College basketball world reacts to NCAA denying eligibility waiver to Tyon Grant-Foster

In this story:
Over five months after he committed to Gonzaga in the transfer portal, Tyon Grant-Foster had his waiver for another year of eligibility denied by the NCAA on Friday.
Grant-Foster has already filed a lawsuit and has a preliminary injunction hearing in Spokane on Thursday. If granted, the 6'7 wing could get an opportunity to play for the Zags temporarily while his lawsuit is ongoing.
The timing is very significant for Gonzaga, which is just 16 days away from their season opener on Nov. 3 against Texas Southern, and they would really like to know if their projected starting small forward is going to have any chance of playing this season or not. And it's a case that has caught a lot of attention from college basketball fans on social media, who are surprised Grant-Foster was denied a waiver considering the extensive medical issues and other extenuating factors that seemed to give him a clear case for another year.
Grant-Foster began his collegiate career at Indian Hills Community College in 2018-19, spending two years at the junior college level before transferring to Kansas, where he appeared in 22 games during the 2020-21 season.
The 6'7 wing then ended up at DePaul and played the first half of the team's first game before he collapsed at halftime due to a heart condition. He ended up having multiple surgeries and missed the next two seasons before emerging at Grand Canyon ahead of the 2023-24 campaign.
After winning WAC Player of the Year for the 'Lopes, Grant-Foster came back for another year in 2024-25, appearing in 26 games. With the NCAA temporarily changing the rules to allow junior college athletes an extra year, Grant-Foster was expected to have his waiver approved.
However, the NCAA has been stringent on the 'five-year window' rule as of late — although appeals have been granted.
Social media was ablaze after the news came out, with many shocked the NCAA would deny a waiver this late in the offseason — and especially after giving Grant-Foster a practice waiver just a few weeks previously.
Here are some of the best social media reactions to the Grant-Foster news:
Just ridiculous. Grant-Foster missed two seasons at DePaul with a heart issue, while the NCAA shows it has no heart or sense. https://t.co/GnqjZN8kJa
— Jay Bilas (@JayBilas) October 18, 2025
Tyon Grant-Foster’s career so far:
— Ryan Hammer🔨 (@ryanhammer09) October 19, 2025
2018/19: JUCO
2019/20: JUCO
2020/21: 22 games played (Kansas)
2021/22: 1 game, almost died (DePaul)
2022/23: DID NOT PLAY
2023/24: 34 games (GCU)
2024/25: 26 games (GCU)
By their own rules, idk how the NCAA denies Tyon’s eligibility. JUCO is… https://t.co/5bJLWBMP55
The part where I’m confused by the NCAA is why wait until late October to rule on this is the reason is the clock rule? Should’ve just said in April his CBB career was over, would probably have a stronger case in a court. https://t.co/gGWMq7awnd
— Tristan Freeman (@hoopsnut351) October 18, 2025
Ridiculous. Tyon Grant-Foster had a pretty serious heart issue that sidelined him for two seasons. We're letting all these former JUCO guys (like TGF) play and plenty of other players for various reasons. Why not let a guy who had a pretty unique circumstance play? https://t.co/xlfz0m77rl
— Sean Paul (@SeanPaulCBB) October 19, 2025
Denying someone because they played a game before having a heart attack is certainly a choice. https://t.co/0mxFgsZ5Ea
— House of Krause (@hokcbb) October 18, 2025
https://t.co/QCv5kDkAyX pic.twitter.com/Zqc3jr15pP
— Inside The Kennel (@InsideTheKennel) October 19, 2025
If there were an eligibility waiver that should have been a no brainer, it should have been this one. https://t.co/1uTKIQZjOl
— Floor Space Scouting (@FloorSpaceScout) October 18, 2025
Younger than Trevon Knell was last year btw 🙄 https://t.co/cmNPKeIgHB
— Unbiased (@UnbiasedClipFan) October 19, 2025
Ok….given Tyon’s story that’s insane https://t.co/uOWAMeh1dv
— JUCOadvocate - Brandon Goble (@JUCOadvocate) October 18, 2025
Wonder when the lawsuit will be filed. Not sure a federal judge in Spokane would rule against Gonzaga.
— Vince Grippi (@vinceg55) October 18, 2025
I would say it was surprising that the NCAA really ruled that a heart issue requiring surgeries wasn’t a valid reason for a waiver, but it’s the NCAA.
— Connor Hope (@HoopsHopeCBB) October 19, 2025
Gonzaga will play an exhibition game on Sunday, Oct. 19, against NAIA Northwest University. Graham Ike, Braden Huff, Adam Miller, and Braeden Smith are all projected to start for coach Few, and whoever starts alongside them - likely one of Steele Venters, Jalen Warley, or Emmanuel Innocenti - is a strong bet to be starting again in November.
MORE GONZAGA NEWS & ANALYSIS

Andy Patton is a diehard fan and alumnus of Gonzaga, graduating in 2013. He’s been the host of the Locked On Zags podcast covering Gonzaga basketball since 2021, and one of two co-hosts on the Locked On College Basketball podcast since 2022. In addition to covering college basketball, Andy has dabbled in sports writing and podcasting across nearly every major sport dating back to 2017. He was a beat writer covering the Seattle Seahawks from 2017–2021 for USA TODAY, where he also spent one year each covering the USC Trojans and Oregon Ducks, and had a stint as the lead writer for College Sports Wire. Andy has also written about the NBA, NHL, and MLB for various news outlets through TEGNA, including KREM in Spokane, CBS8 in San Diego, and KING 5 in Seattle. After stints in Spokane and Seattle, Andy is back in Oregon near his hometown with his wife, daughter, and dog.
Follow AndyPattonCBB