2023 NFL Draft Tracker: Serritella Grades Every Pick
The draft dust has begun to settle but there is no time to rest—as rookies arrive at their new destinations and organizations get set for OTAs. The NFL calendar has turned the page, which means a fresh start for every team. First, we must assess what all went down this past weekend in the “Heart of America.”
Before we start, let’s be clear. The real determination of draft grades can’t truly be assessed for at least five years. Rather, the purpose of these grades is to display which draft classes we liked more than others based on initial reaction. It will help indicate who we ‘think’ did well but inside all 32 NFL war rooms, everyone feels like a winner. Only time will tell.
There was one team who seemed to outclass everyone and that was the Philadelphia Eagles. Big shout out to GM Howie Roseman for earning our only ‘A’ grade. Other franchises who exceeded expectations include the Arizona Cardinals, Baltimore Ravens, Cincinnati Bengals and Seattle Seahawks, all of whom received a ‘B+’ grade. With the exception of the Cardinals, all others mentioned should be viewed as serious Super Bowl contenders. On the opposite end, there were four organizations that earned a ‘C’ designation and made us wonder a bit about their overall direction. They include, the Green Bay Packers, Kansas City Chiefs, New Orleans Saints and Washington Commanders.
Below, every selection of the 2023 NFL Draft has been assigned a grade. Each team has been awarded an overall grade. NFL Draft Bible will continue to roll-out more in-depth recaps, so be sure to check back for more updates. Here are the links for Round 1 and Round 2, in case you missed our instant analysis. Other items of note include our 2024 NFL Draft Big Board and way too early 2024 NFL Mock Draft. Thank you to all the disciples! We are proud to embark upon our 22nd draft cycle in the never-ending search for talent!
ARIZONA CARDINALS
Rd1.No.6. Paris Johnson, OT, Ohio State [A]
Rd2.No.41 BJ Ojulari, OLB, LSU [B]
Rd3.No.72 Garrett Williams, CB, Syracuse [B+]
Rd3.No.94 Michael Wilson, WR, Stanford [C]
Rd4.No.122 Jon Gaines II, OG, UCLA [A]
Rd5.No.139 Clayton Tune, QB, Houston [B+]
Rd5.No.168 Owen Pappoe, LB, Auburn [B]
Rd6.No.180 Kei’Trel Clark, CB, Louisville [B]
Rd6.No213 Dante Stills, DT, West Virginia [C+]
OVERALL = B+
ATLANTA FALCONS
Rd1.No8. Bijan Robinson, RB, Texas [A]
Rd2.No.38 Matthew Bergeron, OL, Syracuse [C]
Rd3.No.75 Zach Harrison, DE, Ohio State [B]
Rd4.No113 Clark Phillips III, CB, Utah [B+]
Rd7.No.224 DeMarcco Hellams, SS, Alabama [C+]
Rd7.No.225 Jovaughn Gwyn, C, South Carolina [B]
OVERALL = B-
BALTIMORE RAVENS
Rd1.No.22 Zay Flowers, WR, Boston College [B+]
Rd3.No.86 Trenton Simpson, LB, Clemson [A]
Rd4.No.124 Tavius Robinson, DE, Ole Miss [C]
Rd5.No.157 Kyu Blu Kelly, CB, Stanford [B+]
Rd6.No.199 Malaesala Aumavae-Laulu, OT, Oregon [D]
