MLB Mock Trade: Diamondbacks Land All-Star Bryce Harper from Phillies
In this story:
Bryce Harper is one of the most valuable players in baseball, combining elite power, on-base ability, and run production with proven consistency in high-pressure situations. His skill set makes him a cornerstone for any lineup, providing not just middle-of-the-order firepower but also leadership and star presence that can elevate an entire roster.
A player of Harper’s caliber can change the trajectory of a team instantly, creating run-scoring opportunities and forcing opposing pitchers to adjust their approach. Any team acquiring him gains a generational talent capable of impacting games, seasons, and playoff outcomes.
Here’s what it would take for the San Francisco Giants to acquire him in a mock trade.
Arizona Diamondbacks - Philadelphia Phillies MLB Mock Trade Details & Fantasy Baseball Impact
Diamondbacks Acquire:
Bryce Harper (1B)
Phillies Acquire:
Ketel Marte (2B)
Jordan Lawlar (SS)
Justin Martinez (RHP)
Bryce Harper was a high‑value fantasy bat in 2025, hitting .261 with 27 home runs, 75 RBI, 12 steals, and a strong walk rate while playing in the middle of a potent lineup. In fantasy, that made him a reliable source of power, runs, and on‑base percentage, especially valuable in OBP and traditional roto formats. If he were traded to Arizona, his value could rise slightly because Chase Field and the NL West tend to be more hitter‑friendly, potentially boosting power and run production. Additionally, being the clear No. 1 bat in the lineup would likely increase RBI opportunities and overall counting stats.
Ketel Marte delivered a balanced and strong season in 2025, hitting .283 with 28 home runs, 72 RBI, 87 runs, and 64 walks. His combination of AVG, power, and runs made him a top‑tier fantasy second baseman. If traded to Philadelphia, his fantasy profile might stay similar or even improve slightly since the Phillies’ lineup generally scores at a high rate, giving him more opportunities for runs and RBI. In many leagues, he would become an even more attractive everyday starter, especially in categories like AVG, OBP, and runs scored.
Jordan Lawlar had a very limited MLB sample in 2025, 28 games with minimal counting stats and a .182 average. In fantasy terms, he had essentially no impact in 2025 and would be considered a deep dynasty or prospect stash rather than an active contributor. If traded to the Phillies and given more playing time in 2026, his fantasy value could grow significantly because his minor‑league track record shows both power and speed potential. But for 2026 drafts, he’d still be an upside bench/prospect pick rather than a core asset until he earns regular at‑bats.
Justin Martínez had a very limited and truncated 2025 due to injury, with a 4.11 ERA and only five saves before undergoing Tommy John surgery. In fantasy, that meant minimal value in 2025 and likely no relevance for early‑season 2026 formats unless he returns from injury late in the year. If traded, his inclusion wouldn’t affect fantasy much unless he comes back healthy and earns late‑innings save chances, but that outcome is uncertain, making him more of a lottery relief piece than a reliable fantasy arm in most formats.
Why The Diamondbacks Make The Trade
If the Arizona Diamondbacks were to trade Ketel Marte along with Jordan Lawlar and Justin Martinez for Bryce Harper in 2026, it would reflect a clear win-now strategy. While Marte offers versatility and balance, Harper provides elite left-handed power, on-base ability, and proven postseason impact, giving Arizona the middle-of-the-order force they need for a championship push.
Beyond on-field production, Harper’s star power could boost ticket sales and the team’s national profile. If the Diamondbacks believe his skill set will age well, taking on his longer contract in exchange for immediate impact makes sense. For Philadelphia, Lawlar and Martinez provide controllable talent and bullpen depth to offset losing their superstar.
Why The Phillies Make The Trade
The Philadelphia Phillies would consider trading Bryce Harper for Ketel Marte, Jordan Lawlar, and Justin Martinez to balance immediate competitiveness with long-term roster control. While Harper is a superstar bat, he carries a massive contract and is approaching his mid-30s, which limits flexibility.
Marte provides a versatile, high-contact presence who can play multiple positions and anchor the lineup, while Lawlar offers a controllable, high-upside infielder, and Martinez strengthens the bullpen.
The package allows Philadelphia to infuse youth and cost-controlled talent into its core while remaining competitive, essentially exchanging a single elite star for multiple assets that can contribute immediately and in future seasons. It’s a classic strategy of converting one expensive superstar into depth, versatility, and long-term upside.
More Fantasy Sports On SI News
Ryan Shea is a seasoned sports enthusiast with a sharp eye for strategy and a deep love for the game—no matter the sport. Whether he’s analyzing roster moves or spotting trends before they hit the headlines, Ryan brings a unique mix of research, instinct, and insider perspective to his writing. With over a decade of experience dominating fantasy leagues, he knows what it takes to build championship-caliber lineups. A diehard fan of all things New York, Ryan proudly reps the Jets, Yankees, Knicks, and Rangers—win or lose.