Notre Dame Recruiting Class Grades: Offense
Notre Dame is not quite done recruiting on offense for the 2021 class, and the staff will look to add one more player to the group in February. But the Irish have commitments at every position, and are finished at four of the five offensive position groups, which means it is time to hand out grades.
Grades are based on a combination of meeting numbers needs, impact talent, scheme fit and how well players at each position complement each other.
QUARTERBACK
Grade: A
Signees: Tyler Buchner
Notre Dame identified Tyler Buchner as its top target at the position right away, and landing him gave the Irish their potential quarterback of the future. Buchner is a unique prospect that can shred teams from the pocket, he can rip off big plays on designed runs and he’s dangerous when moving around the pocket.
I graded Buchner as a five-star recruit following his brilliant junior season, during which he passed for 4,474 yards, rushed for 1,610 yards and accounted for 81 total touchdowns. During the summer Buchner displayed a new look throwing motion, and the ball didn’t come out of his hand as accurately, as powerfully or with the same trajectory it did during his junior season.
California canceling the fall season meant we didn’t get a chance to see if he corrected that motion, or if he was able to adapt and thrive with it. That concern dropped Buchner a bit in the rankings, but he’s still the same ultra-skilled, dual-threat talent that initially earned the five-star grade.
RUNNING BACK
Grade: B-
Signees: Audric Estime
This grade is a B- because Notre Dame needs a second back in this class. Should current commit Logan Diggs end up in the class as well - and I'm confident he will - this grade will jump up to a B+.
Flipping Estime was big for the Irish, because at the very least he gives the staff one back in the class, and a back capable of being a workhorse. Estime complements 2020 signee Chris Tyree extremely well, and his running style fits into the Irish zone-based offense extremely well.
Estime also gives the offense a unique skillset that is currently not on the roster, and he's a better version of the player the team lost (Jahmir Smith), which opened up the scholarship for a second back in the first place.
Much will be made about who the staff didn't land at running back (Will Shipley, Donovan Edwards), but if this class ends up with Estime and Diggs you need to put the star-rankings behind and realize that duo gives the Irish depth chart a major boost in talent, depth, size, power and playmaking ability in the backfield.
WIDE RECEIVER
Grade: A-
Signees: Lorenzo Styles Jr., Deion Colzie, Jayden Thomas
Notre Dame needed at least a three-man receiving corps and it needed high-upside players, and that’s what the staff got. Adding to the grade is the complementary nature of the signees. None of the group is an elite player, but there is quality talent across the board, and the unit fits well together.
Pickerington (Ohio) Central star Lorenzo Styles Jr. is my highest graded member of the wideout class. He was always an impressive athlete, but as a senior he showed an extra gear that made him a game-changer as a vertical threat and with the ball in his hands. Styles projects as either a slot or the field position.
Athens (Ga.) Academy big man Deion Colzie might have a case for the highest ceiling of the wideouts. Colzie is a quality athlete for his size and he has a natural feel as a route runner. Being challenged by better players should do him some good, as should work in the ND weight room. If Colzie puts in the work he could develop into an impact player as a boundary receiver.
Atlanta (Pa.) Pace Academy wide receiver Jayden Thomas lacks the size that Colzie brings to the game or the explosiveness we see from Styles. Thomas is a quality all-around athlete that also thrives on the baseball diamond. He needs to prove he can stay healthy, but Thomas is a tough pass catcher, he’s surprisingly good after the catch, he’s a strong blocker and he’s a smart football player.
TIGHT END
Grade: B
Signees: Cane Berrong, Mitchell Evans
Hartwell (Ga.) Hart County tight end Cane Berrong is an interesting recruit, and the wide gap in how he is evaluated by the recruiting services is interesting to say the least. He is ranked as the nation’s No. 44 overall player by SI All-American and No. 49 overall by ESPN, but Rivals and 247Sports rank him as a three-star recruit.
