Boston bullpen ace Lee Smith saved the day—and two games—as the Red Sox sent the Yankees packing and took control of the American League East race
September 25, 1988

The instant the ball left Mike Pagliarulo's bat, a sense of grim inevitability settled like some poisonous vapor on old Fenway Park, on all of old New England, for that matter. Yes, fainthearted Boston Red Sox fans were telling themselves, it was happening again, just as it had 10 years ago. The New York Yankees were going to lay remorseless waste to another September of hope and promise. Indeed, there was Pagliarulo's fly ball sailing through the cool air last Friday night in an obvious home run arc to the seats in rightfield, transforming yet another apparent Red Sox win into a foredoomed loss. But let us set the scene:

The Yankees came to Boston for a four-game series last week 4½ games behind the Red Sox in a tightening American League East race. Sound familiar? New York had been four back when it hit town in September 1978; it then trashed Boston in four straight by a cumulative score of 42-9, took a share of the divisional lead and finally won the pennant, 5-4, in the postseason Fenway playoff game in which Bucky Dent hit his famous—infamous in New England—seventh-inning homer into the net beyond the leftfield wall.

The eerie similarity between the circumstances then and those of last week set Red Sox fans off on a veritable rampage of dread and self-loathing. It was as if they felt only another Boston Massacre could release them from this terrible angel. Boston Globe columnist Mike Barnicle wrote on Thursday of a recurring nightmare he had been enduring, in which Dent, "this short, beady-eyed guy with the Daytona 500 haircut," stood in the on-deck circle, "a broken bat in his hand and an evil gleam in his eye."

And so, when the Yankees won the first game of the series last Thursday 5-3, driving Sox ace and American League strikeout king Roger Clemens from the mound, Bostonians nodded in miserable acknowledgment of their fate. The Yanks were now 3½ out and closing. If Clemens, who had tossed a one-hitter in his previous outing to break an 0-5 pitching slump couldn't win, what now? Clemens didn't pitch badly, but he was humiliated by a homer and a key double from Pagliarulo, who had been hitting .096 in his last 16 games and, to make matters worse, hails from nearby Medford, Mass. He had also been hurt by a Claudell Washington steal of home made possible, Washington said, by Clemens's habit of ducking his head before going into his motion. Even so, it took five Yankee pitchers, from starter Rick Rhoden to closer Dave Righetti, to finish off the Sox. But then, Yankee pitching had been something of a group grope lately, anyway.

With his ace beaten, Boston manager Joe Morgan turned on Friday night to Wes Gardner, a former reliever and former Met (remember 1986!). Gardner gave up hits to the first three batters he faced—Rickey Henderson, Washington and Don Mattingly—and two runs, but he shut the Yankees down from there until the eighth inning. The New York starter, rookie lefthander Al Leiter, lasted only 27 pitches before retiring with a twinge behind his shoulder blade. The Sox jumped on his successors—Steve Shields, Dale Mohorcic and Lee Guetterman—for seven runs, five of them coming in a riotous fifth inning that included a bases-loaded walk to a rookie, Carlos Quintana, in his first major league at bat. Quintana was hitting for the storm-tossed Jim Rice, who this season had already been given a chilly reception by the Fenway faithful for his tired play, punished for shoving his manager and mocked as he closed in on the league career record for hitting into double plays; then, on Friday, he was hit on the left knee by a Leiter pitch that forced him to the sidelines, out of harm's way. Rice was just one of seven batters, six of them Red Sox, hit by pitchers in the first three games of this bitter series.

Boston had a comfortable 7-2 lead when New York came to bat in the eighth. Gardner gave way to Dennis Lamp after a walk to Rafael Santana and a single by Washington. Dave Win-field scored both of them with a missile off the wall. And when Jack Clark walked, the tying run came to the plate in the suddenly dangerous person of Pagliarulo. Morgan called on his hulking reliever, Lee Smith, who threw one pitch to the Massachusetts Yankee, a fastball "out over the plate," as Pagliarulo described it. Pags connected, and he "knew" the ball was out of the park. "How could it not be?" he asked later. "I hit it better than the one last night."

