| | | W 3-2 | 1-0 (0-0) | Non League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | - |
| | | W 3-0 | 2-0 (0-0) | Non League | Magnolia, OH | - | - |
| | | W 3-0 | 3-0 (0-0) | Non League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | - |
| | | W 3-1 | 4-0 (1-0) | League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | - |
| | | | 4-0 (1-0) | League | West Lafayette, OH | - | - |
| | | L 2-3 | 4-1 (1-1) | League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | - |
| | | W 3-0 | 5-1 (1-1) | Non League | Dover, OH | - | - |
| | | L 1-3 | 5-2 (1-2) | League | Zoarville, OH | - | - |
| | | W 3-0 | 6-2 (2-2) | League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | - |
| | | W 3-0 | 7-2 (2-2) | Non League | Steubenville, OH | - | Watch |
| | | L 1-3 | 7-3 (2-3) | League | Berlin, OH | - | - |
| | | W 2-1 | 8-3 (2-3) | Non League | Lore City, OH | - | - |
| | | | 8-3 (2-3) | Non League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | - |
| | | | 8-3 (2-3) | Non League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | - |
| | | W 3-1 | 9-3 (2-3) | Non League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | - |
| | | L 0-3 | 9-4 (2-3) | Non League | Gnadenhutten, OH | - | Watch |