Rd7.No.229 Andrew Vorhees, OG, USC [A]
OVERALL = B+
BUFFALO BILLS
Rd1.No.25 Dalton Kincaid, TE, Utah [C+]
Rd2.No.59 O'Cyrus Torrence, OG, Florida [A]
Rd3.No.91 Dorian Williams, LB, Tulane [B]
Rd5.No.150 Justin Shorter, WR, Florida [C-]
Rd7.No.230 Nick Broeker, OG, Ole Miss [B+]
Rd7.No.252 Alex Austin, CB, Oregon State [C]
OVERALL = C+
CAROLINA PANTHERS
Rd1.No1. Bryce Young, QB, Alabama [A]
Rd2.No.39 Panthers – Jonathan Mingo, WR, Ole Miss [B]
Rd3.No.80 Panthers – DJ Johnson, OLB, Oregon [B]
Rd4.No.114 Chandler Zavala, OG, North Carolina State [B+]
Rd5.No.145 Jammie Robinson, FS, Florida State [B]
CHICAGO BEARS
Rd1.No.10 Darnell Wright, OT, Tennessee [A]
Rd2.No.53 Gervon Dexter Sr., DT, Florida [C]
Rd2.No.56 Tyrique Stevenson, CB, Miami [B+]
Rd3.No.64 Zacch Pickens, DT, South Carolina [B]
Rd4.No.115 Roschon Johnson, RB, Texas [C]
Rd4.No.133 Tyler Scott, WR, Cincinnati [C]
Rd5.No.148 Noah Sewell, LB, Oregon [B]
Rd5.No.165 Terell Smith, CB, Minnesota [B+]
Rd7.No.218 Travis Bell, DT, Kennesaw State [D]
Rd7.No.258 Kendall Williamson, DB, Stanford [C+]
OVERALL = C
CINCINNATI BENGALS
Rd1.No.28 Myles Murphy, DE, Clemson [A]
Rd2.No.60 DJ Turner, CB, Michigan [B]
Rd3.No.95 Jordan Battle, FS, Alabama [B+]
Rd4.No.131 Charlie Jones, WR, Purdue [A]
Rd5.No.163 Chase Brown, RB, Illinois [B+]
Rd6.No.206 Andrei Iosivaas, WR, Princeton [B]
Rd6.No.217 Brad Robbins, P, Michigan [B]
Rd7.No.246 DJ Ivey, DB, Miami [C+]
OVERALL = B+
CLEVELAND BROWNS
Rd3.No.74 Cedric Tillman, WR, Tennessee [A]
Rd3.No.98 Siaki Ika, DT, Baylor [B+]
Rd4.No.111 Dawand Jones, OT, Ohio State [A]
Rd4.No.126 Isaiah McGuire, DE, Missouri [C+]
Rd5.No.140 Dorian Thompsoon-Robinson, QB, UCLA [B-]
Rd5.No.142 Cameron Mitchell, CB, Northwestern [D]
Rd6.No.190 Luke Wypler, C, Ohio State [B+]
OVERALL = B
DALLAS COWBOYS
Rd1.No.26 Mazi Smith, DT, Michigan [B]
Rd2.No.58 Luke Schoonmaker, TE, Michigan [C+]
Rd3.No.90 DeMarvion Overshown, LB, Texas [B]
Rd4.No.129 Viliami Fehoko, DE, San Jose State [C]
Rd5.No.169 Asim Richards, OT, North Carolina [C+]
Rd6.No.178 Eric Scott Jr., CB, Southern Miss [B-]
Rd6.No.212 Deuce Vaughn, RB, Kansas State [B+]
Rd7.No.244 Jalen Brooks, WR, South Carolina [D]
OVERALL = C+
DENVER BRONCOS
Rd2.No.63 Marvin Mims, WR, Oklahoma [B]
Rd3.No.67 Drew Sanders, LB, Arkansas [A]
Rd3.No.83 Riley Moss, CB, Iowa [B+]
Rd6.No.183 JL Skinner, FS, Boise State [B]
Rd7.No.257 Alex Forsyth, C, Oregon [C+]
OVERALL = B
DETROIT LIONS
Rd1.No.12 Jahmyr Gibbs, RB, Alabama [B]
Rd1.No.18 Jack Campbell, ILB, Iowa [B]
Rd2.No.34 Sam LaPorta, TE, Iowa [B]
Rd2.No.45 Brian Branch, FS, Alabama [A]
Rd3.No.68 Hendon Hooker, QB, Tennessee [B+]
Rd3.No.96 Brodric Martin, DT, Western Kentucky [C]
Rd5.No.152 Colby Sorsdal, OT, William & Mary [C-]
Rd7.No.220 Antoine Green, WR, North Carolina [D]
OVERALL = B
GREEN BAY PACKERS
Rd1.No.13 Lukas Van Ness, DE, Iowa [B]
Rd2.No.42 Luke Musgrave, TE, Oregon State [B+]
