5 Bones to Pick With Drew Lock Skeptics

Chad Jensen

If you espouse optimism in Drew Lock and assert any sort of confidence that the Denver Broncos have finally found their franchise quarterback, you’re bound to get push-back. The national perspective likes to point to Lock’s five-game sample size as a reason to warrant caution.

Some of those same pundits want to pump the brakes on the excitement around Lock only to then profess a preference for the first-round quarterbacks taken in the 2020 NFL Draft, none of whom have played a single snap yet in the pros and thus, have no sample size.

The truth is, we have a vast sample size with which to analyze Lock. He was a four-year starter in the SEC after all.

Some act as if we learned absolutely nothing from Lock’s five-game debut last season. Like he didn’t move the needle at all from the day he was drafted in the second round by the Broncos.

What emerges more often than not is a bias people try to protect and hide. There were a lot of NFL media who panned Lock as a 2019 draft prospect and didn’t view him as a first-round caliber quarterback.

Those same people, in light of Lock out-performing so many of his quarterback brethren from the 2019 class, would rather double-down on their skepticism of his talents rather than eat a little crow and admit they were wrong. It isn’t difficult to pick out those types.

Even now, a large swath of you reading this article are clinging to the ‘but it was only five games!’ refrain. Let me tell you why your misgivings are unfounded and give you five reasons to fully embrace the excitement you feel for Lock, all of which will help if you encounter a Lock skeptics in the wild. They're out there. 

1. He's a Winner

There is such a thing as quality over quantity. In five starts, Lock went 4-1. For contrast, Kyler Murray started all 16 games as a rookie. He flashed at times and showed growth. But the best he could muster was a winning percentage of .313. Atrocious.

Daniel Jones in New York started 12 games but his winning percentage was even worse than Murray's at a god-awful .250. What about Minshew mania? Gardner Minshew at least at the tenacity to produce a .500 winning percentage in 12 starts for Jacksonville. Dwayne Haskins produced a paltry .285 winning percentage and struggled mightily to elevate a Redskins' roster facing a dearth of talent.

Meanwhile, Lock's winning percentage was the best among all rookie QBs last year — .800. It's absolutely crucial to point out that unlike any of his fellow 2019 rookie signal-callers, Lock's impact translated to the win column.

Don’t give me the ‘level of competition’ argument. If you want to argue that Lock benefited from having to face the Detroit Lions and Oakland Raiders to close out the season, then you also have to deduct points from the Offensive Rookie of the Year, who was given a last-place schedule and opened the 2019 season with a middle-of-the-road strength of schedule.

What’s good for the goose is good for the gander. NFL quarterbacks can only play the schedule they’re given. Lock beat two feisty Division rivals, the eventual AFC South-champion Houston Texans, and a really bad Lions squad, while losing to the Kansas City Chiefs in one of the worst ‘conditions’ games the Broncos have played in the last decade.

In each of Lock’s four victories, he found different ways to win. That distinction is one of the reasons fans should be so excited about him.

2. Production 

Lock finished with 1,020 passing yards, a completion percentage of 64.1 and a TD-to-INT ratio of 7-to-3. Extrapolate those numbers over the course of an entire season and Lock was on pace to produce 3,264 passing yards, 22 touchdowns and about 10 picks.

Transcendent numbers? No. More than solid for a rookie? You bet your hindquarters, especially in light of Lock playing for a first-time coordinator who was fired following the season, as well as a first-time quarterbacks coach.

With Pat Shurmur stepping in as offensive coordinator and Mike Shula as his new position coach, imagine what Lock could accomplish in Year 2, especially in the spread system, which, let's just say, is very comfortable for him.

3. Leadership 

One of the most pleasantly surprising aspects of Lock’s rookie debut was how quickly he commanded the respect of his teammates. For veterans, most rookies, even quarterbacks, are best seen not heard. Lock played that role while he was Joe Flacco’s backup and on injured reserve.

But when the time came for Lock to step into the starter’s role, he dispensed with that meek posture and let his swagger and intensity hang out. It helped that he got results. The Broncos had only won three games all season when Lock stepped in with five games left to go. The team would finish 7-9.

Just last week, Justin Simmons said this about the ‘It’ factor Lock possesses and why the veteran safety is so excited about 2020.

