Search

SI PLAYERS POLL

Sept. 27, 2004
Sept. 27, 2004

Table of Contents
Sept. 27, 2004

50 Years of Sports in America
Sports Illustrated Bonus Section: Golf Plus
SCORECARD
CATCHING UP WITH
LETTERS
AIR AND SPACE
SI Players
Inside
Inside The NFL
Inside Baseball
Inside College Football
Inside Boxing
Inside Golf
Departments

SI PLAYERS POLL

Based on a survey of 354 players

Edited by Kostya Kennedy

Who is the NFL's best quarterback?

This is an article from the Sept. 27, 2004 issue Original Layout

Peyton Manning 34%

Brett Favre 23%

Tom Brady 14%

Steve McNair 12%

Which QB is most dangerous in a fourth-quarter comeback?

Brett Favre 47%

Tom Brady 15%

Peyton Manning 15%

Michael Vick 10%

FAST FACTS: Players were not allowed to vote for a quarterback on their team.... Fifteen signal-callers got at least one vote for best QB.... Vick was fifth in the best-QB poll, McNair fifth among comebackers.

For complete results and breakdown of the poll go to si.com/scorecard.

COLOR PHOTO MORRY GASH/AP (FAVRE)COLOR PHOTOTOM STRICKLAND/AP (MANNING)