Skip to main content

There have been plenty of reports on how high the Pirates' asking price is for Bryan Reynolds, but we're now starting to get a clearer picture of how teams might trade for the outfielder.

MLB Network's Jon Morosi reported Thursday that Pittsburgh is seeking a top starting pitcher in any potential Reynolds deal. Morosi cited Bobby Miller, the Dodgers' No. 2 prospect and 26th-best prospect in baseball per MLB Pipeline, and the Blue Jays' Ricky Tiedemann, Toronto's No. 1 prospect and No. 33 in all of baseball, as attractive trade chips.

It appears any deal involving Reynolds will require a prospect of that magnitude (the top 50) as well as additional pieces. For the Blue Jays, that could mean dishing Tiedemann alongside Orelvis Martinez, their second-best prospect and the 70th-ranked youngster in MLB, for Reynolds, a 27-year-old switch hitter.

Reynolds, who slashed .262/.345/.461 in 2022, is a dream fit for the Blue Jays. On the other hand, Tiedemann's growth from A Ball to Double A in his first minor-league season was remarkable. The left-hander flashed ace stuff in the minors and is trending toward a major-league debut as early as 2023. 

If Toronto is unwilling to engage the Pirates on Reynolds, there are other left-handed outfield options in free agency, such as Dominic Smith or Michael Conforto