Rd2.No.50 Jayden Reed, WR, Michigan State [B-]
Rd3.No.78 Tucker Kraft, TE, South Dakota State [C+]
Rd4.No.116 Colby Wooden, DT, Auburn [B]
Rd5.No.149 Sean Clifford, QB, Penn State [C]
Rd5.No.159 Dontayvion Wicks, WR, Virginia [C]
Rd6.No.179 Karl Brooks, DT, Bowling Green [B+]
Rd6.No.207 Anders Carlson, K, Auburn [D]
Rd7.No.232 Carrington Valentine, CB, Kentucky [C]
Rd7.No.235 Lew Nichols, RB, Central Michigan [D]
Rd7.No.242 Anthony Johnson, CB, Virginia [C]
Rd7.No.256 Grant DuBose, WR, Charlotte [C+]
OVERALL = C
HOUSTON TEXANS
Rd1.No.2. CJ Stroud, QB, Ohio State [B+]
Rd1.No3. Will Anderson Jr., OLB, Alabama [A]
Rd2.No.62 Juice Scruggs, C, Penn State [C+]
Rd3.No.69 Tank Dell, WR, Houston [B+]
Rd.4No.109 Dylan Horton, DE, TCU [B]
Rd5.No.167 Henry To’oTo’o, LB, Alabama [B]
Rd6.No.201 Jarrett Patterson, C, Notre Dame [C+]
Rd6.No.205 Xavier Hutchinson, WR, Iowa State [B]
Rd7.No.248 Brandon Hill, FS, Pittsburgh [C+]
OVERALL = B
INDIANAPOLIS COLTS
Rd1.No.4. Anthony Richardson, QB, Florida [B]
Rd2.No.44 Julius Brents, CB, Kansas State [B]
Rd3.No.79 Josh Downs, WR, North Carolina [B]
Rd4.No.106 Blake Freeland, OT, BYU [B]
Rd4.No.110 Adetomiwa Adebawore, DT, Colts [B]
Rd5.No.138 Darius Rush, CB, South Carolina [B]
Rd5.No.158 Daniel Scott, SS, California [C+]
Rd5.No.162 Will Mallory, TE, Miami [B]
Rd5.No.176 Evan Hull, RB, Northwestern [C+]
Rd6.No.211 Titus Leo, OLB, Wagner [B+]
Rd7.No.221 Jaylon Jones, CB, Texas A&M [B]
Rd7.No.236 Jake Witt, OT, Northern Michigan [B]
OVERALL = B
JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS
Rd1.No.27 Anton Harrison, OT, Oklahoma [C+]
Rd2.No.61 Brenton Strange, TE, Penn State [C-]
Rd3.No.88 Tank Bigsby, RB, Auburn [C]
Rd4.No.121 Ventrell Miller, LB, Florida [B-]
Rd4.No.130 Tyler Lacy, DE, Oklahoma State [C+]
Rd5.No.136 Yasir Abdullah, LB, Louisville [B]
Rd5.No.160 Antonio Johnson, FS, Texas A&M [A]
Rd6.No.185 Parker Washington, WR, Penn State [C+]
Rd6.No.202 Christian Braswell, CB, Rutgers [B]
Rd6.No.208 Erick Hallett, DB, Pittsburgh [C]
Rd7.No.226 Cooper Hodges, OT, Appalachian State [B]
Rd7.No.227 Raymond Vohasek, DT, North Carolina [C]
Rd7.No.240 Derek Parish, LB, Houston [A]
OVERALL = B-
KANSAS CITY CHIEFS
Rd1.No.31 Felix Anudike-Uzomah, DE, Kansas State [B-]
Rd2.No.55 Rashee Rice, WR, SMU [C]
Rd3.No.92 Wanya Morris, OT, Oklahoma [C]
Rd4.No.119 Chamarri Conner, CB, Virginia Tech [C]
Rd5.No.166 BJ Thompson, OLB, Stephen F. Austin [B+]
Rd6.No.194 Keondre Coburn, DT, Texas [C+]
Rd7.No.250 Nic Jones, CB, Ball State [C-]
OVERALL = C
LAS VEGAS RAIDERS
Rd1.No.7. Tyree Wilson, DE, Texas Tech [B]
Rd2.No.35 Michael Mayer, TE, Notre Dame [A]
Rd3.No.70 Byron Young, DT, Alabama [B]
Rd3.No.100 Tre Tucker, WR, Cincinnati [C+]
Rd.4No.104 Jakorian Bennett, CB, Maryland [B]
Rd4.No.135 Aidan O’Connell, QB, Purdue [B+]
Rd5.No.170 Christopher Smith II, SS, Georgia [B+]
Rd6.No.203 Amari Burney, LB, Florida [B]
