SI's 2009 MLB Scouting Reports

Atlanta <a href=Braves" title="Atlanta Braves"/>
SI Prediction: 3rd in NL East
Lowe has pitched no fewer than 182 innings in each of his seven seasons as a full-time starter.
Lowe has pitched no fewer than 182 innings in each of his seven seasons as a full-time starter.
Chuck Solomon/SI
Atlanta BravesManager Bobby Cox
20th season with Braves
Team Page | 2009 Schedule
The Braves' winning percentage (11-30) in one-run games last season, a figure you may never again see in your lifetime. Atlanta's poor record can be partly written off as a statistical anomaly, but a brutal bullpen made a substantial contribution. The pen blew more than 40% of its save chances, and its ERA spiked by nearly three quarters of a point over last season's in a year when the majors' overall ERA dropped by 14 points.
Nostalgia has no place in roster-building, but that's what the Braves are guilty of, having re-signed Tom Glavine -- instead of the more effective John Smoltz -- and named him their No. 5 starter. For three years in a row the future Hall of Fame lefty has seen his ERA rise (to 5.54 with Atlanta in an injury-interrupted 2008) and his K-to-walk ratio decline (just under 1 to 1). The 43-year-old Glavine isn't Jamie Moyer; he's run out of steam, and with the Braves capable of challenging the Phillies and the Mets in the NL East, they have to use their best players according to current value, not career value. Righthander Jorge Campillo is healthy, 30 years old and coming off a season in which he struck out 2.8 batters for every one he walked. Campillo deserves that last rotation slot.
2BKelly JohnsonL-R156.287126911
SSYunel EscobarR132.28810602
3BChipper jonesS-R33.36422754
CBrian McCann L-R37.30123875
LFGarret Anderson L114.29315847
RFJeff Francoeur R130.23911710
1BCasey KotchmanL151.27214742
CFJordan Schafer (R)L197.269105112
OFMatt DiazR274.2442144
IFOmar Infante R305.2933400
OFGregor BlancoL268.25113813
RH Derek Lowe5714116.31.133.24
RH Javier Vazquez7712168.61.324.67
RH Jair Jurrjens6413106.61.373.68
RH Kenshin Kawakami (R) 88958.61.062.30
LH Tom Glavine196245.31.645.54
LH Mike Gonzalez7301411.81.194.28
RH Rafael Soriano1390310.31.142.57
RH Peter Moylan289017.91.061.59

When the Braves' front office gathered last fall to plan for the coming season, they identified several starting pitchers and a couple of hitters to go after. To the chagrin of general manager Frank Wren, their pursuit of them would play out in a very public manner.

Among the headlines in newspapers and across the blogosphere were these: report: JAKE PEAVY TO THE ATLANTA BRAVES; BRAVES EXPECTING TO INK FURCAL; BRAVES AWAIT DECISION FROM A.J.; and GRIFFEY WILL PLAY FOR BRAVES. Of course, no one in that group -- frontline starters A.J. Burnett and Jake Peavy, shortstop Rafael Furcal and outfielder Ken Griffey Jr. -- will be calling Turner Field home this year. "I don't think it ever helps to have anything public," says Wren.

The Braves players' hopes rose and fell with each rumor. While vacationing in Italy with his wife, Lauren, second baseman Kelly Johnson received an e-mail from a friend excitedly detailing the Peavy reports. "The news always finds you," says Johnson. "I got pretty excited about Peavy. It was one of those deals that, if it happened, was going to [reshape] the team."

The moves that will instead define Atlanta's '09 season generated fewer bytes: Wren's trade with the White Sox for starter Javier Vazquez and lefthanded reliever Boone Logan, and the signings of Derek Lowe and Japanese starter Kenshin Kawakami -- the latter acquisitions overshadowed by John Smoltz's stunning departure the week before.

The Braves Way has always emphasized starting pitching. In the team's glory days -- from 1991 through 2005 -- their starters were durable and dominant, their ERA in the majors' top three all but two years. But times have changed. Rarely has "innings-eater" been such a coveted commodity for this club. Consider last year's injury and performance woes: Seven Braves started at least 13 games; 11 started at least four; only one threw 160 innings. "It was real important that we [get] guys who not only had good stuff but also had a history of being durable," Wren says.

Lowe, since becoming a full-time starter in 2002, has not thrown fewer than 182 2/3 innings. For the last nine seasons Vazquez has averaged 216.0 innings. Kawakami won the equivalent of the Cy Young in Japan's Central League in '04 and has never had a major arm injury. The rotation's most productive holdover is second-year righty Jair Jurrjens (a 3.68 ERA in 188 1/3 innings).

The deal breaker in the Peavy negotiations was San Diego's demand for Tommy Hanson, a 22-year-old, 6' 6" righthander with command of four pitches, including a fastball that reached 99 mph in his first spring outing and a slider that's been compared with Smoltz's. The MVP of the Arizona Fall League -- he was 5-0 with a 0.63 ERA and 49 strikeouts in 28 2/3 innings -- Hanson is the Braves' top-ranked prospect (No. 4 overall) of their five in Baseball America's Top 100.

Pitching will be especially important, as this lineup will not outslug anyone. All eight regular position players should hit at least 10 homers, but there's no bopper who'll smack more than 25. "We may not have the best 3-4-5 combo in all of baseball," says rightfielder Jeff Francoeur, "but our 6-7-8 is going to be a lot better than most other teams'."

True, but a few more homers would be nice. Atlanta's outfield slugged just 27 home runs in '08; the other 15 NL outfields averaged 66. Francoeur is the wild card, a perfect blend of tantalizing potential and maddening inconsistency. Last year he had just 11 home runs and 71 RBIs after averaging 24 and 104 the two previous seasons. Newly signed leftfielder Garret Anderson should be more productive than Griffey would have been, and Chipper Jones expects to bear more of the power burden after winning last year's batting title with a .364 average but only 47 extra-base hits, the fewest of his career.

As the Braves wait for their prospects to mature, Wren can only hope that he's plugged his holes and that the old adage is true: Sometimes the best deals are the ones you don't make.

-- Joe Lemire

Issue date: April 6, 2009

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.