Skip to main content

Should The Guardians Have Gone With Bieber? Aaron Civale Pulled In First Inning Of Game Five Of ALDS

New York takes early lead over Cleveland in American League Division Series game five.

Cerinatly not the start that everyone wanted from Aaron Civale

He started off the game with a walk followed by a strike out of Aaron Judge. Then two more batted balls followed by a home run from Giancarlo Stanton left it a 3-to-0 ballgame. 

Before you could even blink Terry Francona was walking out to the mound and signaling for the bullpen.

 Civale didn't have any command of the plate in this one. 

New York has seen Civale two times before this meet-up. Including the runs they scored in game five, the Yankees have now tagged him for 13 runs in 9.1 innings of work. 

A lot of people may look at this game and ask why Shane Bieber didn't start. Obviously, hindsight is twenty-twenty and that probably wouldn't have been a bad idea looking at how the first inning went.

Starting a pitcher who is on full rest, versus a pitched three days ago may seem like a good option. But this is an elimination game, you need to go with your ace. 

In this case, that's Bieber. 

Now, it's up to the bullpen at this point to carry it home for the Guardians. 

-----

Read More:

Yankees Force Game Five In ALDS With Win Over Guardians

WATCH: Josh Naylor Goes Deep Off Of Cole To Cut Into Yankees Lead

ALDS Game Four Live Updates And Highlights: Cleveland Guardians Vs. New York Yankees

Guardians Release Lineup Ahead Of ALDS Game Four Vs. Yankees

What The Guardians Need To Do In ALDS Game Four To Beat Yankees

-----

Be sure to stay locked into Cleveland Baseball Insider all the time!

SUBSCRIBE to the CBI YouTube channel

Follow Cleveland Baseball Insider on Twitter: @CBI_FanNation