Jayson Tatum’s Achilles Injury Shakes Up Fantasy Basketball Landscape

Despite trailing 2–1 in the Eastern Conference Semifinals against the New York Knicks, the Boston Celtics entered Game 4 as commanding -300 favorites to advance. Jayson Tatum, the heart and soul of the franchise, came out blazing—scorching the court with a vintage performance that helped the Celtics build an 11-point halftime lead.

Boston seemed to be in full control. They had demolished the Knicks in Game 3 and had held 20-point leads in each of the first three matchups, even if New York rallied to steal the first two on the road. Heading into the second half of Game 4, the Celtics looked poised to tie the series.

But Jalen Brunson had other ideas. Brunson detonated for 18 of his 39 points in a ferocious third quarter, engineering another comeback and giving New York a three-point cushion entering the fourth. What followed was one of the most electric quarters of the entire postseason. Tatum and Brunson went blow-for-blow in a mesmerizing duel of superstar shot-making, each trying to will their team to victory.

Then, everything changed.

Jayson Tatum was helped off the court late in Game 4 after an apparent leg injury on this play. pic.twitter.com/UF8D4mxqlo
— ESPN (@espn) May 13, 2025

After a critical turnover with just minutes left, Tatum suffered a non-contact injury while trying to recover on defense. He crumpled to the floor, clutching his lower leg in obvious agony. It didn’t take long to confirm what fans feared: the injury appeared serious, and he would be sidelined indefinitely. Without their best player, the Celtics faltered late, and the Knicks closed out a 121–113 victory to take a 3–1 series lead.

The loss was gut-wrenching, but Tatum’s injury was a seismic shockwave.

Before exiting, Tatum delivered what might have been his finest game of the postseason: 42 points on 16-of-28 shooting (including 7-of-16 from deep), 8 rebounds, 4 assists, 4 steals, and 2 blocks in 40 minutes of action. It was a masterclass performance—cut short by disaster.

And the long-term prognosis looks grim. Achilles injuries are notoriously difficult to bounce back from, with recovery timelines ranging from nine months to over a year. There’s a real possibility Tatum will miss the entire 2025–26 season, a devastating blow not just for the Celtics but for fantasy basketball managers who have grown accustomed to his first-round production.

Jayson Tatum today underwent successful surgery to repair a ruptured right Achilles tendon. No timetable is currently available for his return, but he is expected to make a full recovery. Further updates will be provided when appropriate. pic.twitter.com/TTXziFtMQB
— Boston Celtics (@celtics) May 13, 2025

Fantasy Basketball Impact Of Jayson Tatum Injury

Tatum finished the fantasy basketball season with the fifth-most fantasy points despite missing 10 games. He trailed only Nikola Jokic, SGA, Giannis, and James Harden.

Though the Celtics are still the defending champs—and the series technically isn’t over—even the most optimistic outlook has Boston facing an uphill climb without its cornerstone. Realistically, Tatum won’t be on fantasy radars unless reports emerge that he’s ahead of schedule. His absence creates a vacuum that will drastically reshape the Celtics’ rotation and the fantasy value of several key players.

Among the biggest risers? Jaylen Brown and Kristaps Porzingis.

Brown, already a top-50 player heading into last season, averaged 22.2 points, 5.8 rebounds, 4.5 assists, and 1.2 steals. With Tatum sidelined, he could easily clear 25 points per game and ascend to second- or third-round status in upcoming fantasy drafts. He finished as the 50th-best player in terms of fantasy points, seven slots behind teammate Derrick White.

Porzingis presents more of a wildcard. He put up solid numbers this season—19.5 points and 6.8 rebounds per game—but suited up for just 42 contests. For Boston to remain competitive, he’ll need to play at least 60 games while significantly upping his production. If he does, expect his draft stock to soar well above his 126 Expert Consensus Ranking (ECR) on FantasyPros.

Meanwhile, the Celtics’ backcourt remains relatively healthy. Derrick White should continue to rack up defensive stats, hit threes, and play a pivotal two-way role. Payton Pritchard could also be asked to carry more of the offensive burden off the bench, especially if Boston goes small more frequently. Pritch produced the 71st-most fantasy points in the NBA despite starting just three games.

Tatum’s injury casts a long shadow—on the court and in the fantasy sphere. While Game 5 at TD Garden will garner plenty of attention, the broader conversation has already shifted toward how this injury will reshape Boston’s future.

It’s a painful end to the season for Tatum, but if anyone can bounce back to superstar form, it’s him. He may carry little fantasy relevance in 2025–26, but he remains a strong candidate to reclaim first-round value in 2026–27. Tatum’s career is far from over—but the Celtics’ dynasty may be hanging in the balance.

Fantasy Basketball Impact Of Jayson Tatum Injury

Recommended Articles