1969 Topps Mickey Mantle "White Letter" Variation: A Must-Have Card
In this story:
RELATED: Cal Raleigh Ties Mickey Mantle, Gets Topps NOW Card
When it comes to Mickey Mantle collectibles, and especially his trading cards, there's always been a debate over which cards are considered the best-of-the-best. While the hobby universally crowns the 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle as his most iconic card, ranking the others in any particular order is much harder than it seems. Deciding which Mantle cards deserve top billing often ignites passionate arguments, heated debates, and a deep reflection on which characteristics matter the most.
RELATED: The Five Essential Baseball Cards of Mickey Mantle
RELATED: The Truth About the Iconic 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle Baseball Card
Within the confines of those conversations collectors find themselves asking a number of initial questions such as whether or not it’s better to be focused on collecting condition-centric rarities like the ever-so-fragile Stahl-Meyer Mantles of mid-1950s lore or the super scarce 1961 Topps Dice Game issues.
Although both of those particular Mantle cards have their supporters as well as their naysayers, there's a third card (and third pool of collectors) that say his 1969 Topps "White Letters" variation should be in the Top 5 or in the very least the Top 10.
The 1969 Topps card was Mantle’s last and final base card during his playing days and its release encapsulates his entire career, displaying his full statistical line for fans to reflect upon. In addition to providing collectors with an anthology of his career statistics, there also lies a unique twist that elevates this particular card’s unique importance.
Known as the “White Letter” variation, it replaced Mantle’s last name which was commonly displayed in yellow with that of a striking white font. Produced in far smaller quantities than the yellow counterpart, it instantly and unknowingly transformed a widely owned card into one of the most coveted chase cards of the late 1960’s.
From a value perspective, the raw version of the "White Letter" variation generally sells in a range of $775-$850 whereas its graded counterparts offer collectors more significant values. According to PSA, there is only 1 PSA 10, 4 PSA 9s, 46 PSA 8s and just109 PSA 7s. Although there are no recorded sales of the PSA 10, there's a good chance it could fetch well into the seven figures especially since the PSA 9s have sold as high as $933K, PSA 8s have sold as high as $74K, and PSA 7s have sold as high as $6,900.
The mystery behind the lettering variation fuels its legend and allows collectors to go on to ask two very important questions, which are: "Was simply a print oversight by Topps?" or "Was it an intentional design flaw aimed at stirring collector demand?". Although there are some experts who speculate that it was a clever marketing move by Topps, others contend that it was an unintentional production error. Either way, such a variation feels fitting for a someone whose career was larger than life.
By embodying nostalgia, scarcity, and the grandeur of a player who defined one of the greatest eras in professional baseball, collectors often describe the 1969 "White Letter" Mantle as the “walk-off home run” of his career from that of a collector’s perspective. While countless Mantle cards possess their own reasons as to why they deserve a place on any “Top 10” Mantle list, this one boasts both limited accessibility and genuine scarcity while remaining a critical reminder as to why Mickey Mantle was a legend in so many ways.
Passionate sports card collector and writer based in Queens, NY. Lifelong fan of the New York Mets, Jets, and Rangers. Covering sports cards and collectibles with deep industry knowledge and enthusiasm, while bringing a fresh perspective to the ever-evolving hobby world on http://SI.com/collectibles.
Follow MJSchilling