State Your Case: Why haven't Hall-of-Fame voters warmed up to Simeon Rice?

Clark Judge

Selectors for the Pro Football Hall of Fame love edge pass rushers. So why don’t they love Simeon Rice?

The former Tampa Bay and Arizona star ranks 20th in all-time sacks with 122, with 10 or more in eight of his 12 pro seasons. Yet he’s never been a finalist for Canton and was a semifinalist just once (2018).

Considering the track record of Hall-of-Fame voters, that doesn’t add up. They're so partial to edge pass rushers that they inducted nine modern-era candidates in a 10-year period (2008-2017) – including former Miami star Jason Taylor, a surprising first-ballot choice after he was named second-team all-decade for the 2000s.

Yet they won’t budge on Rice or former Chargers’ defensive end Leslie O’Neal.

O’Neal’s 132.5 sacks tie him with Lawrence Taylor and Terrell Suggs at 13th all-time, yet, like Rice, he’s never been a finalist and was a semifinalist just once (2018). I mention him because he and Rice are the only Hall-of-Fame eligible pass rushers in the top 20 who aren’t in Canton.

And they’re not close.

I’m serious. Neither was included on the Hall’s preliminary list of 126 candidates in 2014. And while that changed a year later when a couple of voters drew the Hall’s attention to the oversight, it’s an indication of where these two are on voters’ radar.

They’re not, and don’t ask me why.

For starters, Rice’s 122 sacks are more than Charles Haley (100.5), Andre Tippett (100), Warren Sapp (96.5) and Howie Long (88), and they're in in the Hall of Fame. Rice is not. Yet his 28 forced fumbles are more than Haley and Sapp, and his six in 2006 led the league.

But there’s more. He was four-time All-Pro. He was a Super Bowl champion. He was the NFL’s Defensive Rookie of the Year. And he was so dominant during his career that in his 2014 induction speech former Tampa Bay teammate Derrick Brooks called him “one of the best – if not THE best – pass rushers of my generation.”

Yet Hall-of-Fame voters are deaf to the noise, and maybe, just maybe, it’s because of the company Rice kept. As a member of the 2002 Tampa Bay Bucs, he was surrounded by greats on defense. Brooks was a first-ballot Hall choice. So was Sapp. Safety John Lynch has been a six-time Hall-of-Fame finalist. And cornerback Ronde Barber has been a semifinalist the first two years of eligibility.

That’s four Hall-of-Fame worthy defenders from one defense, and, I don't know, but Hall voters may figure that’s enough. I mean, look at the 1985 Chicago Bears. They have three defensive starters in Canton. The 2000 Baltimore Ravens have two. Like Tampa Bay, both were dominant defensive teams, yet won only one Super Bowl with those units.

Or maybe it’s a perception that Rice was a one-dimensional player, with NFL historian John Turney of Pro Football Journal reporting that Rice had a relatively low 38.5 run stuffs (tackles for losses on running plays) during his career. By comparison, the Giants’ Michael Strahan had 84.5, and O’Neal had 73.5.

Then again, it might have something to do with Rice not being an all-decade choice. Of course, that shouldn’t preclude him from getting to Canton. It simply makes his path more difficult. But look who was chosen to that team: Strahan, Jason Taylor, Dwight Freeney and Julius Peppers each had more sacks than Rice, and all but Strahan had more forced fumbles.

So he was in an elite field of pass rushers, and I get it. What I don’t get is why we keep ignoring him and Leslie O’Neal when it comes to advancing their candidacies. O’Neal never was part of a championship team, but so what? Neither was Jason Taylor.

But Rice was. In fact, he was a critical part of a defense that was the first since the 1985 Bears to lead the league in total defense, points allowed and interceptions and that held opposing quarterbacks to a 48.4 passer rating.

So what’s not to like?

“I know I was a Hall-of-Fame player,” Rice told the Talk of Fame Network in 2016. “If I could do it all over again and have a career like (I had), I would. I ushered in a whole ‘nother level of defense, with the Jason Taylors and Jevon Kearses and Dwight Freeneys … all those hybrid, fast-speed guys. I was the first one. And then that was the mold. And they looked for those guys after that.”

I don’t know about that. What I do know is that Simeon Rice once was recognized as an elite pass rusher, one of the league’s best. It’s time Pro Football Hall-of-Fame voters notice him, too, and make him something more than a one-time semifinalist.

Follow on Twitter @ClarkJudge TOF

Comments (3)
No. 1-3
brian wolf
brian wolf

What may hurt Rice in terms of discussion, is what happened to Hardy Nickerson...Free Agency.

Both players were prominent with other teams and their great play might have been largely forgotten, but make no mistake, it was remembered in Tampa Bay.

Though I believe pash rushers like Leslie O Neil and Cedrick Hardman are more deserving of the Hall, Rice was a pure rusher, who deserves strong consideration as well. Other pure rushers like Bubba Baker and Harvey Martin deserve looks as well.

With the HOF considering as many as 20 inductees as part of the Centennial Class, the voters really need to do their homework and make sure the right players, coaches and contributors get in. Like I speculated, it could be all decade selections but finalists who have been snubbed alot, deserve to finally get in. After all, if it wasn't for the toughness of Charlie Conerly in NY at QB, would an Italian coach with bipolar tendencies, like Vince Lombardi really get his chance to shine in Green Bay ?

Clark Judge
Clark Judge


Agree with you on virtually all points. Don't get the ambivalence toward O'Neal and Rice, though I do believe that much of it -- at least with Rice -- is that he's viewed as a pure pass rusher. And Turney's numbers support that. With pass rushers like Freeney and Allen and Mathis ... and even Abraham .... coming up, I don't believe either O'Neal or Rice gets into the room for discussion, and that's a shame. But there are, as you mentioned, so many deserving candidates for inclusion … and not enough spots to put them.


A major sticking point with Rice is his rather thin honors profile of 2/3/none. There are also two current HoFers from that Bucs defense (Sapp, Brooks) and two more likely HoFers (Lynch, Barber). Having a fifth defensive player from a team that only won one Super Bowl may make his sledding tough. Heck, look how hard it is to get in guys like Shell and Greenwood from those 70s Steelers defenses that won four titles.

State Your Case