Social Media Reacts to BYU's Double Overtime Thriller Against Arizona

The Cardiac Cougs are back for a second consecutive season. On Saturday night, no. 18 BYU overcame a double-digit deficit in the fourth quarter to beat the Arizona Wildcats. At one point in the fourth quarter, ESPN analytics gave the Cougars just a 7% chance to win.
Social media exploded in the fourth quarter as BYU made the improbable comeback. In this article, we will recap some of the best social media reactions.
The Cardiac Cougs
Last season, BYU had a reputation for winning close games. Apparently, the Cougars refuse to let that reputation go away. There were multiple accounts that have started to take note of BYU's ability to win so many close games.
BYU wins a thriller in double OT against Arizona to stay undefeated.
β WestCoastCFB (@WestCoastCFB) October 12, 2025
The Cougars are so good at finding ways to win week after week.
pic.twitter.com/aAMIr6d4FM
BYU's brand of football in the past few seasons has inspired this particular block of copypasta that proliferates in the post-game discussionπ pic.twitter.com/Z9ioBz09dx
β RedditCFB (@RedditCFB) October 12, 2025
Former BYU great Austin Collie even took the opportunity to bring out his infamous quote from 2008: magic happens.
β Austin Collie (@AKCollie_17) October 12, 2025
Talk about RESILIENCE from @BYUfootball. When the play had to be made, they made the play. So many players stepped up in the biggest moments. Such a memorable win. Congrats boys!
β Mitchell Juergens (@mitchell_juergs) October 12, 2025
Wow what a comeback win for BYU to remain unbeaten!
β College Football Zone (@CollegeFBonX) October 12, 2025
Heartbreaking loss for Arizona but regardless the Wildcats are much improved from a year ago and played a great game!
INSANE BYU Comeback Win in 2 OT; Cougars Have Nine Lives https://t.co/2qGDCfpzKH
β John Kurtz (@jlkurtz) October 12, 2025
Bear Bachmeier is Becoming a Name
Bear Bachmeier is starting to became a national name in college football. BYU turned to the true freshman down the stretch and he delivered, scoring BYU's final two touchdowns on the ground.
PFF analyst Dalton Wasserman believes Bachmeier has the "it" factor, Wasserman just used a slightly different description for the true freshman.
Bear Bachmeier absolutely has the onions
β Dalton Wasserman (@PFF_Dalton) October 12, 2025
Liam Blutman joked that Bachmeier is the best thing to happen to BYU since Jimmer Fredette.
Bear Bachmeier is the best thing to happen to BYU since Jimmer
β Liam Blutman (@Blutman27) October 12, 2025
BEAR. BACHMEIER. SIX.
β BYU FOOTBALL (@BYUfootball) October 12, 2025
πΊ ESPN2 pic.twitter.com/mhSIszakNW
BEAR BACHMEIER TOUCHDOWN!!
β College Football Zone (@CollegeFBonX) October 12, 2025
BYU sends it to overtime! @BYUfootball pic.twitter.com/NlICPUEbeH
BYU TIES IT LATE π pic.twitter.com/cz88DrPQPv
β FOX College Football (@CFBONFOX) October 12, 2025
One viewer noticed Bachmeier signaling to the sideline to go for two after BYU scored the late touchdown that sent the game to overtime. Sitake overruled the true freshman.
Sitake vetoed it, but Bachmeier telling the sideline he wanted to go for 2 is some serious gunslinger mentality for a true freshman. I like the cut of his jib.
β Gamblin' Gauchos ποΈ (@GamblinGauchos) October 12, 2025
Few Undefeated Teams Remain
Only a few undefeated teams remain in college football. In fact, BYU is 6-0 in consecutive seasons for the first time in program history. 10 teams in college football and 11 teams are undefeated (Miami is 5-0).
10 BOWL ELIGIBLE (and undefeated) TEAMS
β Brandon Marcello (@bmarcello) October 12, 2025
BYU, Georgia Tech, Indiana, Navy, Memphis, Ohio State, Ole Miss, Texas A&M, Texas Tech, UNLV
Player Reactions
A few BYU players went to social media after the game to celebrate the win. BYU cornerback Therrian Alexander III joked that it was time to eat and sleep in preparation for church tomorrow.
THANK YOU COUG NATION! EAT , SLEEP , AND CHURCH TMW!πππΎππΎ
β β one of one β (@therriannn) October 12, 2025
BYU safety Raider Damuni played along with the Cardiac Cougs moniker. Damuni left the game in the first half with an injury and he was missed. The BYU run defense wasn't as stout with Damuni in the lineup. His status for next week's game against rival Utah is unknown.
HOW BOUT THEM CARDIAC COUGS!!? LOVE YOU COUGAR NATION π€πΎπ
β Raider Damuni π«π― (@raiderdamuni) October 12, 2025
More BYU Football Coverage
feed
