A morning commute—in a truck, not a car—to the Raiders facility reveals much about the Oakland quarterback on the eve of his biggest NFL test yet. Plus reader mail, including a possible offseason trade for the Bears

By Peter King
December 07, 2016

DANVILLE, Calif. — It’s pitch black in this cool East Bay ’burb just after 5 a.m. Tuesday, and the Oakland Raiders’ 25-year-old MVP candidate rolls into a coffee shop parking lot in his pickup truck with the child seats in back. Derek Carr is polite, but in a bit of a rush. You’d think the rush is because of the short week, as the Raiders prepare to play a crucial game against Kansas City on Thursday night in middle America. But leaving the house at 5:10 for the 40-minute ride to work is customary for this player who burns to be great for a long time. 

“This is every day,” Carr says, hands deep in his pockets on a 41-degree morning.

I’ll take you with us on Carr’s drive to work Thursday night on the NBC “Football Night in Kansas City” pregame show, which begins at 7:30 p.m. ET, before the game for AFC West supremacy between the 10-2 Raiders and 9-3 Chiefs. (That’s my other job, working for NBC on the football show.) I think you’ll be engaged. America doesn’t really know Carr yet, and I hope you have a better feel for him after seeing this TV piece. And not just for the football—he is on pace for 4,501 yards and 32 touchdowns, and is completing 66 percent of his passes—but for the kind of person he is. So I urge you to watch.

Derek Carr says excellence off the field is as important to him as Raiders success.
Courtesy NBC

What I found interesting—and what I think will come out on TV—is his attention to detail in other parts of his life. For instance, I asked him where he got his drive for excellence.

“Probably my parents,” he said, steering his pickup on an already-crowded Interstate 580 with the early rush-hour traffic. “When they raised me, they laid a foundation for me obviously with my faith, and they showed me the kind of man they wanted me to be. My dad showed me every day the kind of man he wanted me to be … and now I get to show my boys what it’s like to actually be a man, to actually deal with things. How you treat your wife, that’s excellence to me. Football is a game, and my character will rub off on my work ethic and the weight room and the film study and all those things, but when it comes down to excellence, I think about it off the field. I want people to think of my life, I want people to watch this and see me and know that’s who I am. 

• BUCKET LIST—GREEN BAY: The MMQB is embedded in the land of Lambeau this week, telling stories about the NFL’s most tightly knit community

“I’m not putting on a show. I’m gonna go out and be the same person, and if I do that, I don’t have to have a good memory. I don’t have to remember what I said to anybody. Excellence … Showing my boys what it means to be a man, showing them what it means to love your wife, what it means to serve people that you don’t even know, what it means to see someone on the side of the road and stop and help them because that’s just the right thing to do. That’s the kind of stuff that I think [makes up] excellence.”

Heady stuff for 5 in the morning. Carr would be just fine with living his life in a Cal Ripken way, being great on the field and off. Right now, he’s running the most explosive, quick-strike offense in football, and the most fun to watch. A few other thoughts from our 40 minutes in the car that you won’t see Thursday night:

• On handling the pressure of a very big game like this one: “For us, coach [Jack] Del Rio has done such a great job of teaching us how to make every game the same. You treat every game like a big game and then when the big games come, it’s just normal for you.”

• On playing with his dislocated throwing pinky: “There's nothing that holds me back. Obviously there’s still pain in it, which is normal because of the swelling and all those things, but you know, that doesn’t hinder me at all. I’m able to grab the football, I’m able to throw it, so that’s all that matters.”

• On whether he thinks his brother David’s lack of great success after being the top pick in 2002 affected his own draft stock in 2014 (Derek Carr was the 35th overall pick): “As much respect as I have for the league, I hope not. You know, because that’s pretty ignorant to me. We’re two completely different people, two completely different situations. … You’d have to ask the other teams. I know that Oakland didn’t feel that way, I know that [GM] Reggie McKenzie didn’t feel that way, and I think that is what fired me up the most is when they would talk about that situation, they thought it was the biggest positive ever. Because they’re like. ‘You’ve already been in the NFL for 12 years, you’ve already seen it, you’ve already experienced the highs the lows, all the experience that you’ve gained is nothing but good. And when they said that, I was like, I want to go here so bad.

