The Jury's Out

Notre Dame is piling up points and victories, but are the Irish worthy of a coveted BCS bid?
November 09, 2009

How good is Notre Dame? The question becomes more urgent with each victory by the Fighting Irish. Their 40--14 beatdown of hapless Washington State in San Antonio last Saturday won't turn any heads, but with a 6--2 record and a No. 22 ranking in the BCS, Notre Dame becomes more relevant every week. If the Irish were to win out and finish 10--2, it's hard to imagine their not cracking the top 14—the minimum requirement to be eligible for an at-large BCS bid, so coveted by schools such as TCU and Boise State. "We've put ourselves in position for good things to happen," says Notre Dame coach Charlie Weis.

The victory over the Cougars was the kind rarely enjoyed by the Irish this season. None of their previous four wins had been by more than seven points—a troubling stat for a team that averages more than 31 points. Despite narrow losses to Michigan and USC, the Frenetic Irish have yet to win over poll voters. They are 21st in the USA Today poll, 20th in the Harris. "Their inability to shut anybody down makes people mistrust them," says former USC coach John Robinson.

Led by junior quarterback Jimmy Clausen, Notre Dame's offense is more than good enough. The Irish rank fifth in the country in total offense (457.6 yards per game), primarily because the 6'3", 223-pound Clausen has developed into a bona fide Heisman contender—and arguably the best quarterback in the game. He is second in the nation in pass efficiency, completing 66.9% of his throws with 18 touchdowns and two interceptions.

It's the defense that might hold Notre Dame back. Its root problem is a front four that hasn't generated much of a pass rush. Too often coordinator Jon Tenuta has had to resort to the blitz, which leaves the secondary vulnerable to big plays. Notre Dame ranks 109th against the pass and has allowed five scoring tosses of 20 yards or more.

After a date with Navy in South Bend this Saturday, road games against No. 14 Pitt and Stanford are sandwiched around a visit from Connecticut. Weis says there's a chance that star wideout Michael Floyd will be back for the Nov. 14 game against the Panthers. Floyd, a 6'3", 220-pound sophomore, scored five touchdowns and averaged 27.5 yards a catch through the first three games before breaking his collarbone in a Sept. 19 win over Michigan State. With a team that must score plenty of points to keep alive its BCS hopes, Floyd can't return soon enough.

Now on SI.com

Look for Gene Menez's Heisman Watch every Monday at SI.com/bonus

EXTRA POINT

Ducks Rising

You won't find Notre Dame in this week's SI playoff bracket. The Fighting Irish did not get a single vote from the 14 writers and editors who cast ballots. While Texas flipped positions with idle Alabama, Oregon, moving up from 10th, made the biggest jump from last week. Jeremiah Masoli(below), a dual-threat quarterback, threw for 222 yards and ran for 164 more as the Ducks piled up 613 total yards in a 47--20 drubbing of USC, the Trojans' worst loss since 1997.

The SI playoff bracket is released every Sunday at SI.com/bonus

[The following text appears within a chart. Please see hardcopy or PDF for actual chart.]

1 Florida

16 Utah

8 Boise State

9 LSU

5 TCU

12 USC

4 Cincinnati

13 Pitt

National Champion

Texas 2

Ohio State 15

Iowa 7

Georgia Tech 10

Oregon 6

Penn State 11

Alabama 3

Houston 14

PHOTOGREG NELSON (CLAUSEN)OFFENSIVE FORCE With 18 TD passes and only two interceptions, Clausen has emerged as a Heisman favorite. PHOTOROBERT BECK (MASOLI) CHART

HOLE YARDS PAR R1 R2 R3 R4
OUT
HOLE YARDS PAR R1 R2 R3 R4
IN
Eagle (-2)
Birdie (-1)
Bogey (+1)
Double Bogey (+2)