Spartan Nation Turn On Their QB After Rivalry Game Loss

In this story:
Spartan Nation entered into fury after the Michigan State Spartans underwent their fourth loss of the year, and they used that fury to get fired up for their rivalry game against the Michigan Wolverines.
THE SPARTY IN ME IS FIRED UP
— Travon (@whoistravon_) October 25, 2025
The first possession of the game went to the Spartans, and they had the opportunity to impress the Spartan Nation.
But the patience of fans was already very thin, and when the Spartans' quarterback Aidan Chiles turned the ball over on the first drive of the game, almost all hope had been immediately lost.
Dead inside… @MSU_Football
— Charles🥶🌍 (@TreRamsey2) October 25, 2025
When they had gotten the ball back after the turnover, the refs made themselves known when the drive had been dismantled by a missed pass interference call.
It's obvious that the refs are leaning in favor of Michigan
— 🌆SUMMERTIME-CHI🌆 (@DanDupree11) October 26, 2025
Penalties began racking up against MSU afterwards, attaining a false start, delay of game, illegal contact, and pass interference in quick succession.
By the end of the first quarter, the Spartans were down 10-0, with a looming chance for a blowout, all words for anger were expressed by Spartan Nation.
Once again a terrible coaching game by @MSU_Football @MSU_Battman it’s time to move on from Smith after this game. Team doesn’t look prepared at all
— RC (@Tizzle1105) October 26, 2025
The start of the second quarter lit a spark under the feet of Chiles, and momentum began going the team's way when he was finally able to orchestrate a successful drive and score, making it 7-10.
This, of course, made Spartan fans happy, but as they had been a week before, most needed to see more before they were convinced, especially because of conduct issues and penalties that came from them.
The conduct issues didn't end there either, because the Spartans had already racked up three personal fouls before the half, and it began making fans look at the team in disgust.
Msu scum throwing punches. 3 personal fouls already, can't believe Michigan keeps making them do that since they're always the victim
— Lu of〽️ (@LueOfM) October 26, 2025
Regardless of personal conduct, MSU's defense began to do its job, heating up alongside the offense and getting a good stop so that Chiles could have the ball in his hands again.
Yet another drive was shut down by a missed PI penalty, though, and the refs were under more scrutiny than head coach Jonathan Smith as Chiles failed to score before the half.
Not one, but TWO blatant pass interference calls on Michigan missed by these refs.
— Chad Latz (@LatzChad) October 26, 2025
MSU entered halftime with the game being much closer than many might have expected, down 10-7, yet Spartan Nation was still upset despite the close game.
Do these guys even know how to play football? @MSU_Football Get a 1st down and frantically loose it. Get some discipline!
— DM (@mumziepooh) October 26, 2025
Spartan Nation was upset further when the second half began, as the defense was not prepared for the rushing attack of the Wolverines, and more penalty controversy led to another score.
@FBI be useful and investigate the refs in the @MSU_Football game.
— heroux4 (@_Heroux4) October 26, 2025
Offensive stalls continued to plague the Spartans, with a lack of scores being abundant in the third quarter as the Wolverines tried to run the clock out.
The pee wee football offense is not working @MSU_Football
— Matt in Michigan (@Matt_inMichigan) October 26, 2025
Michigan worked its way into scoring again to go up against MSU 24-7 near the end of the third, and the mountain left to climb for the Chiles-led offense was beginning to become insurmountable.
The climb began in the fourth quarter with a touchdown catch by Nick Marsh, and a failed two-point conversion that confused many.
BRANDON COMIN' THROUGH pic.twitter.com/3hYBLteClU
— Michigan State Football (@MSU_Football) October 26, 2025
Seriously. Whyyyyyy. TERRIBLE.
— Janette Stephens (@janettemsu) October 26, 2025
Momentum built up off of a fumble recovered by MSU, and it died down at the same pace when the offense stalled out, turning the ball back over on downs.
By then, the game was essentially over, and with a final score of 31-20 from a garbage time score apiece, the future of the Spartans was becoming clear. That future is not in Smith's, or especially not Chiles' favor.
@MSU_Football get rid of Aiden Chilles and Johnathan Smith!!!!!
— Jason (@spartan040812) October 26, 2025
Fire Smith. Kick Chiles to the curb. Izzo needs to do it himself.
— LGRW’s (@fakethefunk21) October 26, 2025
bench chiles, put my goat milivojevic in 🐐
— dazzer (@imDazzer) October 26, 2025
Keep up with all our content when you follow the official Spartan Nation page on Facebook, Spartan Nation, WHEN YOU CLICK RIGHT HERE, and be sure to share your thoughts on how Michigan State played against Michigan when you join our community group, Go Green Go White, WHEN YOU CLICK RIGHT HERE.

Nathan Berry is a senior at NCCS and was raised a Michigan State Spartan fan. With a great interest in sports and writing, journalism is a great avenue to pursue both.