"That's probably the thing I'm most excited about for this season," Simmons told Bleacher Report. "I know everyone says it, but he has—even in the locker room, behind the cameras and closed doors—he has this sense of, like, confidence but it's not cocky. It's just like 'watch and follow me' type of swag. That's just something that I've felt like the previous couple of years we've been there we just might not have had. Not even getting into the systems and all that stuff. But I haven't really felt that, I guess. I'm excited for Drew because he closed off the year on the right foot and I'm excited for him to start out the year, especially with the weapons that he has. I'm just excited." 

No matter who you ask in the Broncos locker room, bring up Lock’s name and you’ll get a smile. Lock has united a locker room that had spent the better part of the last four years literally in the doldrums. Not only has Lock given fans hope, his own teammates can’t help but feel confident and optimistic about what the future holds. Lock’s leadership style is effective, his swagger contagious.

What happens next for the Broncos? Don't miss out on any news and analysis! Take a second and sign up for our free newsletter and get breaking Broncos news delivered to your inbox daily!

4. Football Intelligence Quotient

Perhaps because he played in a different scheme each year at Missouri, not many draftniks talked about his football IQ heading into the 2019 draft. However, despite utilizing the very wristband that garnered him the ‘Buzz Lightyear’ moniker from his teammates, everything about Lock’s rookie campaign spoke to his football intelligence.

Think back to Game 3 of the preseason. That version of Lock that looked a tad overwhelmed and pressing, compared to even the Week 13 version where he showed such poise, couldn’t have been more different. That was one of the disguised blessings he got from spending 11 weeks on IR.

It allowed him to learn and assimilate not just the playbook but life as a pro without the immediate demands of performing on gameday. During his 11-week exile, Lock went through each Broncos practice twice per day using the team’s virtual reality program and watched each session from the sideline.

As a result, he was able to hit the ground running when his number finally got called in Week 13. Are we talking about the second coming of Peyton Manning here? No. But if 2019 proved anything, it’s that Lock’s football intelligence quotient it considerable. Listen to Coach Shurmur who spoke about this very issue just last month. 

"I think he's got good football sense," Shurmur said. "He understands concepts, so when you talk about it—even though you're not watching him do it—you can watch the film and 'What would you do here based on this look? What is this look? Is it corner-cushion? Safety rotation? Linebacker location?' All the things that you need to see and talk about, he can talk about with great comfort. So that's the starting point." 

For a coach who’s yet to get hands on his starting quarterback thanks to a pandemic, that’s got to be comforting. It’s also worth mentioning that, unlike the last highly-drafted Broncos quarterback, football is Lock’s top priority. Nothing takes precedent over the game and his career, which is square one for every prospective franchise-caliber quarterback.

5. The Eye Test

I could go on and present more statistics or turn to advanced analytics to support my take here but at the end of the day, you already know the truth, even if you have some lingering doubts. As a Broncos fan and as a fan of the game, you know when you see a good quarterback.

The eye test is just as important as the other factors I’ve listed here today. You don’t need a degree from MIT and you don’t need to be a graduate of the Scouting Academy in order to recognize a good player when you see one.

Bottom Line

I could go through a pros and cons list from Lock’s Mile High Huddle scouting report on Lock but like you, I know what I saw; a very talented, surprisingly competent, strong-armed quarterback with intangible traits on the same level as his physical gifts.

If you’re still harboring misgivings, just let ‘em go. Jump in with both feet and hop on the Lock train. I won’t call it a ‘hype’ train because hype implies that it’s overblown or exaggerated.

If you need a little encouragement, just look at what the Broncos front office is saying about Lock by virtue of almost every offseason move it made this year.

General managers don’t invest untold millions and coveted premium-round draft picks to build the nest around a young quarterback unless they’re sure they’ve got the right guy. The Broncos did not flinch when it came to building the nest around Lock, so whatever skepticism is left in your mind about Lock, if any, allow that fact to bridge the gap.

Lock is the truth. Embrace it. Get fully behind your guy. This time, you won’t be disappointed. 

Follow Chad on Twitter @ChadNJensen and @MileHighHuddle.

