Rice, Jackson, Owens among notables for Week 5 med check

Saturday October 9th, 2010

There's a ton of injuries that will affect a lot of fantasy teams this week as players continue to go down at what seems like a rapid pace. The thing is, they're not. It's a similar pattern to what we've seen the past couple years, with time and names conflating to make it seem that it's more. Things that are closer appear bigger and it works that way with time -- what just happened seems more important than the faded memories of 2009 -- and with stars -- we notice a lot more when Tom Brady is injured than when some backup corner gets injured. There're plenty of real injuries, so there's no need to inflate anything around this issue. Lets get to them here (and on Twitter):

UPGRADE: Ray Rice DOWNGRADE: Knowshon Moreno

The Broncos still haven't been able to get past the hamstring issues of Knowshon Moreno. Despite conservative care, Moreno's legs simply aren't responding to the rest and treatment of his pair of Grade II strains. This isn't so much a slow-healing issue as it is one of trying to get everything right in order to not be back at square one a week after he finally gets into games. There's not only a balance between the right and the left legs that has to be dealt with, but also a balance between the strength of the hamstrings at the back of the leg and the quadriceps at the front. One doctor I spoke with compared it to NASCAR, adjusting the air pressure at a pit stop to try and fix the handling. It will be at least one more week, perhaps two, before we get to see how Moreno handles. For the Ravens, they have a series of minor injuries. Ray Rice was forced into action last week after LeRon McClain and Willis McGahee couldn't go, but Rice didn't cause any further problems with his knee. Amazing what wearing a pad over a knee can do for its safety. McClain is expected to go, though his shoulder is still problematic. It's the same issue for Todd Heap -- a shoulder sprain -- but he'll go as well.

UPGRADE: Matt Cassel, Joseph Addai DOWNGRADE: Austin Collie

Only seventeen players on this week's OIR for the Colts, so things are looking up! Or not, since it's key players who are being added to the report. The RB situation is, again, problematic, forcing the team to add some depth from the practice squad. Joseph Addai practiced all week without limitation, which makes the questionable tag a bit confusing. It looks as if he's going to play normally, but have a backup ready. Donald Brown won't be ready, having missed another week of practice. He's also questionable, which means it's 50/50 -- one will play and one won't. I don't think that math is going to make the NFL feel very good. The WR situation is a bit better. Reggie Wayne will play despite a minor knee issue and so should Pierre Garcon (hamstring) and Austin Collie (foot). The latter are both GTDs, but Garcon practiced more and appears to be the more likely to see targets. There's some significant issues on the defensive side as well. The loss of Melvin Bullitt for the season puts more focus on the rest of the defensive backfield, so GTDs with Jerraud Powers and Antoine Bethea will be key. It looks like both should play, but the speed of the Chiefs could really come into play. The Chiefs come into Indianapolis healthy and undefeated, a combination that goes together by design.

UPDATES (11:40 a.m.): Collie is active, though there's no clarity on how much he'll play. Sources say Garcon is still the better play.

The Colts defensive backfield has no depth, with only one strong safety on the active roster.

UPGRADE: Ryan Torain DOWNGRADE: none

Most of the issues for the Packers are on the defensive side. Nick Barnett had a second opinion on his wrist injury, which will need surgery. The question now is whether the surgery has to be done now, ending his season, or whether it can wait until after the season. Barnett's wrist isn't that similar to Brian Urlacher's, an injury I've seen it compared to time and again. The wrist is a complex of small bones, ligaments, and tendons that is very difficult to reconstruct properly, and loses function and can cause massive pain with only a small problem. Cullen Jenkins (hand) and Charles Woodson (toe) should play, much as they have, but there's not a lot of depth. With Ryan Torain taking over for Clinton Portis, who'll be out longer than the six weeks the 'Skins are selling now, there could be some openings. Beyond Portis, the injuries for the 'Skins are minor and the same ones they've been dealing with. Trent Williams is the one that's a bit more important, but Donovan McNabb has been able to adjust without his big tackle.

