F1 News: Electric Blanket Ban Reconsidered As Teams And Drivers Fight Against It

The unheated tyre plan isn't sounding like it's something anyone can stand behind.

Formula 1 recently took a step back from the anticipated electric blanket ban, which had been pencilled in for the 2024 regulations. While it had garnered a significant amount of attention, the teams, in their collective decision, have postponed this enforcement. This has sparked the debate anew: should the ban be implemented or reconsidered?

Listening to the Stakeholders: Drivers and Teams

In this intricate dance of decision-making, Formula 1's stakeholders' voices certainly didn't hold back. Drivers, rightly, feared the danger of starting a session on cold tyres - despite tests showing that it only took a short number of laps for the tyres to warm up and exhibit high levels of traction.

Teams have also stood by their initial belief that blankets should still be used. 

Listen To The Latest Driven Mad Podcast Episode

Concurrently, both FIA and Formula 1 hesitated to firmly shut out Bridgestone coming on as the official tyre provider. Were the ban to be enforced in 2024, the spotlight would inevitably shift to Pirelli who are eager to maintain their place in the sport. 

Pirelli's In-depth Tyre Analysis and Research

After 17,134km of testing on-track and countless more in simulation, Pirelli was able to present their thorough analysis of their unheated tyres. Comparing their new rubber to the current C3 tyre compound used in F1's 2023 season, albeit unheated, they showed a significant improvement in their findings, albeit an improvement that we may not want to see.

While they found at colder tracks their hard tyres would lose up to six-tenths initially, with the first lap showing a loss of 2-seconds. It's only after two laps that the tyres start to reach optimum performance. On a hot track, however, it only took a single lap for the rubber to reach optimum performance. 

When the 2023 tyres were compared to these new tyres (both unheated but at their optimum rubber and air temperature), there was only a loss of 3%. These new tyres also wear slower in cold temperatures, and at hot temps, wear only slightly faster. Of course, fans of the sport won't be wanting to hear this, with many calling for the need for more pitting during a race weekend. 

Both tyre types were prone to overheating on hot tracks after prolonged use, but Pirelli is keen to remind us that they haven't finished developing this new range yet. 

Strategy Changes

Pirelli has admitted that it's likely that, with this new unheated rubber, races will extend by around four seconds due to the slower initial laps. But the Italian company also believes there will be less chance for undercutting, meaning the drivers will have to focus on on-track overtakes instead of relying on pit strategy. 

As we've seen from the season so far, I'm not entirely trusting that this is plausible, and could instead result in races with less excitement due to the removal of pit strategy, albeit it with a similar number of overtakes. Pirelli disagrees, and states that teams will exhibit different strategies on different compounds. I find this hard to believe. 

More of a focus will also be put on the first lap of the life of the tyres. The driving style on this first lap will change how the tyre behaves for the rest of its use, adding another layer of strategy to this moment. 

Pirelli will need to be awarded the place of tyre provider for this test to continue, but at the moment, it's not filling me with confidence, or the teams and drivers.