As the crowd fell silent, Yankee manager Lou Piniella was doing a little dance in the dugout and Sox rightfielder Dwight (Dewey) Evans was retreating, tracking the ball. Then, suddenly, Evans stopped just inches short of the wall, reached up and caught the ball one-handed. He didn't even have to leap. There would be no Yankee sweep this time. And, said Boggs, tweaking a horde of "negative" reporters afterward in the clubhouse, "There'll be no 1978 now. Sorry, fellas."

The fact is that this New York team, for all of its vaunted firepower, is not up to 1978 snuff. The defense is uncertain and the pitching is in disarray. The latest pitching coach, Clyde King, currently in his third term at that job, looks upon his staff much as Bonaparte must have viewed la Grande Armèe on its retreat from Moscow. "Our bullpen is worn out," King said after watching a total of seven relievers go to the front Thursday and Friday. "We're using three, four, five guys a game. That's because we have to approach every game as if it were the last of the season. People malign our pitching staff. Well, if you look at the ERA [4.35 through Sunday], maybe it's deserved. But we have guys who, while they're not exactly hurting, are just a little tired."

King has been on the job for only five weeks and is the third Yankee pitching coach of the season; owner George Steinbrenner apparently considers men in this position as expendable as his managers. And in fact King would rather be back up in the front office as special adviser to the boss, the job he held before being called on to help out below. "Heck, since I've been here, I've been everything but owner," says King. That's one job, rest assured, he can forget about.

Both Piniella and Morgan entered this critical if not exactly historic series feeling they had to earn at least a split. Both wanted more, of course, especially Piniella, who looked red-eyed and sorrowful after Pagliarulo's near homer on Friday. Time, he knew, was running out on him. He has only this weekend's three-game series with the Sox in Yankee Stadium to make up the ground lost in Boston. Morgan, who comes across as a funnier, faster talking and certainly more profane Pa Kettle, was as relaxed and cheerful during the weekend as his team's fans were overwrought and fearful. He spent hours before every game regaling newsmen with recollections of his days as a "career minor leaguer."

"I was a Triple A player, period," he said. "But what the bleep, I got more bleeping stories and I know more people—including some I don't want to know—so what the bleep. I played for five major league teams, and all that added up to was a year and a half and about 30 hits [36, to be exact]. But what the bleep. I was going to write a book about all this. I'd have called it How's Your Old Tomatoes. That was a signal for the squeeze play I learned from Joe Schultz when he managed me at Triple A in Atlanta. Joe would coach third and say to the runner, 'How's your old tomatoes?' And that runner would go."

In the fourth inning on Saturday, Morgan called his own squeeze play without the tomato code, but for all the good it did him, he might as well have said, "How's your old man?" With the game scoreless, Mike Greenwell on third and Todd Benzinger at bat against the Yankee's Charles Hudson, Morgan flashed the sign. Greenwell broke for the plate, but Benzinger, transfixed, only vaguely attempted to bunt. New York catcher Don Slaught had Greenwell trapped, but instead of throwing the ball, he tried to run him down between home and third. Slaught finally caught up with him just short of third but dropped the ball attempting a diving tag. Greenwell never did score, though, and that's only fitting because he had no business being on third base in the first place. He got to first after he struck out on a Hudson pitch in the dirt that got away from Slaught. Boldly, he tried to steal second, and when Slaught, having one of those innings, threw the ball into centerfield, Greenwell reached his final stop at third. To complete his awful sequence, Slaught struck out leading off the next inning. So it goes for the Yankees, the 1988 model.