Rd7.No.231 Nesta Jade Silvera, DT, Arizona State [C]
OVERALL = B
LOS ANGELES CHARGERS
Rd1.No.21 Quentin Johnston, WR, TCU [C]
Rd2.No.54 Tuli Tuipulotu, DL, USC [B-]
Rd3.No.85 Daiyan Henley, ILB, Washington State [A]
Rd4.No.125 Derius Davis, WR, TCU [D]
Rd5.No.156 Jordan McFadden, OG, Clemson [B]
Rd6.No.200 Scott Matlock, DT, Boise State [A]
Rd7.No.239 Max Duggan, QB, TCU [C]
OVERALL = B-
LOS ANGELES RAMS
Rd2.No.36 Rams – Steve Avila, OL, TCU [C+]
Rd3.No.77 Byron Young, DE, Tennessee [B]
Rd3.No.89 Kobie Turner, DT, Wake Forest [C]
Rd4.No.128 Stetson Bennett, QB, Georgia [B+]
Rd5.No.161 Nick Hampton, OLB, Appalachian State [B-]
Rd5.No.174 Warren McClendon Jr., OG, Georgia [B]
Rd5.No.175 Davis Allen, TE, Clemson [C+]
Rd5.No.177 Puka Nacua, WR, BYU [B-]
Rd6.No.182 Tre’Vius Hodges-Tomlinson, CB, TCU [C+]
Rd6.No.189 Ochaun Mathis, OLB, Nebraska [B-]
Rd6.No.215 Zach Evans, RB, Mississippi [B]
Rd7.No.223 Ethan Evans, P, Wingate [C-]
Rd7.No.234 Jason Taylor II, FS, Oklahoma State [B+]
Rd7.No.259 Desjuan Johnson, DE, Toledo [C+]
OVERALL = C+
MIAMI DOLPHINS
Rd2.No.51 Dolphins – Cam Smith, CB, South Carolina [B]
Rd3.No.84 Devon Achane, RB, Texas A&M [C+]
Rd6.No.197 Elijah Higgins, WR, Stanford [C+]
Rd7.No.238 Ryan Hayes, OT, Michigan [B+]
OVERALL = B-
MINNESOTA VIKINGS
Rd1.No.23 Jordan Addison, WR, USC [B]
Rd3.No.102 Mekhi Blackmon, CB, USC [B]
Rd4.No.134 Jay Ward, CB, LSU [C+]
Rd5.No.141 Jaquelin Roy, DT, LSU [B]
Rd5.No.164 Jaren Hall, QB, BYU [C+]
Rd7.No.222 DeWayne McBride, RB, UAB [C+]
OVERALL = B-
NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS
Rd1.No.17 Christian Gonzalez, CB, Oregon [A]
Rd2.No.46 Keion White, DE, Georgia Tech [B+]
Rd3.No.76 Marte Mapu, LB, Sacramento State [A]
Rd4.No.107 Jake Andrews, OL, Troy [C+]
Rd4.No.112 Chad Ryland, K, Maryland [C]
Rd4.No.117 Sidy Sow, OG, Eastern Michigan [B]
Rd5.No.144 Antonio Mafi, OG, UCLA [B]
Rd6.No.187 Kayshon Boutte, WR, LSU [A]
Rd6.No.192 Bryce Baringer, P, Michigan State [C-]
Rd6.No.210 Demario Douglas, WR, Liberty [D]
Rd6.No.214 Ameer Speed, DB, Michigan State [B+]
Rd7.No.245 Isaiah Bolden, CB, Jackson State [B+]
NEW ORLEANS SAINTS
Rd1.No.29 Bryan Bresee, DT, Clemson [B]
Rd2.No.40 Isaiah Foskey, DE, Notre Dame [B]
Rd3.No.71 Kendre Miller, RB, TCU [C]
Rd.4No.103 Nick Saldiveri, OG, Old Dominion [C-]
Rd4.No.127 Jake Haener, QB, Fresno State [B]
Rd5.No.146 Jordan Howden, FS, Minnesota [D]
Rd6.No.195 AT Perry, WR, Saints [C+]
OVERALL = C
NEW YORK GIANTS
Rd1.No.24 Deonte Banks, CB, Maryland [B]
Rd2.No.57 John Michael-Schmitz, C, Minnesota [B+]
Rd3.No.73 Jalin Hyatt, WR, Tennessee [B]
Rd5No.172 Eric Gray, RB, Oklahoma [C+]
Rd6.No.209 Tre Hawkins, CB, Old Dominion [D]
Rd7.No.243 Jordon Riley, DT, Oregon [C+]
Rd7.No.254 Gervarrius Owens, FS, Houston [C]
OVERALL = C+
NEW YORK JETS
Rd1.No.15 Will McDonald IV, OLB, Iowa State [C+]
Rd2.No.43 Joe Tippman, C, Wisconsin [B]
Rd4.No.120 Carter Warren, OT, Pittsburgh [C+]
