Updated post-Week 6 ESPN college football rankings leave fans in disbelief

In this story:
Another week of college football, another week of juggling numbers, and another week of ESPN's computers causing fans to shake their heads, question their sanity, or just log off the Internet. ESPN's FPI figures, which are statistically driven, seemingly cause a weekly meltdown among many college football backers. Here's the fallout from the Post-Week 6 FPI release.
Texas and Miami
The two biggest issues most fans see with this week's FPI are at spots 8 and 9. Texas, fresh off two losses, is still ranked No. 8, while 5-0 Miami is below them at 9th. Of course, in a more direct route, Miami bested Florida comfortably, while Texas just lost to the same Gator team. From outraged Hurricane fans to fans recognizing that at this point, Texas might be struggling to lay claim to No. 8 in the SEC is quite a thing.
Texas above Miami 🤣🤣 I knew three year olds that could develop better “analytics” than ESPN
— Travis Bowen (@T_Bowen10) October 5, 2025
All I know is Texas can’t beat anyone with a pulse. Does that mean they’re ranked 8th in whatever FPI is?
— LNK J (@CHuskerJ) October 5, 2025
Miami beat Florida State, who beat Florida, who beat Texas, but somehow Texas is better than Miami? I’d love to hear why that it
— #11 WhoDatRaider🌵🏴☠️ (@7BS_is_here) October 5, 2025
Notre Dame?
Another common complaint, which aligns again with Miami fans, is that 3-2 Notre Dame is No. 5, despite losing to No.9 Miami and No. 13 Texas A&M, neither of which have lost a game. Once again, the maths, as they say, aren't mathing.
If only Miami and A&M could play ND and settle it on the field…
— Dr. Emil Schaffhausen (@XrayDFS) October 5, 2025
While it’s good seein’ Tennessee at 11…a 2-loss Notre Dame at 5? 2-loss Texas at 8 ahead of Miami? USC at 10? Come on! Gotta love the FPI rankings…mission accomplished by ESPN on getting people to talk about this stuff!!! https://t.co/lNPz4gn8Kf
— Bob Baskerville (@TheHoundBB) October 5, 2025
There's no lack of other consistency issues across the FPI rankings. The handling off the lower half of the Big Ten, the continued absence of undefeated Georgia Tech from the FPI, and plenty more head-shakers.
Duke like 25 spots ahead of Tulane? I guess head to head means nothing. Makes perfect sense!
— Bill Ryan (@BillRyan58) October 5, 2025
GT is 5-0 and nowhere to be seen?
— glen manry (@GlenandJuice66) October 5, 2025
Illinois should be where Penn State is and Penn State shouldn’t be on this list.
— dissident 812 (@genXdude812) October 5, 2025
But as usual, the best analysis is probably the widest and most direct.
— O.B. #Dademade (@OB808) October 5, 2025
— 🪶🪶 (@leoisthename33) October 5, 2025

Joe is a journalist and writer who covers college and professional sports. He has written or co-written over a dozen sports books, including several regional best sellers. His last book, A Fine Team Man, is about Jackie Robinson and the lives he changed. Joe has been a guest on MLB Network, the Paul Finebaum show and numerous other television and radio shows. He has been inside MLB dugouts, covered bowl games and conference tournaments with Saturday Down South and still loves telling the stories of sports past and present.