Why Fantasy Managers Must Start Mike Evans in Week 16

Mike Evans returned from IR in Week 15 with a huge performance. We break down why he should be a start in Week 16.

Dec 11, 2025; Tampa, Florida, USA; Tampa Bay Buccaneers wide receiver Mike Evans (13) looks on during warmups before the game against the Atlanta Falcons at Raymond James Stadium. | Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images

Mike Evans is back and firing on all cylinders after returning from IR in Week 15, delivering a standout performance that reminded fantasy managers why he’s one of the league’s most consistent and explosive wide receivers. Healthy and fully integrated into the offense, Evans brings huge upside and a proven connection with quarterback Baker Mayfield.

He also has a knack for finding the end zone, making him a dangerous weapon in any matchup. In Week 16, he’s not just playable, he’s a must-start for fantasy lineups seeking reliable production and big scoring potential.

Mike Evans is fresh off a strong return from IR in Week 15

Mike Evans was phenomenal in his return from IR in Week 15. This marked his first game action since Week 7, after missing six straight games due to a broken collarbone.

MIKE EVANS WITH A HALL OF FAME MOSSED CATCH.

😱

The GOAT is back. pic.twitter.com/bST02DcFCj

— MLFootball (@MLFootball) December 12, 2025

In the game, Evans caught 6 of his team-high 12 targets for 132 yards, showcasing his ability to make plays and move the chains. He led the team in both receptions and yardage, demonstrating he was fully involved in the offense right out of the gate.

He totaled 19.2 fantasy points, proving that he remains one of the most reliable and explosive players in the NFL. Evans’ performance signals that he’s ready to deliver consistent production in the coming weeks, making him a must-start option for fantasy managers.

Mike Evans High Upside and Redzone usage

Mike Evans has only played in five games this season due to various injuries, but he always makes his presence felt on the field. In those five games, he has already recorded six red-zone targets, showing that he remains a key scoring threat for the Bucs.

He ranks fourth on the team in red-zone targets, behind Emeka Egbuka (13 in 14 games), Tez Johnson (9 in 13 games), and Sterling Shepard (7 in 13 games), but ahead of Chris Godwin, who has four in six games this season. This highlights Evans’ continued value, especially in fantasy football, despite limited time on the field.

Week 16 Playoff Matchup and Implications

The Bucs face the Carolina Panthers in Week 16. The Panthers rank as the 11th-best defense in fantasy football against opposing wide receivers this season. With both teams tied at 7-7 atop the NFC South, the stakes are incredibly high — the winner will take sole possession of first place and gain a stronghold on playoff positioning.

Despite the tougher matchup, Evans’ outlook remains strong. His experience, career-long success, and ability to perform in high-pressure situations make him essentially matchup-proof. With the importance of this game, Evans is poised to be a key factor for the Bucs and a reliable fantasy asset in Week 16.