West Virginia’s Tournament Fate Is Surprisingly Alive — Here’s How

In this story:
Look, I'm not here to predict that West Virginia will win enough games to get to the NCAA Tournament, nor am I going to tell you that you should feel good about the odds of that happening. What I am here to say is there's still a chance, and no, I'm not talking about the Big 12 Conference tournament.
An at-large bid is still very much in play for the Mountaineers, although a lot has to go right. How is that so? Well, simply due to playing in the Big 12 Conference.
The remanning schedule w/NET Ranking
at No. 77 Cincinnati (Quad 2)
vs. No. 19 Texas Tech (Quad 1)
at No. 37 UCF (Quad 1)
vs. No. 115 Utah (Quad 3)
at No. 54 TCU (Quad 1)
at No. 67 Oklahoma State (Quad 1)
vs. No. 15 BYU (Quad 1)
at No. 93 Kansas State (Quad 2)
vs. No. 37 UCF (Quad 2)
Q1 games: Five
Q2 games: Three
Q3 games: One
What HAS to happen for West Virginia

Let's start with the obvious. They HAVE to beat Utah AND win at least two of the three Q2 games. The reason I say two of the Q2 games is that if they were to lose one of Cincinnati/Kansas State, beating UCF at home would make up for it. Going 2-0 and losing to UCF isn't the end of the world because the Knights are likely a tournament team, and who knows? That could be a Q1 game at the end of the year, depending on how they play.
Going 3-1 (at worst) puts WVU at 17-9 (8-5). Now, let's go to the Q1 games. In my opinion, beating Texas Tech is probably more likely than taking down BYU, but if I'm being honest, I'm not sure I see either happening.
Should they drop those two, then they'll need to beat UCF, TCU, and Oklahoma State on the road just to be on the bubble at 20-11 (11-7). If you ask me, winning 11 games and being four games over .500 in the best conference in basketball should be enough to get you in. The analytics probably disagree.
Let's get crazy for a second
Say West Virginia beats Texas Tech, goes 3-1 in Q2/Q3 games (doesn't lose to Utah), loses to BYU, beats UCF on the road, and splits the TCU/Oklahoma State road trip. That also puts the Mountaineers at 20-11 (11-7), but with a huge quality win over Texas Tech and another win over another likely NCAAT team in UCF. Is that enough? I would have to think so, but then again, it is the selection committee we're talking about.
MORE STORIES FROM WEST VIRGINIA ON SI
The No. 3 Player in 2027 and WVU Are More Connected Than Most Realize
MAILBAG: Wasted Time, Tournament Path, 2026-27 Roster, Good News + More
Bob Huggins Makes His Stance Clear on Ross Hodge, the Future of WVU Basketball
Help Is on the Way! Two West Virginia Signees Named McDonald's All-American Nominees
Stock Up, Stock Down: A Theme Developing, Offensive Efficiency + More

Schuyler Callihan is the publisher of West Virginia On SI and has been a trusted source covering the Mountaineers since 2016. He is the host of Between The Eers, The Walk Thru Game Day Show, and In the Gun Podcast. The Wheeling, WV native moved to Charlotte, North Carolina in 2020 to cover the Charlotte Hornets and Carolina Panthers.
Follow Callihan_