Malkin Shines, Crosby Struggles: Pittsburgh Penguins Player Grades at the Quarter Mark

The Pittsburgh Penguins have officially completed the quarter mark of the season, losing to the St. Louis Blues Thursday night and leaving them in 8th place in the Metropolitan Division with a 7-12-2 record, and just 16 points in the standings. Only two teams in the NHL, Chicago and Vancouver, are currently worse.
Here are my player grades for the roster so far through the first 21 games of the season. Grades are based on the player’s production versus the expectations for that player coming into this season.
Forwards
Evgeni Malkin: A-
19 GP, 6G-12A-18P, (-2)
The 40-year-old has been the most consistently productive forward. Strong assist totals and low penalty rate relative to his style, though he still has a penchant for bad turnovers at the top of the offensive zone. He’s driven offense regardless of line or power-play unit assignment.

Tommy Novak— A-
21 GP, 8G-7A-15P, (+2)
Tied for team lead in goal total, and one of the steadiest two-way showings among the forwards. Face-offs have been a big minus, so he is currently playing wing on the second line. His overall impact has been among the best on a struggling roster.
Nick Robertson— B+
20 GP, 7G-0A-7P, (+5)
Excellent finishing rate on limited ice time (~13 min/GP). The speed and forecheck are noticeable. He was given an opportunity to play with Crosby when the season started, but has since settled nicely into a role on the fourth line.
Ben Kindel— B-
18 GP, 4G-5A-9P, (-12)
Encouraging flashes after his earlier medical issue, especially when elevated; he is currently centering the second line. Still a bit inconsistent and the plus-minus is rough, but the underlying tools and recent usage are positive.
Rickard Rakell— C+
21 GP, 8G-5A-13P, (-5)
Shot volume is there (leads forwards in 5-on-5 shots in some tracking), finishing can be inconsistent at times, but he could be heating up with 3 goals in his last 4 games and is now tied for the team lead in the category. Already linked to one trade this season and is a top candidate to be moved before the deadline.
Sidney Crosby— C
21 GP, 6G-9A-14P, (-9)
Production is well below his standards. Some expected-goals numbers suggest the process has been better than the results at times, but the decline in burst and playmaking vision is noticeable. I believe he is still battling through multiple injuries, the main culprit being the knee that was injured during the Olympics in February of 2026, which caused him to miss a total of 15 games last season. Second-half improvement will be critical to the team’s success.

Hendrix Lapierre— C
16 GP, 2G-5A-7P, (-3)
First year in the system for a young player. He was briefly tried on the wing so his speed could remain in the lineup, but you could quickly tell he is far superior at the center position, so back he went. Contributes modestly without standing out positively or negatively in most games.
Connor Dewar— C
21 GP, 2G-3A-5P, (-1)
Fourth-Liner and penalty killer who hasn’t quite found the same success this season as he had last
year. Leads the team with 31 hits. Needs to start producing if he wants to keep his place in the lineup.
Ville Koivunen— C-
17 GP, 2G-4A-6P, (EV)
Has received a long leash as one of the young players getting an extended look, but his play has been up-and-down, including some healthy scratches. Not a total non-factor, but his AHL game hasn’t translated at the upper level, prohibiting him from seizing the opportunity.
Blake Lizotte— C-
21 GP, 0G-5A-5P, (-3)
High energy and motor guy playing fourth-line minutes and killing penalties, but also not finding the same success this season. Struggling in the face-off circle, but still remains an important piece on the roster.
Egor Chinakhov— D
17 GP, 3G-3A-6P, (-5)
On pace for a low-teens goal total after higher expectations. Seems to hit the goal post or crossbar at least once a game. Needs to get his shot on net to be effective. Process indicates positive regression could be coming, but the output is disappointing so far.
Andrei Kuzmenko— N/A
12 GP, 0G-1A-1P, (-7)
Skating limitations are noticeable and he’s been a non-factor in any of his games played. He is likely still feeling the effects of losing his father at the start of training camp.
Bryan Rust, Rutger McGroarty, Justin Brazeau, Elmer Soderblom — Incomplete or Injury-limited
Defense
Kaedan Korczak— B+
21 GP, 0G-10A-10P, (-2)
A pleasant surprise. Mobile, capable puck-mover who has settled into a useful role without major gaffes. Will get physical when needed. He is second amongst the defense with 23 hits and is also second on the team with 29 blocked shots.
Kris Letang— B+
21 GP, 1G-10A-11P, (+2)
Aging gracefully in a reduced role. Lowest goals-against rate among regular defensemen in some tracking; solid veteran contribution. Leads the defense in hits with 27.

Erik Karlsson— B-
21 GP, 3G-16A-19P, (-14)
Points are strong (team leader), but defensive results have been poor (high goals-against rate at 5-on-5). Partner instability has hurt, though it appears Stastney is the right partner for him. The offense is real; the two-way impact is not matching last year’s peak. One of the players most likely to be moved at some point this season.
Samuel Girard— C+
18 GP, 2G-6A-8P, (-7)
The offensive acumen can’t be ignored, but he too often is out of position in the defensive zone or being out-muscled in front of the net. Needs to focus on more consistent defense if he wants to take the next step forward.
Spencer Stastney— C
16 GP, 0G-3A-3P, (-1)
Low-event, mistake-light, reliable defender. Understands spacing, moves the puck efficiently and is a superb skater. He can pair with offensive defensemen because his skating makes up for any mistakes committed by his partner.
Declan Carlile— D
20 GP, 3G-3A-6P, (-9)
Offense generation when he’s on the ice is decent, but the goals-against numbers (elevated 5-on-5 rate) and decision-making issues have been costly. Another young player getting an extended look and being allowed to work through his mistakes, which have been plenty.
Trevor van Riemsdyk— N/A
6 GP, 0G-1A-1P, (EV)
Recently activated from IR. Back in the lineup after not having played since October 9th against
Columbus.
Goaltending
Sergei Murashov— B
8 GP, 2-5-1, 3.25 GAA, .894 SV%
Roller-coaster results with some strong recent outings. The young goalie has shown the ability to steal games; consistency and the defensive environment remain challenges. Has starter upside if he can cut down on simple mistakes.

Arturs Silovs— C-
13 GP, 5-7-1, 3.41 GAA, .873 SV%
Mixed bag. Has kept the team in games at times and has a couple of shutouts, but the overall save percentage and goals-against average reflect the team’s defensive struggles more than poor individual play.
Overall, the grades reflect a team that has underperformed relative to expectations through the first quarter of the season. A handful of players — most notably Malkin, Novak, and Korczak — have held up their end, but too many regulars have fallen short of the production or defensive reliability the Penguins need. With the standings already looking bleak, second-half improvement from the core (particularly Crosby) and clearer roles for the younger players will be essential if Pittsburgh hopes to climb out of the early-season hole.
-ee12e506b256ef4ed25d9c6143b1ea40.jpg)
Douglas Penz is a freelance sports journalist based in Pittsburgh with more than 25 years of independent coverage of the Pittsburgh Penguins. He has followed the team closely across multiple eras, focusing on game coverage, analysis, and in-depth reporting from a fan-informed but independent perspective. He holds a Bachelor’s degree in Communications Management from Robert Morris University.