DONALD A. QUARLES
Secretary of the Air Force
The All-America must have greater ability than others in his area. Publicity gives him a national reputation, but he rates it. The great Otto Graham claims that publicity more than ability helped make him an All-America. I'm sure the pros who played against him don't think so.
This is an article from the Dec. 3, 1956 issue
ADMIRAL ARTHUR W. RADFORD
Joint Chiefs of Staff
The All-America team is a great American tradition. Some outstanding players who don't get a volume of publicity are overlooked, but those who are chosen are probably as good, even though they were fortunate in playing on teams that received national publicity.
Those picked undoubtedly deserve the honor. But it's the luck of the draw. The Cleveland Browns, the pro national or division champions for 10 years, have very few All-Americas. I'm told Defensive Captain Don Colo was never an All-America. But he was still a great player as a professional.
New York Yankees
It's impossible for a group to pick a college All-America team where the 11 chosen are actually the best players in the country. Only in the pro league, where you can see every man play against every team, is it possible to pick the 11 top stars with absolute conviction.
Head football coach
Every player selected for the All-America team deserves the honor. A player must get publicity to be selected, but he has to be good to get the publicity. However, other players could be selected, and they would deserve the honor. Some All-Americas have failed with the pros.
ECAC football referee
Every All-America must have great ability and be a very exciting player. As Otto Graham said, publicity often gives a man the nod. Many football fans never heard of Tuffy Leemans before he played with the N.Y. Football Giants. Yet to this day he ranks as one of their greatest halfbacks.
NCAA Game-of-the-Week sportscaster
Without taking anything from the All-Americas, I'd say that they're all good but not always the best. Although the experts scan the powerhouses and do their best, I've seen many kids that were never heard of become greater pro players than their teammates who were selected as All-Americas.
GEORGE C. WILSON III
Wilson Chemical Co.
Publicity is a big factor in the All-America, but some college players with great ability earn the respect and admiration of sports-writers. They deserve all the publicity they get. The College All-Stars, made up of All-America selectees, have licked the champions of the professional league.
N.Y. Journal-American Sports editor
There is a great deal of merit in these selections. However, there are so many good football players on the national scene that an occasional back who gets the loudest drum beats is picked over better players. The pros know those who are missed and often draft them over the publicized All-Americas.
The All-Americas are built by more than just publicity. The A.P. takes a cold look at all the college players. Take 1928 when we picked Dutch Clark of little Colorado College as the All-America quarterback. A lot of people laughed at us, but we were certain he was the best.
Head football coach
University of Pennsylvania
It's wonderful for a boy and for his school when he makes All-America. But some selections, chosen from many, are criticized. However, there's one way to still all criticism. Instead of choosing just 11 players, why not select a full squad of 33 players as the All-America team?
JIM LEE HOWELL
N.Y. Football Giants
The All-America selections are a colorful finale to the college football season. To be chosen, a player must have great ability, but an occasional player who doesn't get rave notices is missed. In pro football, I played alongside John Mellus, a star tackle, whom the experts missed.
Which is more fun to play, college or pro football? (Asked of professionals)