This is an article from the Nov. 1, 1954 issue
"Heck, no! After all those cheers and all those girls, how could I ever get him back on my chicken farm? That would be easier if he were a scholar. He would be resigned and philosophical. But a football star would most likely be dreaming about the chickens back on the campus."
MARION E. JACKSON
ATLANTA Daily World
"Yes. Football develops character, understanding and sportsmanship. I played the game. The coach is father, mother, teacher and minister to his squad. And look what football has done for so many colored players—Fritz Pollard of Brown, Duke Slater of Iowa, J. C. Caroline of Illinois."
"No. With that athletic ability I'd rather he be a Jack Dempsey, a Gene Tunney, a Rocky Marciano. The risk of permanent injury in the ring isn't as great. And he'd be fairly rewarded. A college football star draws thousands to a game. What does he get in return? A paltry scholarship, if that."
"No, although I love the game. But being nuts about football doesn't make sense. It often gives boys the wrong sense of values if they get to be real big-time. They're idolized everywhere. There's too great a letdown after college days if the same adulation doesn't continue."
EMMETT O'DONNELL JR.
LT. GEN. USAF
"Yes, if he could play good football. But I wouldn't want football to be the biggest thing in his life. The prospect of serious injuries wouldn't worry me. Players in good condition are seldom injured seriously. I know that from experience. I was an assistant coach at West Point for three years."
"Yes. An All-America tag helps a man go far in life. Sure, he may break a leg or have his face twisted, but he takes that chance when he crosses the street. My nephew was an All-America end at U.C.L.A. Shortly after graduation he became a vice president of a large company. No drag, either."
JOHN P. CARMICHAEL
CHICAGO Daily News
"Yes. Players enjoy the competition. They benefit from the association and prestige to a degree that far overshadows the possibility of injury or tendency to become athletic bums. There should be more full scholarships for boys who want to trade football ability for honest educations."
FORD MOTOR CO.
"Yes, if his studies didn't suffer. What father wouldn't? Football grew out of American colleges. It's the greatest competitive game ever developed. A boy who can star on the football field while maintaining good scholastic grades is a potential leader in industry."
MRS. THEODORE INNES
"No. He played in high school. I was so worried that I could never watch him play. He used to say: 'Mother, you never get hurt if you follow the rules.' When he did get hurt he said someone else didn't follow the rules. At college, I pleaded with him 'not to be beef for the varsity.' "
NEW YORK, N.Y.
"No. Big-time football takes too much time. And it results in many permanent injuries. But there's more than the physical risk. Too many plaudits, too many girls can go to a boy's head. It's fine to die for dear old Yale, but I'd rather see him put the same enthusiasm into his studies."