Paul Skenes has embarrassing fail at Pat McAfee’s ‘Big Night AHT’ in Pittsburgh

It was an amazing night at Pat McAfee’s “Big Night AHT” in front of over 12,000 screaming fans at the Pittsburgh Penguins arena. It wasn’t so much for Pittsburgh Pirates ace Paul Skenes who had a couple of embarrassing moments as one of the big guests for the show.
The star of “The Pat McAfee Show” and polarizing ESPN personality McAfee brought out some Pittsburgh legends for the show.
Some of the surprise guests at Pat McAfee's sold-out 'Big Night AHT' live show in front of 12,582 fans in Pittsburgh:
— Front Office Sports (@FOS) April 10, 2025
• Ben Roethlisberger
• Sidney Crosby
• Paul Skenes
• Jelly Roll
• Wiz Khalifa
• Shane Gillis
• Jey Uso
• Parker McCollumpic.twitter.com/nifMkygwTr
A lucky fan — who unfortunately turned out to be a Philadelphia Eagles fan to the crowd’s ire — even won $2 million in an unreal moment.
RELATED: Livvy Dunne's dog Roux mesmerized watching 'papa' Paul Skenes pitch from couch
Stars like Penguins’ Sidney Crosby and former Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger helped make the giveaway prize bigger by throwing a football through a giant ring. Unfortunately, the Pirates fireball throwing ace Skenes missed for $1 million.
FOR ONE MILLION DOLLARS
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) April 10, 2025
OH NOOO @Paul_Skenes #BigNightAHT pic.twitter.com/suuTibFPGh
And then a second time for $500K.
RELATED: Livvy Dunne’s sister Julz perfectly roasts LSU gymnast, Paul Skenes in odd glam pic
WE STILL LOVE YOU @Paul_Skenes #BigNightAHT https://t.co/kJpPpxOguQ pic.twitter.com/Hg8OuT40qW
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) April 10, 2025
Well, if it was a baseball no doubt he’d have thrown it through.
It hasn’t been a great week for the 22-year-old Skenes as he got shelled for five runs in his first loss of the season to the St. Louis Cardinals on Tuesday.
Hey, as McAfee said, Pittsburgh fans still love him even if he failed to throw a football throw a ring. He’s also dating LSU gymnast Livvy Dunne, so Skenes will be just fine and is clearly winning at life.


Matt Ryan is a dedicated sports journalist with over 20 years of experience in digital and linear media. After receiving a Masters in Journalism from USC, he’s worked for Fox Sports, NBC Sports, Yahoo Sports, USA Today Sports Media Group, and Bally Sports, while holding various leadership roles along the way.