UPGRADE: Steven Jackson, Sam Bradford DOWNGRADE: none

This game is no longer for the No. 1 pick, though both teams know there's a long way to go before there's real playoff implications to the matchup. Both teams have pretty extensive injury lists, but the key players are mostly healthy. Steven Jackson showed his groin is healthy enough to play effectively, though it was clear it was on his mind. That long run he broke off was as much about holding back a bit as it was breaking free. The Rams should get Laurent Robinson back, but it's unclear how much he'll be in the mix in the Rams' offense. For the Lions, they're still without Matthew Stafford for another few weeks, leaving them to rely on Jahvid Best. Best, like Jackson, played well through injury and should do the same this week. Tony Scheffler had a concussion last week. While he came back to practice on Friday, he's a GTD at best. Brandon Pettigrew has been getting more and more of the TE targets. That pattern should continue. Both defenses have a lot of bumps and dings, so this could end up more of an offensive shootout than many expect.

UPDATE (10:40 a.m.): Best will play, but expect similar results from last week as he continues to fight turf toe.


The Bills come in to this week's game healthy and down one RB. Marshawn Lynch has gone west, but there's still not much clarity on who gets the carries. The Bills appear to be easing C.J. Spiller into the NFL this season, so expect Fred Jackson to get more touches, but for Spiller to get enough chances to be a decent fantasy option. His long term health is the bigger question. The Jags have their RB1 in Maurice Jones-Drew and his minor ankle sprain isn't going to change that. He'll get his normal touches this week. The team doesn't have any other significant injuries.

UPGRADE: Jonathan Stewart DOWNGRADE: none

The Bears are smartly keeping Jay Cutler (concussion) out of this week's game, despite being cleared to practice. The "second impact" is often a bigger issue, in addition to all the other problems a concussion can bring. There's just no way to protect a QB from that possibility, as clearly illustrated a couple years back by Trent Green. The Bears' protection problems are what started this and they seem loathe to expose Cutler to more punishment until he's a bit more distant from the initial injury. He should be back for Week 6. Todd Collins will be the one standing in. Even he didn't make it through last week unscathed, he'll play through some neck soreness. Carolina will be without star Steve Smith (ankle), leaving their WR corps very thin. DeAngelo Williams missed practice with an illness, but should play. The lack of targets is going to shift the offense to the run, which means they'll need Williams.

UPGRADE: Terrell Owens DOWNGRADE: none

Can a hit be dirty without being illegal? I'm not sure what T.J. Ward was thinking when he went headhunting on Jordan Shipley last week, but I know that Ward's hit has Shipley on the sideline for Week 5 while Ward will be playing against Atlanta. Sure, he's a bit lighter in the wallet, but NFL players don't take those fines seriously, even when they get into the Bentley bucks. Ward's job is to hit. He was drafted because he was a big hitter. Highlight shows love big hits. And I have no problem with big hits. I do have a problem with hits targeted at the head, which is what Ward did. He went for the knockout blow and got it. That simply can't be tolerated in an NFL that's still coming to terms with the implications of head injuries. Chad Ochocinco should get his normal targets, though last week's bias on targets toward Terrell Owens is likely to happen again. Ochocinco's groin isn't quite 100% yet, but there was no indication in practice that it's not very close. On the Bucs side, they have their normal concerns for Kellen Winslow. His chronic knee issues aren't going away, but they have a pretty good understanding on how to get him ready each week.

UPGRADE: Michael Turner DOWNGRADE: none

The Browns have a lot of question marks. Jake Delhomme (ankle) is again a GTD, but there was more indication during practice that he's ready. The reps were split down the middle between Delhomme and Seneca Wallace. I'm not sure Delhomme, even if he starts, will be effective, so avoid him unless you're stuck. Peyton Hillis has a mild quad strain, but was protected this week in practice so that he could go. The question is not will he play but will he play at 100% or could the quad tighten up more? The Browns could use Jerome Harrison a bit more this week regardless. At WR, both Josh Cribbs and Brian Robiskie should play, though neither is an ideal fantasy play unless you get credit for return yardage (Cribbs). They're also banged up on the defensive side, with Shaun Rogers and Robaire Smith listed as questionable. That should open up some holes for the Falcons running game. The Falcons might get Michael Jenkins back this week, but he's at best the third option behind Roddy White and Tony Gonzalez, so don't look for much there.

UPDATE (10:40 a.m.): Hillis will start and get normal carries.

UPDATE: (11:40 a.m.): Wallace gets the start, but Delhomme is active as the No. 2.