I was in between on Berrong heading into his senior season, but the Georgia native impressed me quite a bit as a senior. His blocking continues to impressive, and his vertical speed got even better. Berrong showed much-improved route running skills, which he combined with top-notch ball skills to be a different maker for Hart County.
Wadsworth (Ohio) High School big man Mitchell Evans is a quality depth player. He’s massive (6-7, 240) and a decent athlete for his size. Notre Dame’s coaches seem to like him more than I do, and if they are right this tight end class will perform much better than my grade, and my grade shows I already think highly of it.
OFFENSIVE LINE
Grade: B+
Signees: Blake Fisher, Rocco Spindler, Caleb Johnson, Joe Alt, Patrick Coogan
Notre Dame needed at least four blockers in this class and it needed tackle bodies, and the Irish checked off both boxes with this five-man class. There is one pure tackle in the class, two tackles that could also thrive inside at guard, and two interior blockers. It was a balanced class from that standpoint.
The one-two punch at the top of this class is as good as any in the class. Avon (Ind.) High School offensive tackle Blake Fisher was so good as a senior that he leaped Buchner as my top graded player. He showed improved conditioning, he reshaped his body a bit and he was absolutely dominant.
Fisher could be a multi-year starter at tackle, and it wouldn’t surprise me if he thrived at that position. It’s not hard to envision a future line that has 2020 signee Tosh Baker manning the left tackle position, Fisher dominating at right tackle, and Notre Dame having the nation’s best tackle tandem, which it had in 2015 and has again in 2020.
I could also see Fisher move inside to guard and becoming a special player there. In fact, a case could be made that guard is where his upside is truly the greatest, but it’s about picking between which position he could be very good at that allows him to get on the field the quickest.
Clarkston (Mich.) High School star Rocco Spindler is another Top 100 caliber player in this line class. Spindler played guard as a junior and thrived at tackle as a senior, but his highest upside is inside. A former wrestler, Spindler has the power and physicality needed to be a force at the point of attack, and he’s athletic enough to be a top-notch blocker on pulls, traps and on the second level.
What keeps this class from being either an A- or A grade is that players three through five aren’t in the same league as the top two, and while there is some upside there, it’s not to the level as past classes like 2019, 2017, 2014 or 2013 in regards to the quality of the depth.
Ocala (Fla.) Trinity Catholic big man Caleb Johnson is my third ranked offensive lineman in the class, and he had an impressive offer list. He’s a physical blocker that lacks the athleticism of other top tackles, but he makes up for it with length and toughness.
The player that holds the key to this class being elite is North Oaks (Minn.) Totino-Grace tight end Joe Alt, who projects to play offensive tackle in college. Alt has a low floor, and we don’t yet know if he can add the necessary weight and strength needed to play tackle in college without losing his athleticism.
The reason I love this signing is that Alt also has a very high floor. If he maintains his foot quickness, agility and balance while getting to 300 pounds adding grown man strength there’s a chance that Alt could become a really darn good college tackle. If that happens this class jumps up to an A grade.
Chicago (Ill.) Marist guard Patrick Coogan is a tough blocker, but his lack of athleticism could relegate him to a depth role for much of his career.
GRADE KEY
A — Elite / College Football Playoff caliber
B — Outstanding / Top 15 caliber
C — Solid / Borderline Top 25 caliber
D — Subpar / Not good enough
F — Disaster
To comment below be sure to sign up for a FREE Disqus account, which you can get HERE.
———————
Become a premium Irish Breakdown member, which grants you access to all of our premium content, our premium message board and gets you a FREE subscription to Sports Illustrated! Click on the link below for more
Be sure to stay locked into Irish Breakdown all the time!
Join the Irish Breakdown community!
Subscribe to the Irish Breakdown podcast on iTunes.
Subscribe to the Irish Breakdown YouTube channel.
Follow me on Twitter: @CoachD178
Follow me on Parler: @BryanDriskell
Like and follow Irish Breakdown on Facebook