Between The Eers: Predicting West Virginia's Ceiling and Floor in 2025

In this story:
Can West Virginia truly contend for a Big 12 title in year one under Rich Rodriguez? If so, it's going to take a whole lot of luck and excellent play in all three phases of the game.
Last week on Between The Eers, Eugene Napoleon and I gave our game-by-game predictions. I went with 7-5; Gene says 9-3. On today's episode, I go into the schedule a little further, predicting what the ceiling and floor for West Virginia is this season.
Ceiling: 8-4
I almost said 7-5, which is what I predicted, but there are a few games that I view as coin flips, and if one more goes West Virginia's way than I expect, I can see 8-4 happening. For example, if Texas Tech swung and missed on a bunch of those defensive guys in the portal and ends up being the same Texas Tech we're all accustomed to, that could go in WVU's favor. 9-3 or better is possible, but I just have a difficult time finding a path beyond eight wins.
Floor: 4-8
In an ideal world, 6-6 is the floor. But this is the reality. There are well over 70+ newcomers on the roster, and with the schedule, it could be a recipe for disaster. Well, maybe not a disaster, that may be a bit harsh, especially for year one. But this schedule is not one you'd like to have with this much of a roster turnover. If WVU stumbles out of the gate and enters Big 12 play with one or two losses, it could spiral downhill.
Recent Between The Eers episodes:
Reacting to the Jimmori Robinson court ruling
WVU Trolls Pitt Fans for Staying Home for Backyard Brawl
Game-by-Game Predictions for WVU Football in 2025
Will West Virginia Be This Year's Biggest Surprise in College Football?
Is There a Legit Five-Man QB Battle at WVU?
Football season show schedule:
Between The Eers: Sundays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays
The Walk Thru GameDay Show: Thursdays
Mountaineer Postgame: Immediately after the game
MORE STORIES FROM WEST VIRGINIA ON SI
Nicco Marchiol’s Season Could Go Two Ways — Here Are the Stat Projections
One Week Away: Final WVU Offensive Depth Chart Projection for 2025
Kirk Herbstreit Picks Rich Rodriguez as Top Hire Over Bill Belichick and Others
Wren Baker Admits He Was 'Frustrated' With WVU Football's Student Section Attendance
WVU Still Has No Clue if Jimmori Robinson Can Play This Season

Schuyler Callihan is the publisher of West Virginia On SI and has been a trusted source covering the Mountaineers since 2016. He is the host of Between The Eers, The Walk Thru Game Day Show, and In the Gun Podcast. The Wheeling, WV native moved to Charlotte, North Carolina in 2020 to cover the Charlotte Hornets and Carolina Panthers.
Follow Callihan_