Moment of Truth: Will There Be Baseball in 2020?

Chris Halicke

On March 27, Major League Baseball and the Players Association (MLBPA) agreed on a few key economic issues amid the coronavirus shutdown. Advances on player salaries and service time highlighted the agreement, and while still many other issues remain in flux, the players union got some form of protection if the worst-case scenario played out.

Of course, that scenario would be no baseball played in 2020. Advances worth $170 million give Major League players some form of income for 2020 and gaining whatever service time they accrued in 2019 helps players get closer to that goal of free agency, even without playing an inning this year.

Good. The last thing MLB needs right now is giving fans any reminder of 1994. Everyone's money, even the minor leaguers (kind of), is taken care of. Now, about that thing called the regular season. 

According to a report by ESPN's Jeff Passan, there are three conditions in the agreement that could seriously affect the pulse of the regular season:

  • There are no bans on mass gatherings that would prohibit play in front of fans. 
  • There are no travel restrictions in the United States and Canada.
  • Medical experts determine that there would be no health risks for players, staff or fans, with the commissioners and players union still able to revisit the idea of playing in empty stadiums.

The Centers for Disease Control & Prevention (CDC) currently has a recommendation in place, prohibiting mass gatherings of 50 or more people in place through May 10. If the spread of the novel coronavirus hasn't improved by then, that date could very well be pushed back. 

On Saturday, President Donald Trump held a conference call with commissioners and top executives from 12 professional sports leagues. On the call, President Trump said he hopes to have fans in stadiums by August and September. While that perfectly lines up with the beginning of the NFL season, it could seriously affect the start of the MLB season or the resumption of the NBA, NHL, or MLS seasons. 

On a positive note for the survival of the MLB season, MLBPA executive director Tony Clark told USA Today Sports that the players are "very open" to playing in empty stadiums.

That brings us to the bottom line: If MLB is going to have a season in 2020, there will have to be games in empty stadiums for at least a portion of the season. The best-case scenario seemed to be a start in June, but now the trend from MLB leaders seem to have July 4 as a possible target for Opening Day. Any start in August would surely put the conclusion of the World Series some time in December, which is where things begin to get a little fuzzy.

“We would play as long as we possibly could,’’ Tony Clark told USA Today Sports. “Obviously, the weather becomes a challenge the later you get in the calendar year, but we would do our best to play as many as possible regardless of when we start.

In order for the baseball season to go that deep into the calendar year, neutral sites would certainly have to be a part of any agreement between MLB and the MLBPA. Eight of the 30 ballparks in Major League Baseball have a permanent or retractable roof, making them ideal locations for neutral site games.

  • Rogers Centre (Toronto, ON, Canada)
  • Marlins Park (Miami, FL)
  • Tropicana Field (St. Petersburg, FL)
  • Globe Life Field (Arlington, TX)
  • Minute Maid Park (Houston, TX)
  • Miller Park (Milwaukee, WI)
  • Chase Field (Phoenix, AZ)
  • T-Mobile Park (Seattle, WA)

According to The Athletic's Ken Rosenthal, MLB is considering quarantining teams and playing games in empty stadiums in Arizona and Florida, where Major League clubs play their spring training games. It's not a be-all end-all for MLB, but they have to consider all options if they are to save their season.

Unless both MLB and the MLBPA can come to an ironclad agreement to play in both empty stadiums and neutral sites, there won't be baseball in 2020. Period. Not to rain on any optimist's parade, but it's time we really look at this realistically. If there is baseball in 2020, it's going to look a lot different, even if it is just temporary. 

If there is a season, the game of baseball will be drastically impacted this year. Expanded rosters, empty stadiums, neutral sites, games played around Thanksgiving, possible uptick in player injuries – all of these and more are just symptoms of a regular season forcibly played amid a pandemic. Not to mention, how badly will a shortened offseason affect the 2021 season?

Even if all goes well and MLB and the MLBPA take every step necessary to salvage the season, it could all be out of their hands. If the spread of COVID-19 worsens, baseball could do everything right and still have no baseball played in 2020.

Unfortunately, that's a reality we all need to embrace.

Do you think baseball will be played in 2020? Leave your opinion in the comments below.

Follow Inside The Rangers on SI on Twitter: @SITexasRangers
Like Inside The Rangers on SI on Facebook:
Follow our Rangers insider Chris Halicke on Twitter: @ChrisHalicke

Click the "follow" button in the top right corner to join the conversation on Inside The Rangers on SI. Access and comment on featured stories and start your own conversations and post external links on our community page.

Comments (4)
No. 1-1
Joe G 2020
Joe G 2020

I think players are being a bit selfish and close-minded when they state that baseball without fans in the stadium is not baseball. First, this pandemic is most likely adversely impacting the average american much more seriously (unemployment, economically) than most, if not all, baseball players. Second, I suspect that most fans generally cannot even ever get to a live game with no pandemic(location, travel, COST) and rely completely on electronic game transmissions to watch. Third, this country needs the All American game now more than ever. Fourth, your fans will definitely be with you, you just won't be able to hear or see them (do you really need that narcissistic rush all the time). Fifth, during these uncertain and scary times we have all had to step up our game and help where we can, players should be no different, and I might add, should be expected to do more from their pedestals. Sixth, I love this game and have so for over 50 years. We need real baseball.
Please be safe and do the right thing. Follow expert guidelines. But, don't let an empty stadium, if that is all it comes down to, be the reason to let us all down.


3 Replies


Thank you for getting this comment thread started with a fairly succinct, well-reasoned and level-headed post.

I think you're absolutely right, though from the MLBPA's statement it sounds like they won't make a fuss about it at least as a collective voice. My fear, which is reflected in the article's last paragraph, is that ultimately it may not matter if the players are willing to play in empty stadiums.


I’m curious... just how many games does the average fan go to in a year? I’d say one, if even that at all. So to get all worked up about the season starting in parks with no fans should be welcomed, as opposed to know baseball at all. Get the season started as soon as it is safe for the players to do so. When it’s safe for large public gatherings, then open up the doors. Listen, I go to about 30 games a year, so it’s killing me that I can’t get to a game yet; however, if I have a choice between watching a game on tv with no fans in the stands or no baseball at all, well, my choice is rather simple- play the games!!


Dont they remember during their teens, sometime the audience was just their parents: