old Jesse Litsch as the only reliable arm behind Halladay. During a midseason demotion last year Litsch cut down on throwing his cutter and relied more on a four-seam fastball that made him a more overpowering pitcher down the stretch.

"If not for those injuries we never would have found out about Litsch," says general manager J.P. Ricciardi. Now similar opportunities are available to Cecil and Romero to earn the final two starting spots. But in a division that has three teams capable of winning 95 games, such uncertainty in the rotation is not encouraging. "We're realistic," says Ricciardi with a shrug. But when the G.M. looks beyond this season he can only smile and say, "We're excited."

-- Ted Keith

Issue date: April 6, 2009

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide — from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Grant Wahl, Andy Staples and more — delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.