Softball America Catcher Rankings Highlight Elite Talent from OU, Florida, Arizona
With the 2026 regular season rounding out in the next week, Softball America released its final in-season catcher rankings.
The source listed the top 15 backstops at the DI level based on stats, advanced metrics, RPI and general eye test.
The SEC, Big 12, and Big Ten each had three representatives named, followed by one athlete from the ACC, and five others outside of the Power 4.
Additionally, three of the top five catchers recently had their dreams become reality upon receiving AUSL Golden Tickets. Reese Atwood earned the second overall, granting her selection into the 2026 AUSL College Draft, followed by Sydney Stewart with the fourth, and Jocelyn Erickson with the tenth.
Take a look at the top five who suit up in the gear nearly every inning and their supporting numbers. Visit Softball America for the full list.
Top 5 Catchers in College Softball
1. Kendall Wells, Oklahoma, .377 BA, 3 2B, 36 HR, 79 RBI
2. Jocelyn Erickson, Florida, .421 BA, 13 2B, 19 HR, 67 RBI
3. Sydney Stewart, Arizona, .431 BA, 7 2B, 19 HR, 73 RBI
4. Reese Atwood, Texas, .366 BA, 7 2B, 16 HR, 53 RBI
5. Bri Despines, Louisville, .397 BA, 15 2B, 4 3B, 7 HR, 62 RBI, 17 SB
Sydney Stewart leads the Big 12 in OPS and RBI as she rises in our latest catcher rankings.
— Softball America (@SoftbalAmerica) April 27, 2026
Find out who the best backstops are here: https://t.co/Qszi1c9GI1@sydneyyystewart | @ArizonaSoftball pic.twitter.com/1SWzXwht1d
Kendall Wells, Oklahoma Sooners
Kendall Wells is on a complete tear in her rookie campaign, sliding into the top spot, improving from No. 3 in March. She set the SEC single-season home run record on March 31 with her 27th, followed by breaking Sooner legend Jocelyn Alo's and OU's single-season record with her 35th four-bagger on April 24. She currently leads the NCAA in home runs (36), sits in second in RBIs (79) and total bases (168), and is third in slugging (1.113).
Behind the dish, she's committed just one error for a fielding percentage of .996 with 241 putouts and 17 assists. She's also a big reason her Sooners have reclaimed the No. 1 rank.
https://t.co/spATTcanaK pic.twitter.com/b00A3NLN2e
— Oklahoma Softball (@OU_Softball) April 25, 2026
Jocelyn Erickson, Florida Gators
Jocelyn Erickson has continued to put up consistent stats for the Gators since arriving on campus in her sophomore year. The lefty catcher has accomplished a third year with 15+ home runs, currently sitting at number 19. Her .736 slugging percentage, .529 on-base percentage, and 67 RBIs have all been career bests.
Beyond the metrics, Erickson's leadership is immeasurable. She's thrown out two base stealers in just two attempts. Her .993 fielding percentage is compiled of 285 putouts, 17 assists, and a rare pair of errors.
Sydney Stewart, Arizona Wildcats
Sydney Stewart made the vertical jump from No. 4 in March to No. 3 in April. As of today, she leads the Big 12 in various categories: on-base percentage (.584), slugging percentage (1.055), on-base + slugging (1.639), RBI (73), and walks (41).
She's putting up a banner year in her senior campaign with potential for an extended season with her Arizona Wildcats, who finished second in the Big 12 standings, 34-13 (15-6).
Stewart has been part of four double plays and thrown out three on the base paths.
Add us as a preferred source on Google
Maddy Lewis was a four-year starting infielder for UC San Diego Softball (2015–19), helping lead the Tritons to two conference championships, a West Region title, and a trip to the Division II National Championship in her senior season. She graduated from UC San Diego with a degree in Communication, where she also wrote for the student newspaper, The Guardian. After college, Maddy spent two years as a Sports Information Director, working closely with the softball, basketball and running programs, deepening her appreciation for the stories behind the stats. She has continued her playing career on the international stage as a member and captain of the Israeli Women’s National Softball Team for the past four years, facing top talent at European Championships, Canada Cups, and the Maccabi Games. Beyond competing, Maddy remains deeply committed to growing the game. She co-hosts the Jewish Softball: More Than A Game podcast, offers private instruction in the Bay Area and has coached teams at the Triple Crown Sports International Challenge and the JCC Maccabi Games. With a passion for storytelling and softball, she is dedicated to giving back to the sport that has shaped her both on and off the field and making an impact on the next generation in any way she can.
Follow maddoglew