Skip to main content
Publish date:

What's Next for the Giants After Nate Solder's Opt-out?

We attempt to answer the pressing questions such as what effect does Nate Solder's opt-out have on the cap, who will be the starting tackles and more.

Giants' offensive tackle Nate Solder's decision to opt-out of the 2020 season comes as little surprise given his and his family's history.

In his statement released on Twitter, Solder, a testicular cancer survivor, announced that after much prayer and reflection, he is opting out of the 2020 season.

Besides being in the High-Risk Player Category himself, Solder's young son Hudson qualifies as a "High-Risk Cohabitant" under the NFLPA's COVID-19 Amendments to the CBA. Hudson Solder has been battling cancer for most of his young life, a battle that includes chemotherapy.

The Solders also welcomed a new baby boy this off-season. Given that young infants take some time to build up their immune systems, the decision was a no-brainer for Solder, a team captain last year, and one of the Giants player reps.

So what's next for the Giants? Here are some questions--and answers--about where they go from here.

Can Solder change his mind?

No. Decisions made to opt-out are irrevocable.

Who starts at left tackle?

This is an easy one: Andrew Thomas. That's why the Giants drafted him fourth overall, to be their future left tackle.

What about at right tackle?

That's not as easy, but the candidates will include veteran Cam Fleming, Nick Gates (who will presumably be working at center, as well), and rookie Matt Peart.


Oct 10, 2021; Arlington, Texas, USA; New York Giants quarterback Mike Glennon (2) throws the ball as Dallas Cowboys outside linebacker Micah Parsons (11) defends in the fourth quarter at AT&T Stadium.

Why the Giants Will Win, Why They Won't, and a Week 13 Prediction

The Giants will try to stack back-to-back wins together for the first time this season.

Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa (1) in action agains the Carolina Panthers during NFL game at Hard Rock Stadium Sunday in Miami Gardens.

New York Giants at Miami Dolphins: Game Info, Odds, Notes, and More

Here's everything you need to know about the New York Giants at Miami Dolphins.

Nov 28, 2021; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; Philadelphia Eagles tight end Dallas Goedert (88) can not secure a pass as New York Giants defensive back Steven Parker (38) defends during the second half at MetLife Stadium.

Giants Add DB Steven Parker to 53-man Roster

New York also elevates two from the practice squad ahead of their Week 13 game against the Miami Dolphins.

Peart is believed to be the long-term answer at right tackle, but the third-round draft pick out of UConn is still a little bit on the raw side (check out Nick Falato's write up of Peart after the Giants drafted him in April for a refresher on what the young man's film showed).

Jan 25, 2020; Mobile, AL, USA; North offensive tackle Matt Peart of Connecticut (65) in the first half of the 2020 Senior Bowl college football game at Ladd-Peebles Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Chuck Cook-USA TODAY Sports

Matt Peart.

Fleming would appear to have the inside track given his experience int he league and, in particular, in the Cowboys offense, whose offensive-minded head coach (Jason Garrett) and offensive line coach (Marc Colombo) are now with the Giants as the offensive coordinator and offensive line coach respectively.

The Giants could roll with Fleming at right tackle, especially if Gates becomes knee-deep in the center competition. If an emergency should arrive where Thomas struggles or can't go at left tackle, Fleming could flip to the other side and, with there likely now going to be a priority on getting Peart up to speed in a hurry, he could step in.

What is the effect on the salary cap?

Solder was due to earn a $9.9 million base salary this year. He also received a $3 million roster bonus earlier this year. 

Assuming he did indeed qualify for the High-Risk opt-out--and there is more than enough evidence based on his history with cancer to suggest he did--the $350,000 stipend he's receiving will not count against his base salary which means the Giants will be credited for Solder's $9.9 million base salary this year. His prorated signing bonus ($6.5 million) will remain on the books this year.

But don't go expecting the Giants to spend any savings like an out-of-control shopper during a post-Thanksgiving sale.

With the 2021 NFL salary cap likely to fall to as low as $175 million, the smart NFL teams will look to roll over whatever money is left to 2021 to help off-set some of the roster decisions they otherwise would have had to make to get under the cap.

According to Over the Cap, the Giants have already committed $170,145,019 toward contracts next year. That doesn't include the saving on Solder, nor the anticipated funds needed to sign edge Markus Golden and kicker Chandler Catanzaro. 

Regardless, that's not a lot of breathing room should the 2021 cap fall to that $175 million floor. And with the Giants having Dalvin Tomlinson's and Leonard Willams' deals coming up plus the need to sign draft picks plus other free agency activity, that's not a lot of breathing room.

Get the latest Giants news by joining the community. Click "Follow" at the top right of Giants Country page. Or sign up to receive our free daily newsletter.