The Red Sox did get a run in their half of the fifth, but not without controversy. Baby-faced Jody Reed, whose mustache makes him look like a kid dressed up for Halloween, doubled and reached third on Rich Gedman's sacrifice. Then Wade Boggs lifted a high fly down the leftfield line. A fan, leaning out of the stands that angle out almost to the playing field, had a shot at catching the ball but missed. Henderson did catch it, falling awkwardly backward against the wall, while Reed tagged and scored easily from third. Piniella rushed onto the field in a rage, claiming correctly that third base umpire Ted Hendry had called fan interference, but incorrectly that the run, therefore, should not count. Umpire crew chief Jim Evans said Reed would have scored in any event, and the run counted, whereupon Piniella announced that the game was being played under protest.

The freak plays could not detract, however, from a magnificent pitching duel between Hudson—starting in place of Tommy John, who had a stomach virus—and Bruce Hurst, who over the last two months has stood in for Clemens as the ace of the Boston staff. Hudson had allowed only one run and two hits going into the eighth when Evans led off with a rising drive into the screen, which proved to be the game-winning run. The packed house rocked, and even the most devout disbeliever was now shouting hosannas. The homer gave Evans 100 RBIs for the season, the third time in a distinguished 16-year career he had passed the century mark. Benzinger scored a gravy run on Larry Parrish's double, but this was Citizen Hurst's game. He allowed only three hits and a run, while walking two and striking out nine. It was his 18th win against five losses, his ninth win in his last 10 decisions and his 13th this season in Fenway, the supposed graveyard of left-handers. "I think this team has come to realize that pitching is an important part of our game," he said, earnestly emphasizing the obvious. "And Roger [Clemens] is a big reason for that. He's been a dominant force." But not as dominant lately, Hurst was too modest to say, as Bruce Hurst has been.

On Sunday, Boston sent the Yankees packing with a 9-4 thrashing as the Sox pounced on poor Ron Guidry—now a sorry imitation of his once invincible self—for six runs in just 1‚Äö√Ñ√∂‚àö√±‚àö¬® innings. A three-run homer by Ellis Burks in the first and a two-run shot by Evans in the second led an early attack that put the game out of reach for the now dispirited New Yorkers. They had come to town confident of repeating history. They left 6½ out, in fourth place, with their pennant hopes all but dashed.

The Sox may well have exorcised forever the demons of 1978. But they're not without some sorcery of their own: Out of character though it may seem, Morgan keeps a little metal witch on his desk, professing, however, that he attaches no importance to the talisman. "Some woman sent it to me," Morgan says. "I don't know what it is—the wizard of bleep, maybe." Besides, he says, he doesn't need anything exorcised, least of all the ancient events of '78. "I can't even remember the '70s," he says. "I was in the minor leagues." But after last weekend at Fenway, one could hazard a guess that '88 might just possibly have some meaning for him.

PHOTOCHUCK SOLOMON PHOTOCHUCK SOLOMONPiniella (left) squawked, but it was Reed—and four other Sox—who got hit by pitches. PHOTOJOHN BIEVER[See caption above.] PHOTOJOHN BIEVERHurst hurled a beauty on Saturday, fanning nine and frustrating New York on three hits. PHOTOJOHN BIEVEROminous memories were awakened in Fenway when Clemens was shelled on Thursday. PHOTOCHUCK SOLOMONEvans couldn't snag Washington's drive on Sunday, but he did hit a homer of his own. TWO PHOTOSCHUCK SOLOMONGreenwell (left) leads Boston in RBIs, but on Sunday it was Burks (top) who drove in three. PHOTOJACQUELINE DUVOISINHenderson had a ball on the base paths, running his season's stolen base total to 85. PHOTOJOHN BIEVERDespite a pair of homers and four RBIs in the series, Pagliarulo left Fenway in a funk.

"Fainthearted Boston fans were telling themselves it was happening once again."

Eagle (-2)
Birdie (-1)
Bogey (+1)
Double Bogey (+2)