Arizona Football Talk: Honest Evaluation of Noah Fifita
In this story:
Welcome! To another edition of the Arizona Wildcats Insiders Podcast featuring your host Troy Hutchison, who will be delivering a daily podcast discussing everything happening surrounding Arizona athletics, giving you an inside look at all the programs on campus.
Hutchison has been covering Arizona for the last seven years, with his coverage spanning all across UA’s campus from football and men’s basketball to Title IX sports. Plus, with so many former Wildcats playing at the next level in their prospective sports there will be moments where he will take a deep dive into the Cats excelling outside of Tucson.
Coming into the game, Arizona (3-1, 0-1 Big 12) felt like it had momentum with an impressive start to the season and getting healthy during the bye week. However, on the first drive of the game, the Wildcats marched down the field looking for points but missed a 46-yard field goal by kicker Michael Salgado-Medina, which seemed to set the tone of the game against No. 14 Iowa State.
Arizona found itself in an early 22-0 hole against Iowa State due to missed opportunities, sloppy play, and unforced errors. The Wildcats would score right before half, making it a 15-point game.
Still, the Wildcats fell 39-14 against Iowa State as the early errors and slow start to the second half proved to be too much for Arizona to overcome.
Arizona’s defense had been one of the better units nationally coming into the game, holding opponents to 8.7 PPG, which was tied for sixth in college football. But the Wildcats’ defense clearly hit a bump in the road against the Cyclones.
In the first three games of the season, Arizona had done a good job of eliminating explosive plays, with the only one that really stood out being the 75-yard touchdown run by KSU.
Through the first three quarters against Iowa State, the Wildcats allowed SIX explosive plays, with all of them coming through the air against Arizona’s secondary.
Iowa State quarterback Rocco Becht was able to go 14 of 20 passing for 243 yards, with most of his yardage coming on those six plays.
Now, although Becht was able to get the job done through the air, he did most of his scoring damage on the ground, scoring on the 1-yard line against the Wildcats’ defense three times.
Meanwhile, Arizona couldn’t get off the field when it needed it most as Iowa State went 6 of 12 on third down conversion. Plus, the Wildcats allowed the Cyclones to go 2-for-2 on fourth down conversions.
Everything seemed to spiral out of control for Arizona, which, unlike the Cyclones, struggled on third downs, going an underwhelming 4 of 13 for the game.
When looking at the stats, Arizona was able to move the ball and put up yardage against the Cyclones’ defense. However, the Wildcats’ struggles on third and fourth down plays caused Seth Doege’s unit to come up empty in critical situations.
Despite Arizona being able to come up with a turnover in the fourth quarter, the Wildcats came up empty again late in the game with an interception thrown by Fifita in the red zone to seal the deal.
Arizona is clearly a better team than last season, but the Wildcats put together another poor road performance in the Brent Brennan era and now have lost 4-straight road games in blowout fashion, dating back to last season.
Now, with the game behind Arizona, we at Arizona Wildcats On SI have broken down the quarterback position and handed out a grade for Noah Fifita’s performance against Iowa State.
Fifita’s Stat Line
Against the Cyclones, Fifita threw the ball more than he had all season, going 32 of 48 while totaling 253 yards to go along with his two touchdown passes and two interceptions. It was his first turnovers of the season.
Grade: C-
When Fifita first became the starting quarterback of Arizona back during the 2023 season, he was one of the most accurate passers in the nation, completing 72% of his passing attempts. Then, he struggled under Dino Babers and saw his completion percentage drop to 61% in 2024.
Although he has seen improvements under Doege, Fifita is completing a career low 59% of his attempts coming into the Iowa State game. However, following the loss, he is up 62% on 126 passes.
Still, even on some completions, Fifita has thrown behind his receivers causing them to slow down and resulting in a short pick up instead of an explosive play.
If Arizona’s offense is going to take the next step, Fifita needs to start putting the ball on the money so his playmakers can make explosive gains.
Pleas be sure to share your thoughts on the performance of Noah Fifita against ISU. To do so, follow us on our X account by clicking on the link.
Troy Hutchison grew up attending Arizona athletic events, which gave him a unique perspective and knowledge of the athletic department's rich history. He attended UA and began covering the Wildcats in 2018. As the Arizona Wildcats Beat Writer on SI, he is set to deliver wall-to-wall coverage to give fans an in-depth perspective.
Follow THutch1995