SI's 2009 MLB Scouting Reports

Cleveland <a href=Indians" title="Cleveland Indians"/>
SI Prediction: 2nd in AL Central
Wood, lights-out for the <a href=Cubs in '08, gives the Tribe its first power closer since Danys Baez held the role in '03." title="Wood, lights-out for the Cubs in '08, gives the Tribe its first power closer since Danys Baez held the role in '03."/>
Wood, lights-out for the Cubs in '08, gives the Tribe its first power closer since Danys Baez held the role in '03.
Brad Mangin/SI
Cleveland Indians Manager Eric Wedge
Seventh season with Indians
Team Page | 2009 Schedule
Strikeouts Fausto Carmona had for every walk he issued last season -- well off his 2.25 K/BB rate in 2007, when he was 19?8 with a 3.06 ERA. His regression in '08 (8?7, 5.44 ERA) might have another explanation: fatigue. During his breakthrough '07 season at age 23, he threw 140 1/3 innings more than he did the previous year, well over the 30-inning leap accepted as the unofficial industry standard for pitchers under 25.
Peak performances by DH Travis Hafner in 2005 and '06, when he was the best hitter in the AL, should not be enough to guarantee him a job in '09. Cleveland suffered last season, largely from a lack of production from Hafner, who ate up 10% of the club's payroll while hitting .197 with five homers and missing more than three months with a shoulder injury. Throw in a mediocre 2007, during which his homer total fell by 18 and his slugging percentage dropped 208 points, and Pronk, 31, looks as if he's in steep decline. The Indians have to pay Hafner $49 million through 2012 whether he hits or not; rather than have him torpedo another season, they should take a long look at rookie Matt LaPorta, the big prize in the CC Sabathia trade with Milwaukee. Like Hafner, LaPorta's game is entirely in his bat, which is major league ready.
CF Grady Sizemore L 6 .268 33 90 38
3B Mark DeRosa R 129 .285 21 87 6
C Victor Martinez S-R 105 .278 2 35 0
DH Travis Hafner L-R 183 .197 5 24 1
SS Jhonny Peralta R 63 .276 23 89 3
RF Shin-Soo Choo L 134 .309 14 66 4
1B Ryan Garko R 117 .273 14 90 0
LF Ben Francisco R 173 .266 15 54 4
2B Asdrubal Cabrera S-R 236 .259 6 47 4
C Kelly Shoppach R 137 .261 21 55 0
IF Jamey Carroll R 297 .277 1 36 7
LH Cliff Lee 9 22 3 6.9 1.11 2.54
RH Fausto Carmona 117 8 7 4.3 1.62 5.44
RH Carl Pavano 182 4 2 3.9 1.49 5.77
LH Scott Lewis 175 4 0 5.6 1.08 2.63
RH Anthony Reyes 128 4 2 4.6 1.27 2.76
RH Kerry Wood 38 5 34 11.4 1.09 3.26
LH Rafael Perez 187 4 2 10.1 1.18 3.54
RH Jensen Lewis 120 0 13 7.1 1.44 3.82

Directly behind the Indians' new spring training complex in Goodyear, Ariz., lies a vast desert field of old, largely dormant aircraft. It's not a pretty sight, but it offers an apt metaphor for a sleek-looking 2008 Indians team that never really got off the ground. Like the smaller planes in the field that on occasion take flight, lefthander Cliff Lee soared from out of nowhere to Cy Young greatness last season; but the bigger carriers, notably catcher Victor Martinez, righthander Fausto Carmona and DH Travis Hafner stalled. Cleveland had a .500 season that was every bit as unexpected as its run to the AL Championship Series in '07.

Last season's underperformance prompted a sell-off of free-agents-to-be CC Sabathia, Casey Blake and Paul Byrd that brought a fleet of shiny prospects in return, including slugging outfielder Matt LaPorta, outfielder Michael Brantley and catcher Carlos Santana, a superb switch-hitting talent who was the talk of camp with his line drive bat and shotgun arm. "This is our best collection of young talent since the '90s," says general manager Mark Shapiro, referring to the era that produced such All-Stars as Albert Belle, Manny Ramirez, Jim Thome and Kenny Lofton.

While the future looks exciting, there is still enough talent to compete now and continue the franchise's trend of 90-plus victories in odd-numbered years (93 in 2005, 96 in '07, as opposed to 78 in '06 and 81 in '08). A bounce-back season by Hafner, who hit .197 in an injury-wrecked 2008, would be a big help. ("With age plus injury, plus shrinkage [of stats]," one G.M. says, "I wouldn't hold my breath.") It's been a year and a half since Hafner has produced like a middle-of-the-order slugger, but, says Shapiro hopefully, "there are not many guys in the history of the game who just dropped off the face of the earth either."

Even if Hafner isn't half of what he once was, there is other offensive firepower, starting with 30-30 leadoff hitter and centerfielder Grady Sizemore. Shortstop Jhonny Peralta had more extra-base hits than Alex Rodriguez did in '08, and rightfielder Shin-Soo Choo, whose 1.038 on-base plus slugging percentage in the second half of the season trailed only superstars Ramirez, Albert Pujols and Mark Teixeira, has the look of a hitting star in the making, especially now that he's learned to hit lefties. Mark DeRosa, obtained from the Cubs in the off-season, has steadily improved as a hitter in each of the last four years and brings valuable versatility to the lineup.

If the offense, which led the majors with 379 runs after the All-Star break, has been enhanced, the bullpen has been upgraded dramatically. New closer Kerry Wood, coming off a dominant season with the Cubs, "brings fear to the other team," says catcher Kelly Shoppach, a contrast to previous closer Joe Borowski, whom Shoppach says admiringly, got by on "nothing." The only question ever regarding Wood is his health. Though he was slowed early in camp by back soreness, Wood says, "My body feels good."

Wood, however, is only part of the bullpen equation. The regressions last season of setup men Rafael Betancourt and Rafael Perez were big reasons why the Tribe had the second-worst bullpen ERA in the majors (5.13). Speaking like a man who's watched his pen swing between excellent and awful for four seasons now, manager Eric Wedge concedes, "We're feeling pretty good right now, but in a month we may be trying to figure it out."

The same goes for a rotation that has Cy Young winner Lee and Carmona, the fourth-place finisher in the '07 vote. But the steep decline of Carmona last year and the extra weight he appeared to be carrying this spring are no less a concern than the rest of the rotation, which includes Yankees washout Carl Pavano as the No. 3 starter.

If the rotation proves to be weak, there is enough positional depth to trade for a pitcher. And with the closer role stabilized, there's reason to believe that the Central's most talented team is ready to take off again.

-- Jon Heyman

Issue date: April 6, 2009

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide — from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Grant Wahl, Andy Staples and more — delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.