Derek Carr has played like an MVP candidate this season, ranking in the top seven in passing yards, touchdowns and passer rating.
Lachlan Cunningham/Getty Images

• On his explosive offense: “In this league, separation is a hard thing to come by from a receiver and a corner, it just is. And the more I can get the ball to them quicker while that separation is still good, that's what [offensive coordinator Bill] Musgrave always tells me: Get it to him while the getting’s good.”

• On playing against Kansas City safety Eric Berry, and watching him run back an interception for a touchdown and a missed two-point conversion for a 2-point play Sunday in his hometown, Atlanta: “It's amazing. It’s remarkable, to know that that’s where had his treatments, for his cancer … to know that that’s where he’s from … to see what he’s been able to do. This game, like I said, is way bigger than football. For him to just inspire people, to bring hope to people who may be going through the same thing. Maybe they’re not going to go catch pick-sixes or pick-twos after they’re done, but they can go do something amazing with their lives. I think it’s just a tremendous thing, and I hope that that story blesses people.”

• THE FINE FIFTEEN: Where do the Raiders rank on Jenny Vrentas’ list? 

• On the key to beating Kansas City: “Protect the football. No one has to do anything superhuman. No one has to go out there and think they need to make a superhero play.”

It’s tough for stars to stay hidden for very long in the NFL. This league mints new stars annually, almost monthly. I walked away from my time with Carr thinking he’s going to be a face of the NFL for a long time.

And now for your email...

* * *

Matt Barkley has been a pleasant surprise in an otherwise lousy season for the Bears.
Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images


Peter, does Matt Barkley's play in two games make it even more likely Jay Cutler will be elsewhere next year? Obviously the defensive competition hasn't been the best, but has he shown enough that Chicago can trust him to be the backup or even compete with Hoyer for the starting role next year? Assuming the Bears draft a QB next year, how do you think this plays out?

—Mark L., Muscatine, Iowa

Great question, Mark. Hard to answer it without seeing Chicago’s last four games, which are against four playoff contenders. Specifically, I want to see Barkley’s poise against the onslaught of Detroit’s resurgent pass rush this week, and Minnesota’s stifling rush in Week 17. Both of those are on the road. If Barkley is competitive in those two games plus the two home games (against Green Bay and Washington), obviously that changes everything. In any case, I can’t envision Cutler being back for big money. I’d draft a quarterback if I were GM Ryan Pace, and develop him in 2017 with a vet like Barkley or Hoyer holding the fort.

Actually, you know what I think would be interesting, and what I would do if I were Pace? I’d offer my first-round pick to New England for Jimmy Garoppolo and a third-round pick. It would be tough for Bill Belichick to turn down a top-five pick for Garoppolo. Very tough. But I’d do it if I were Pace—unless he liked any of the quarterbacks in the draft more than Garoppolo. The only barometer I’d use if I were Pace is not price tag, but rather whether I thought the Patriots’ backup was good enough to be his quarterback of the future. In that case, make the deal.

• THE PLAYOFFS ARE COMING: In Monday Morning QB, Peter King breaks down the postseason races by division and makes his predictions


I see a lot of people mad about Jeff Fisher getting a new contract. I see it this way: The Rams are in a lame-duck status until the new stadium is built. The stadium is going to be completed for the 2019 season. Fisher's contract is over at the end of the 2018 season. I believe that keeping an average coach on board, letting Jared Goff develop, and recovering from their trade to get Goff sets up for a really splashy inaugural season of a new stadium. I believe the Rams will bring in a big name like Sean Payton in 2019, have a developed quarterback, and will really make a splash in the new stadium and make the playoffs.  

—Daniel R., Wasilla, Alaska

Hard to see into 2019, Daniel. I think the point that’s being missed about the Fisher deal is this: It’s basically a $7 million or $8 million golden parachute for an owner paying $2 billion to build the prettiest stadium in the United States in the glitziest city in the United States, instead of making Fisher coach the last year of his contract as a lame duck in a season in which the Rams were surely at a big disadvantage. If the Rams stink it up down the stretch and finish 5-11 or 4-12, Stan Kroenke has the right to dump Fisher for one guaranteed year of pay—which I believe is likely in that scenario. Now, if the Rams had extended Fisher for three guaranteed years, that would have been silly. But one guaranteed year, knowing he might not coach it if the team went in the toilet this year? Not such a bad option.


