SI: Fergus Muir, a 66-year-old retired Scottish executive,
claimed that on Nov. 6, 2001, he holed a 375-foot putt from the
tee to a front pin position on the 144-yard, par-three 5th hole
of the Eden Course at St. Andrews. Earlier this month his claim
was accepted as a new world record. How did you verify that it
was a record length?
This is an article from the April 28, 2003 issue
CM: We have lots of resources here. Of course we have our record
books. We have contacts at specialist magazines. The Internet is
also a good source.
SI: So, basically, you do a Google search?
CM: Yes, that can work.
SI: There must be more to the verification process than that. How
can you be absolutely certain that Muir didn't simply make it up?
CM: We have a healthy cynicism. When you see so many claims, you
get a feel for what is genuine. We're professionals here, and we
have a lot of checks and balances. We don't like to make
mistakes, and hopefully we don't, because we're the final word.
SI: Can you be more specific?
CM: We have guidelines. He has to provide a letter and at least
two witness statements from people of local standing in the
community. It also helped that there was a lot of press coverage.
SI: Whoa, whoa, whoa! Are you saying we have to trust the press?
CM: I'm a former sports journalist by trade, so yes. I have a lot
of contacts on various sports desks, and I trust that journalists
do their best to report fairly.
SI: Do you ever use a lie detector?
CM: As an organization we prefer to take things on good faith,
and a claim will be rejected if there is any shadow of doubt.
Most record attempts are on video for evidence, but that wasn't
the case with this.
SI: So Muir now holds the record. But don't you think that
someone somewhere has holed a longer putt and you haven't heard
CM: It's quite possible. Most people submit records for purely
historical reasons. The previous record for the longest putt
[166'8"] was also set in the U.K. We invite claims from
everywhere, but it's more ingrained in the U.K. culture. We'd
like to increase our global exposure.
SI: I'm sorry, but I have to ask: Is there a chance, however
small, that Muir paid off his two buddies to vouch for him?
CM: [Long pause] Do you have some information that I'm not aware