UPGRADE: Kevin Boss, Kevin Walter DOWNGRADE: Andre Johnson

Houston will approach Week 5 the same way it did Week 4: lots of decisions to make just before game time, which makes it tough on fantasy players. Andre Johnson is a lot closer to playing this week than last, but it's still unclear how much he can do on an ankle that's still very tender. Jacoby Jones (calf) is also hurt, leaving Kevin Walter and Owen Daniels to soak up the targets. The defense has a lot of dings, but none that should really change their game plan. One injury that's going under the radar is the rib injury to Derrick Ward. With Arian Foster still in Gary Kubiak's doghouse, Ward stood to get some more carries this week, but those will now go to Steve Slaton. The Giants come into Week 5 with some RB questions. Ahmad Bradshaw's ankle sprain didn't slow him down in practice this week, so despite the designation on the OIR, don't panic and don't think that Bradshaw will be losing any of his touches. He won't have Madison Hedgecock in front of him, but Brandon Jacobs, despite some early week rumors, won't be taking that role. Instead, it seems like the Giants will be following the trend of shifting some of their running offense and pass protection to quick passes, giving Eli Manning more chances. Manning's gotten the scouting report from his brother, who attacked the Houston linebackers with lots of option routes. Kevin Boss isn't Dallas Clark, but he should get a lot of looks. On defense, the Giants will have Osi Umenyiora, but will not have Mathias Kiwanuka or Keith Bulluck.

UPDATE (10:40 a.m.): Johnson is expected to play, but he's not a great fantasy play with bad ankle.

UPDATE: (11:40 a.m.): Jones is inactive and Johnson active, as expected.

UPGRADE: Ladell Betts, Beanie Wells DOWNGRADE: Larry Fitzgerald

The Saints win the award this week for most players on the OIR with 19. Most will play, though any injury is going to limit players somewhat. Drew Brees' knee sprain didn't seem to bother him and the idea that any QB would be on the field without knee braces is just silly in 2010. Jeremy Shockey's the same. It's at RB, where Pierre Thomas is out again and Chris Ivory still isn't 100% where there's some offensive worry. Ladell Betts is really the only healthy back. We should continue to see Lance Moore taking on Reggie Bush's role in the passing game, where he's excelled so far. There's a ton of issues on defense, mostly with the passing game. Will Smith is a GTD and will be slowed by a groin strain if he plays. Almost everyone in the defensive backfield has something going on. Tracy Porter (knee) is out for a couple weeks following surgery and there are depth issues at SS. No one seems sure if this is good news for Max Hall in his first start or good news for the Saints, in that they're not facing some passing surgeon like Brees who could find the weaknesses. Hall, for his part, has Larry Fitzgerald to throw to, but that's about it. Both Early Doucet and Steve Breaston are out, leaving the Saints to shade coverage even more to Fitzgerald. Beanie Wells might see more carries if they try to transfer the offense and slow the game down to help Hall.


While there are some big names - or at least names you'd recognize - on the OIR for both teams this week, there's really nothing significant here. Dez Bryant is still the WR3. Justin Gage is the same or less. Only Kyle Kosier's struggles seem to have any effect on the line play for both the running and passing game, with sources telling me he's looked much better this week and should play.

UPGRADE: Philip Rivers, Michael Bush DOWNGRADE: Ryan Mathews

The Chargers continued to limit Ryan Mathews in practice, indicating there's still some lingering issues with his ankle. It won't keep him out but expect similar touches to last week (nine for 55 yards, plus one reception.) That goes the same for Mike Tolbert (16 carries) in probably the same proportion. The Raiders are just stricken this week with injuries. Darren McFadden is out with another hamstring strain, leaving those touches to Michael Bush, who seems completely recovered from thumb surgery. Zach Miller (hip pointer) should play. The defense is so thin, any injury on the field this week could force the team to start shuffling players out of position. Facing Philip Rivers without depth is going to be a hard task, so upgrade Rivers and his targets this week.

SI Apps
We've Got Apps Too
Get expert analysis, unrivaled access, and the award-winning storytelling only SI can provide - from Peter King, Tom Verducci, Lee Jenkins, Seth Davis, and more - delivered straight to you, along with up-to-the-minute news and live scores.