Imagine an NFL game in which one team kicks 10 field goals, scoring 30 points and the other team scores five touchdowns, scoring 35 points. After the game, the “losing” team declares that they really won the game because they scored 10 times while the other team only scored five times. Of course, that’s completely false because the rules of the game don’t count number of times scoring, they count the final score. And teams base their entire game plan and in-game strategy on the rules as they existed before the game was played. The absurdity of the losing team's claim is right up there with your “analysis” of the Electoral College. Trump and Clinton played according to rules that have existed since George Washington ran for his first term—and both candidates based their game plan and their strategy on the fact that they had to win 270 electoral votes, not win the popular vote. But now the losing team is trying to say it really won; all you have to do is change the rules after the game has been played! Now maybe you’re not saying this. Maybe your point is that the rules should be changed before we play the next game. That’s fine, but you should know that those in politics who are talking like this don’t care what the rules are, they just want to undermine Trump’s presidency by suggesting he won the election by a technicality. Trump did win in a landslide. There were 51 elections run on Nov. 8 and Trump won 30 of them.

—Steve M., Essex, Vt.

All I said was Trump trumpeting winning the election in a landslide when he lost the popular vote by 2.5 million votes is comical. Nothing else.   

• THE MMQB HOLIDAY GIFT GUIDE: Dominic Bonvissuto runs down ideas for NFL fans, from playbook pint glasses to football leather watch bands


I read the large portion about Henry Burris and the Grey Cup in your column Monday. I can’t tell you how much I enjoyed that part. I am a huge NFL fan. I was born and raised in Ottawa but have always gravitated more toward the NFL game. But as with everyone in this city I have always been a fan of our football team (when we’ve had one) and with the Redblacks when they came back into the league. Your piece was so heartwarming to read. How great a city Ottawa is, how great a capital city it is. How great our country is and how free we are. We are as neighbors always directly linked and compared. We share a lot of values and similarities, but it’s our differences that make us great and original. Thank you for writing to that point, and thank you for giving this fan a big smile about his city, his team and who he chooses to read every Monday.

—Mike G.

In two phone conversations with Henry Burris totaling maybe 80 minutes, it was difficult to not come away with strong and positive feelings for him and his career and his attitude about life. I have a soft spot for Canada. My wife and I took a 35th anniversary train trip across the Canadian Rockies last year; I went to two CFL games to open the 2014 season (Jenny Vrentas to a third) and loved it … the spirit, the love of the game and franchises, the fun of the wide field and the different rules. And Henry Burris illustrates, to me, why athletes play the games they play. He loves football, and he’s forever thankful to the country that adopted him for the chance to build a career and a family.


In hockey, the backup goalie plays about 15-20 games in an 82 game season. Why don’t NFL teams with a QB in his mid- to late 30s consider giving that QB a rest against inferior teams? If Jimmy Garoppolo were to play against Cleveland and Jacksonville, the Pats would likely win, and Brady’s body would be theoretically fresher later in the year and playoffs, wouldn’t it? It would also give the backup some valuable snaps in the event the starter gets hurt.

—Joe A.

Question for you: What happens the first time the Patriots, sitting Tom Brady, lose to a team everyone assumes they’d beat? And what happens when the Chargers sit Philip Rivers and lose to anyone? Howling would ensue.


I was really bummed when Fitz didn’t get mentioned in your article. He’s now third all-time in receptions and 10th all-time in receiving yards. What makes this so impressive is that these numbers came while playing in Arizona with some of the, shall we say, less than average QBs that have ever played the position. Also of note is that Carson Palmer passed Dan Fouts for career passing yards, and that David Johnson is quietly putting up huge numbers with, to put it nicely, a not Dallas O-Line. Fitz and Palmer are talking him up as the MVP, but he’s not getting any respect in the national media, which is a shame.

—Dusty T.

File this one under the “I should have written about Fitzgerald this week” error section. He joins a long list of people I’ve ignored when they do great things. David Johnson too. I plan to give them their due before the end of the year.

• Question or comment? Email us at talkback@themmqb.com

You May Like

Eagle (-2)
Birdie (-1)
Bogey (+1)
Double Bogey (+2)