ESPN's Final Preseason CBB Rankings Slot Illinois at No. 16: Too High or Too Low?

In this story:
If you thought Illinois head basketball coach Brad Underwood's offseason couldn't get any better, guess again. Underwood received a six-year contract extension back in May, landed two elite players via the transfer portal – guard/forward Andrej Stojakovic and junior center Zvonimir Ivisic – and on Wednesday saw his squad ranked No. 16 in ESPN's final top 25 college basketball preseason poll.
ESPN's Final Top 25 Preseason Rankings:
— College Basketball Report (@CBKReport) October 8, 2025
1. Purdue
2. Florida
3. Houston
4. UConn
5. St. John's
6. Louisville
7. BYU
8. Michigan
9. Kentucky
10. Duke
11. Texas Tech
12. Arkansas
13. Arizona
14. UCLA
15. Iowa State
16. Illinois
17. Auburn
18. Tennessee
19. Alabama
20. Gonzaga
21.…
Equally impressive, perhaps, is that Illinois is considered by ESPN to be the fourth-ranked team in the Big Ten, behind No. 1 Purdue, No. 8 Michigan and No. 14 UCLA. In the speing, and in some cases even now, certain experts and outlets also put the Illini behind Oregon and, in some cases, Michigan State.
Is Illinois ranked too high?
Maybe. Illinois brings back three of its starters from last year in Tomislav Ivisic, Kylan Boswell and Ben Humrichous, so it's not like Underwood isn't bringing back any experience. But the Illini lost Kasparas Jakucionis and Will Riley to the NBA Draft back in June, and replacing the production of the team's two most dynamic offensive players won't be easy.
And it may be a surprise to some that Illinois was ranked ahead of Oregon and Michigan State. Dana Altman reloaded in Eugene, and he still has Nate Bittle – maybe the Big Ten's best all-around center – to lead the way. And the Spartans made it all the way to the Elite Eight last season and have one of the best coaches in college basketball in Tom Izzo.
What stands out about #Illini basketball to Andrej Stojakovic now and when he was in the portal?
— Tristan Thomas (@TristanThomasTV) October 2, 2025
"We have one clear vision, and that's just to win games." pic.twitter.com/AF5AOcG9H9
What are realistic expectations for Illinois?
According to ESPN's rankings, Illinois should make it to at least the Sweet 16, but let's pump the brakes for just a minute. Underwood has been in Champaign for nine years now and has won multiple games in the NCAA Tournament just once. His best season came two years ago when Illinois made it to the Elite Eight, so based on his track record alone, Illinois isn't exactly a lock to make a deep NCAA Tournament run.
At the end of the day, though, Illinois has a ton of talent and should make it to the Sweet 16. Returning three starters from last year plus landing Zvonimir Ivisic and Stojakovic via the portal is big. And freshmen David Mirkovic and Mihailo Petrovic give Illinois more depth and versatility than perhaps any team in the conference outside of Purdue.
We'll know a lot more about Illinois come conference play, but for now, the hype is legit and fully warranted.
2025-26 Pronunciation guide. Save for future reference. pic.twitter.com/TLu6yQOV1y
— Illinois Men's Basketball (@IlliniMBB) October 3, 2025

Jared Shlensky is a contributing writer for On SI and a freelance play-by-play broadcaster. Jared was previously a sports betting writer for Yardbarker, an On-Air YouTube Personality for the Sports Geek and a minor league play-by-play broadcaster.