Rd5.No.143 Israel Abanikanda, RB, Pittsburgh [C+]
Rd6.No.184 Zaire Barnes, LB, Western Michigan [B]
Rd6.No.204 Jarrick Bernard-Converse, CB, LSU [C]
OVERALL = C+
PHILADELPHIA EAGLES
Rd1.No.9 Jalen Carter, DT, Georgia [A]
Rd1.No.30 Nolan Smith, OLB, Georgia [A]
Rd3.No.65 Tyler Steen, OL, Alabama [B+]
Rd3.No.66 Sydney Brown, SS, Illinois [A]
Rd4.No.105 Kelee Ringo, CB, Georgia [B+]
Rd6.No.188 Tanner McKee, QB, Stanford [C]
Rd7.No.249 Moro Ojomo, DT, Texas [B]
OVERALL = A
PITTSBURGH STEELERS
Rd1.No.14 Broderick Jones, OT, Georgia [A]
Rd2.No.32 Joey Porter Jr., CB, Penn State [A]
Rd2.No.49 Keeanu Benton, DT, Wisconsin [B]
Rd3.No.93 Darnell Washington, TE, Georgia [B+]
Rd4.No.132 Nick Herbig, OLB, Wisconsin [C+]
Rd7.No.241 Cory Trice Jr., CB, Purdue [B]
Rd7.No.251 Spencer Anderson, OG, Maryland [C]
OVERALL = B
SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS
Rd3.No.87 SS Ji’Ayir Brown, SS, Penn State [B+]
Rd3.No.99 Jake Moody, K, Michigan [C]
Rd3.No.101 Cameron Latu, TE, Alabama [C]
Rd5.No.155 Darrell Luter Jr., WR, South Alabama [C]
Rd5.No.173 Robert Beal Jr., OLB, Georgia [C]
Rd6.No.216 Dee Winters, LB, TCU [C]
Rd7.No.247 Brayden Willis, TE, Oklahoma [C]
Rd7.No.253 Ronnie Bell, WR, Michigan [B]
Rd7.No.255 Jalen Graham, LB, Purdue [C]
OVERALL = C
SEATTLE SEAHAWKS
Rd1.No.5. Devon Witherspoon, CB, Illinois [A]
Rd1.No.20 Jaxson Smith-Njigba, WR, Ohio State [A]
Rd2.No.37 Derick Hall, OLB, Auburn [B]
Rd2.No.52 Zach Charbonnet, RB, UCLA [B]
Rd.4No.108 Anthony Bradford, OG, LSU [B]
Rd4.No.123 Cameron Young, DT, Mississippi State [B]
Rd5.No.151 Mike Morris, DE, Michigan [B+]
Rd5.No.154 Olu Oluwatimi, C, Michigan [B+]
Rd6.No.198 Jerrick Reed II, SS, New Mexico [C-]
Rd7.No.237 Kenny McIntosh, RB, Georgia [B]
OVERALL = B+
TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS
Rd1.No.19 Calijah Kancey, DT, Pittsburgh [A]
Rd2.No.48 Cody Mauch, OG, North Dakota State [B+]
Rd3.No.82 YaYa Diaby, DE, Louisville [B]
Rd5.No.153 Dennis SirVocea, LB, Pittsburgh [C]
Rd5.No.171 Payne Durham, TE, Purdue [B+]
Rd6.No.181 Josh Hayes, DB, Kansas State [D]
Rd6.N0.191 Trey Palmer, WR, Nebraska [B]
Rd6.No.196 Jose Ramirez, DE, Eastern Michigan [B]
OVERALL = B
TENNESSEE TITANS
Rd1.No.11 Peter Skoronski, OT, Northwestern [A]
Rd2.No.33 Will Levis, QB, Kentucky [C]
Rd3.No.81 Tyjae Spears, RB, Tulane [B]
Rd5.No.147 Josh Whyle, TE, Cincinnati [C+]
Rd6.No.186 Jaelyn Duncan, OT, Maryland [B]
Rd7.No.228 Colton Dowell, WR, Tennessee-Martin [C]
OVERALL = C+
WASHINGTON COMMANDERS
Rd1.No.16 Emmanuel Forbes, CB, Mississippi State [B+]
Rd2.No.47 Jartavius Martin, CB, Illinois [C+]
Rd3.No.97 Ricky Stromberg, C, Arkansas [C]
Rd4.No.118 Braeden Daniels, OG, Utah [C]
Rd5.No.137 KJ Henry, DE, Clemson [C+]
Rd6.No.193 Chris Rodriguez Jr., RB, Kentucky [C]
Rd7.No.233 Andre Jones Jr., DE, Louisiana [C]
OVERALL = C
*Follow us @NFLDraftBible for year-round coverage of the 2024 NFL Draft nd beyond!