Comments (41)
No. 1-10

Funny that you site college yet say he’s a winner when he was a loser in college. I know you don’t like honesty and so you say 4-1 in 5 different ways and make it sound like it’s a different argument. Facts are this, he played 3 dreadful teams and 2 good ones. He wasn’t particularly good in the final 4 games just throwing 2 touchdowns. Yes the team won, yes he was there, no he didn’t do enough to only receive praise. If Shelby doesn’t get his big hand up Denver is 3-2 with lock and your entire argument out the window based off a play that has nothing to do with lock. Maybe he will be great, maybe not, but discarding everyone who’s honest as a hater just makes you sound like a massive homer(yes I know you are).


These justifications don’t even hold that much water. He’s unproven but has potential. That’s about the best way to put it. The best argument above is his leadership because he was statistically underwhelming. Put him on the Giants, Jags, Cardinals or Skins and the win % won’t be much different. Your argument about the O-ROY needing to lose points is shallow at best. While it is true that he was 4-1, and wins are the end game, he beat the Raiders, Chargers, Lions and a team that is GMed and coached by Bill O’Brien. The ‘conditions’ in Kansas City were the same for both teams and it wasn’t competitive. Don’t anoint him after 5 games, he’s unproven but has potential.


Scangarello was a terrible play caller for the Broncos. Lock's "mediocre" stats have a lot to do with his OC not giving him chances/putting the team in bad positions. I also still believe he should have been the starter week 7 after he was cleared medically (or not even put him on IR in the first place) but the team chose to hide him. Anyone who actually watched Lock saw ups and downs, but consistent growth from game to game (even though the stats dont show that). Abraham Lincoln once said that there are 3 types of lies: lies. Damned Lies. Statistics. The eye test means more than many give it credit for


I would also mention the fact that Lock raised all ships, especially the OL. This team was an emotional mess by the time Lock took over because the confidence had been beat out of them. Lock turned this team around emotionally. I would mention as well that the team leader, Von Miller, called Lock a "rock star." That's a pretty good endorsement.


What I saw in his playing time last year was similar to a young Elway or Farve. Still has a lot to learn, but he’s a play maker that’s not afraid to take chances. I’ll take him over any of the game manager types of QB we’ve had over the last few years.

Vertcal Stripes
Vertcal Stripes

Really like you article Chad but I would drop #1 as a reason for optimism. If memory is correct, Peyton went 3 and 13 his first year in the league. You make a great point about the Broncos seeing what we all saw and going ALL in. I don't think they would have if they weren't very sure of what they have at QB. Block for him and have him learn to protect himself when outside the pocket and I think we're going to have some fun football to watch!


And Peyton Manning went 3-13 his rookie year. I don't expect Lock to be Peyton Manning by the time his career is done, but I want a little bit of pragmatism. Lock played well given that, when the team was down, he inspired better play. This was a team that had lost multiple very close games that came down to one or two plays (or in the case of Chicago, one bad ref call and a play) and, watching the games, there was no doubt that the offense questioned it's ability to do even the simple things against other teams. When Lock played, for the first time of the season, I watched a team pull together. Yep, the KC game sucked, but there were lots of reasons for that, very few of which fall entirely on Lock's shoulders.

Here is my bottom line: Teams win games. Teams lose games. The Broncos looked like a better team with Lock under center, and shows signs of learning from his mistakes. Give him better weapons and coaching and see where he takes us.


Some folks like to be cautious so they don't feel let down or feel foolish later while others of us prefer to believe in what might be. I feel Lock is the best most exciting prospect we have had in years. He has those certain qualities of athleticism, playmaking ability and leadership that gives everyone optimism. And now he has more weapons and a year under his belt. Plenty of reasons to believe in the Broncos being fun to watch again. Be as cautious as you want I think we are going to have a really exciting season.


What does not get mentioned a lot is the fact Lock had more juice from the draft community as a junior then he did as a senior. Several of the draft pundits had Lock with a high probability to be the first overall pick if he stayed in school (which he obviously did) He show flashes of brilliance, along with some what was that. That is called being a young QB. We are going to find out what he really is. I was one of the first passengers on the Lock train back when there were not many of us on board. I am excited to see what the kid has in his bag.


Now if he can only stay healthy. Trouble with getting excited about a player is that so many get hurt with such regularity. Last stat Ii saw had better than the chance of a player eing hurt is over 100%. Hurt defined as having to miss practices or games. And before a math major attacks, by 100% it is meant if there ar 50 players there will be more than 50 injuries.